News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Churchill’s Famine: The killing of three million is a sto... by Convolutional on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:21AM (#36104224)
Then why are we continually subjected to propaganda about the "Holomodor" famine in the Ukraine in 1932, or the (last) famine in China in 1959?

England is blameless for their imperial involvement in the Irish and Indian famine - the Soviet Union and PRC are communist evil when a famine happens in their countries.

I should also note this Ukrainian Holomodor junk people are babbling about (which Walter Duranty and the New York Times at the time said was not happening) was before the English-enabled Indian famine.

Re:Churchill’s Famine: The killing of three million is a sto... by Jibbedeyeah on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:38AM (#36104353)
Ok tankie.
Re:Churchill’s Famine: The killing of three million is a sto... by gishbunker on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:35AM (#36104336)
I think it's absolutely reasonable to blame England for famines in Ireland and India, as well as blame Soviet style communism for famines in Ukraine and China.

I'm a (non Soviet style) communist, and it's frustrating to me to see both communist and capitalist posters say, "my side did nothing wrong, yours is the killer". Both communist and capitalist regimes have caused famine. We need to observe both and feel comfortable with the idea that even things we agree with sometimes do evil.

Re:Churchill’s Famine: The killing of three million is a sto... by revelio on Sunday May 28, 2023 @11:01AM (#36104592)
This should be obvious enough to not need pointing out, but at the time of the Bengal famine there was a world war in which Japan was invading Asia and Germany was invading Europe. Many of the things that exacerbated the Bengal famine were due to defensive measures designed to avoid even worse deaths if those invasions were successful.

In contrast, the famines in the USSR and PRC weren't caused by invasion. They were caused by the collectivization of agriculture for ideological reasons.

Re:Churchill’s Famine: The killing of three million is a sto... by Convolutional on Sunday May 28, 2023 @11:11AM (#36104687)
> Japan was invading Asia and Germany was invading Europe. Many of the things that exacerbated the Bengal famine were due to defensive measures designed to avoid even worse deaths if those invasions were successful.

You're talking as if England had not invaded and subjugated India. Gandhi was in prison during World War II due to noncooperatiom with the English invaders, and Nehru and the then big tent Congress party had the same policy. Bose actually went to Japan as he wanted the Japanese to come into India and drive out the English invaders.

What was the Dust Bowl famine in the US at the same time but policies of "agriculture for ideological reasons"?

Re:Churchill’s Famine: The killing of three million is a sto... by revelio on Sunday May 28, 2023 @12:09PM (#36105297)
At the time of the famine