News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Catastrophic Risk of AI by og_kalu on Thursday June 01, 2023 @01:15PM (#36154258)
>Actual tasks I need humans to do today: - performing a medical exam on my dad to see if he needs vascular surgery

  - cleaning my bathroom

  - writing a performance review for a software engineer
 
 - investigating a react codebase that uses redux in some places and not others to determine a strategy for better state management
 
 - driving my daughter to the gym after school

These are tasks bottlenecked by embodiment not intelligence

Personalized robot assistance - https://tidybot.cs.princeton.edu/

Software development - https://ai.googleblog.com/2023/05/large-sequence-models-for-...

Re:On the Catastrophic Risk of AI by gensym on Thursday June 01, 2023 @03:00PM (#36155771)
Why do you think embodiment isn't intelligence?

I'm genuinely curious (i.e., this isn't a rhetorical question) because that seems to be a common assumption among folks who talk about intelligence, and I honestly don't understand it.

For example, I enjoy rock-climbing as a hobby. Doing it involves literally learning new patterns of movement. That's part of what makes it fun. I don't understand why that isn't considered intelligence, while learning the steps to, say, invert a matrix is.

Re:On the Catastrophic Risk of AI by og_kalu on Thursday June 01, 2023 @04:20PM (#36156811)
>For example, I enjoy rock-climbing as a hobby. Doing it involves literally learning new patterns of movement.

Sure but does your ability to learn new patterns of movement have much to do with having the hands to climb ? Do you think an amputated person would be less intelligent than you because he could not climb the same rocks ?

Would a blind man be less intelligent than you because he couldn't drive ?

You can't go and ask GPT-4 to go clean your room right now.

But is it because it's not intelligent enough to understand what it means to tidy up your room and go about doing that ? Or is the default inability to see and touch the real issue ?

Many papers/demonstrations including what I linked point overwhelmingly to the latter.