Re:On the Catastrophic Risk of AI
by og_kalu on Thursday June 01, 2023 @04:20PM
(#36156811)
>For example, I enjoy rock-climbing as a hobby. Doing it involves literally learning new patterns of movement.
Sure but does your ability to learn new patterns of movement have much to do with having the hands to climb ? Do you think an amputated person would be less intelligent than you because he could not climb the same rocks ?
Would a blind man be less intelligent than you because he couldn't drive ?
You can't go and ask GPT-4 to go clean your room right now.
But is it because it's not intelligent enough to understand what it means to tidy up your room and go about doing that ? Or is the default inability to see and touch the real issue ?
Many papers/demonstrations including what I linked point overwhelmingly to the latter.
Sure but does your ability to learn new patterns of movement have much to do with having the hands to climb ? Do you think an amputated person would be less intelligent than you because he could not climb the same rocks ?
Would a blind man be less intelligent than you because he couldn't drive ?
You can't go and ask GPT-4 to go clean your room right now.
But is it because it's not intelligent enough to understand what it means to tidy up your room and go about doing that ? Or is the default inability to see and touch the real issue ?
Many papers/demonstrations including what I linked point overwhelmingly to the latter.