Re:South Australia passes law to ban “disruptive” protests
by csdvrx on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:47AM
(#36136010)
> Your freedom to be an imbecile takes away my freedom of living in an imbecile-free society.
Unfortunately for you, this "freedom of living in an imbecile-free society" does not grant you or the government to decide which opinions (as forms of speech) are "imbecile", and to limit their spread through censorship.
Re:South Australia passes law to ban “disruptive” protests
by surgical_fire on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:11AM
(#36136181)
Why are you trying to remove my freedom to decide who is an imbecile?
Why are you censoring me?
Re:South Australia passes law to ban “disruptive” protests
by csdvrx on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:20AM
(#36136629)
This is very correct and I should have phrased things differently: you can call any idea or opinion "stupid", and you can also scream whatever you want, but you can't do anything to limit their spread through censorship (and there may be more people, also with louder voices than you :)
Re:South Australia passes law to ban “disruptive” protests
by surgical_fire on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:49AM
(#36136782)
Precisely. Perhaps now you understand my original point.
Re:South Australia passes law to ban “disruptive” protests
by csdvrx on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:55AM
(#36137794)
Not fully, as I like my american freedom a whole lot more than comfort: I'll take a free but imbecile-full society with free speech + the freedom to bear arm over the european version of """free speech""" + restriction of gun ownership to the police and the military.
Curiously enough, that seem to goes hand-in-hand with the police throwing hand grenades and using RPG against protesters - this may be A-ok in Europe, but that wouldn't fly here.
Re:South Australia passes law to ban “disruptive” protests
by surgical_fire on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:04AM
(#36137889)
Woosh
Yes, let's not pretend the problem was people "questioning" policies. The problem was people actively disrespecting them.
This is the problem of freedom. Your freedom to be an imbecile takes away my freedom of living in an imbecile-free society.