News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by chrismorgan on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:00AM (#36092895)
> Monotype fonts, which have been specially adapted to these recommendations, carry the name affix, "1450".

None of those commas should be present, and they significantly change the meaning of the sentence. With them (especially the first), it means that all Monotype fonts have been specially adapted to these recommendations and carry The Name Affix, which is “1450”. The commas serve equivalently to parentheses: “Monotype fonts (which have been specially adapted to these recommendations) carry the name affix ("1450").”

What they meant was: “Monotype fonts which have been specially adapted to these recommendations carry the name affix "1450".” That is: the subset of Monotype fonts so adapted are identified by the presence of the “1450” name affix.

A remark like this would normally be off-topic on HN, but I mention it because (a) the line threw me, for a couple of readings, and I only resolved it because I know Monotype fonts have been round much longer than this DIN 1450 thing and by inference from the next sentence; and (b) correct language usage is at least as important as font when it comes to “barrier-free reading”.

Some of the other commas in the article are also wrong in the same and similar ways. I’m curious whether there might be something about comma usage or sentence structure in the native language of the author, which I’m guessing isn’t English. (There are a few other mildly unusual or clumsy word choices and sentence structures, and a few minor errors. Given the context, probably German.)

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by hommelix on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:40AM (#36093058)
> Some of the other commas in the article are also wrong in the same and similar ways. I’m curious whether there might be something about comma usage or sentence structure in the native language of the author, which I’m guessing isn’t English. (There are a few other mildly unusual or clumsy word choices and sentence structures, and a few minor errors.)

Yes this translation from German. The comma fits the way German grammar recommends it. Some other clues: DIN is a German standard organization and the company advertising this new font is a German Ltd (GmbH).

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by kwhitefoot on Saturday May 27, 2023 @01:11PM (#36096364)
Perhaps the translator was American. A lot of American text looks like a pepper shaker full off commas was upended over it.
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by noitpmeder on Saturday May 27, 2023 @03:17PM (#36097379)
At least we don't have all these 'u's polluting our words! I'll die before I spell 'color' differently!

:)

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by pavlov on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:26AM (#36093010)
The commas around the “which” clause seem to follow German rules for embedded subordinate clauses:

https://www.germanveryeasy.com/comma

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by JdeBP on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:26AM (#36093009)
It's fairly obviously primarily targetting a German market. There are no French and Spanish versions, and I suspect that the English version is there as the fallback for whatever international market there is.

The German language version has fewer commas:

* https://www.linotype.com/de/6990/din-1450.html

I wonder how badly Hacker News would have coped with a submission in German. (-:

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by Eduard on Saturday May 27, 2023 @06:35AM (#36093572)
"Schriften von Monotype, die speziell an diese Empfehlungen angepasst wurden, tragen den Namenszusatz „1450“."
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by fnord77 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:39AM (#36093054)
* * *
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by adrianmonk on Saturday May 27, 2023 @12:02PM (#36095790)
No, the first two commas are extraneous as well.

From https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/usage-of-essen... :

> Essential clauses modify key words and are important to the main point of a sentence. Nonessential clauses provide superfluous information that, while interesting, does not change the main point of a sentence. Nonessential clauses are offset by punctuation such as commas or parentheses to indicate the clause as an aside.

With the commas, it is a nonessential clause, which means the meaning should stay the same if it is removed. And that would turn the sentence into this:

> Monotype fonts carry the name affix "1450".

But that isn't the meaning of the sentence. It's not true that Monotype fonts (all of them, in general) have "1450" in their names. Only the ones that follow the recommendation do.

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by noitpmeder on Saturday May 27, 2023 @03:21PM (#36097401)
This is the kind of assertive falseness I associate with ChatGPT!
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by grey_earthling on Saturday May 27, 2023 @05:02AM (#36093149)
> “Monotype fonts which have been specially adapted to these recommendations carry the name affix "1450".”

Even this isn't wholly clear. They should have said:

> “Monotype fonts that have been specially adapted to these recommendations carry the name affix "1450".”

The word “that” defines the subject of the sentence; the word “which” describes the already-defined subject. This is a rule of thumb usually expressed as: “‘that’ defines; ‘which’ describes”.

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by 082349872349872 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @05:51AM (#36093391)
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by quietbritishjim on Saturday May 27, 2023 @06:52AM (#36093646)
If we're going to be pedantic about language use (and it appears that we are): "cf" is short for the Latin for "compare [with]". To me, that only makes sense when the reference is something very analogous, e.g. you're talking about caramelising onions and you cite an article about caramelising carrots. Most of the time it's used, including this time, it would be more appropriate to just say "see also".
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by meghan_rain on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:44AM (#36093901)
This entire thread is peak HN lmao
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by 082349872349872 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:13PM (#36097825)
TIL — going forward I'll use see for 'compare' and cf for 'contrast'
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by the-printer on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:00AM (#36093992)
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by djbusby on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:19AM (#36094126)
Or use 'nb' - nota bene
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by projektfu on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:05AM (#36094482)
Monotype "1450" fonts are specially adapted to these recommendations.
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by stumblers on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:16AM (#36093769)
They're using the words "Monotype Fonts" as a type shop, a brand, a company...I forget which but I set type decades ago and remember the name. They're not referring to 'monotype fonts' as a type of font, like serif or sans serif.
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by mannykannot on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:37AM (#36093874)
I feel the issue applies in this case also, unless all of Monotype Fonts' fonts are DIN 1450 fonts.
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by trinix912 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:10AM (#36094521)
Perhaps because nouns are usually capitalized in German.

Seriously tho, does it really matter that much? There are native English speakers who write worse than that.

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by throwaway290 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:46AM (#36094796)
It matters that if you are writing illegibly even the ultra legible typeface is not going to help that much
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by nyanpasu64 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @02:55PM (#36097226)
Even worse, when reading this sentence in the comments, I thought it was referring to monospace coding fonts, which happen to share the same "legibility features" as required by DIN 1450 (tailed l, dotted 0, etc.)
Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by mannykannot on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:48AM (#36093929)
As this sentence immediately follows a paragraph introducing the new standard, I would probably go with something like "The affix '1450' is used to designate those monotype fonts which have been specially adapted to these recommendations."

Now I am wondering if the different rules for verb placement in German and English contribute to the difficulty of punctuating translations unambiguously.

Re:Din 1450, recommended for barrier-free reading by jhgb on Saturday May 27, 2023 @02:00PM (#36096763)
What you're seeing here is absolutely English written by a German. In German, restrictive clauses are separated by commas. This language feature seeps into English written by Germans by means of interference.