News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by ricardobayes on Saturday May 27, 2023 @03:42AM (#36092814)
No, sorry this is 100% on you. You should have implemented throttling, and daily query limits. Once you put something on the internet for free, you can't complain then if people are using it.
Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by usrbinbash on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:29AM (#36093020)
> you can't complain then if people are using it.

Yes he can complain, and bombarding a free service for unlimited requests isn't okay.

For starters because the people doing that, will usually be among the first to cry when the free service stops being free, blocks their requests or suddenly requires an API key.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by ranguna on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:37AM (#36093050)
> bombarding a free service for unlimited requests isn't okay

Hummmm.... OP's website on https://getjsonip.com/ says:

> Supports unlimited requests and is free.

Seems like we have a bit of a contradiction here.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by usrbinbash on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:52AM (#36093114)
I see no contradiction.

There is a difference between gracefully and responsibly using something that is offered for free, and just bombarding it with requests like no tomorrow.

People can of course do the latter. But then they don't get to complain when at some point, the available offerings present walls of legalese instead of a few simple and clear statements, and the user experience goes from seamless and easy to "Click here to register an API Key"

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by ranguna on Monday May 29, 2023 @04:18AM (#36111869)
It all depends on the nature of the work you are doing.

One thing is to own a service that's used by 10 MAU and you extend the service with a job that calls the OP's service 100 times a second. That's bad, you are using way more than you need.

Another thing is to own a mobile app used by 10M MAU and you embed the OP's service into the app. That's not bad intention, you just added a new service to your app. The problem is that the OP's definition of "unlimited" is not really unlimited.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by srvmshr on Saturday May 27, 2023 @06:59AM (#36093685)
No that is not why OP had set up the server. It was gratis. A complementary service. It was supposed to be used responsibly, since it seems evident that this isn't sponsored by some corporate. For a hobby project hosted on their own dime, it was okay for fair use. If this was something a dev needed for their business, self-hosting it (if FOSS) or licensing it from the creator was the right thing, so that OC didn't have to bear the burden.

Imagine a local hobby meetup giving free ice cream at the venue. Just because someone liked it and it was free, didn't allow them to invite over all their siblings, kith and kin, brethren and the entire ancestral village.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by revolvingocelot on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:10AM (#36094516)
Back in highschool, my friends and I got kicked out of a buffet restaurant. Every movie I've ever seen a poster for suggests that it's "Only in Theatres", yet I've held many a DVD release in my hands.

There's something about reasonability and fair-use and use over time going on here, but I just can't put my finger on it.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by ransackdev on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:51AM (#36095279)
You didn't get kicked out, you got played. They bank on the fact that most people will eat less than the price of admission, kinda almost like the ones who under eat the admission cost subsidize the ones who overeat the admission cost. Kinda like the paying customers for a service usually subsidize the running costs of the free tier. The buffet advertised all you can eat, you paid them, that's a contract. Unless there's fine print that you agreed to, you had no obligation to leave before you had your fill if they were open still. America 101, contracts and liability for breaches of contracts.

For example here's the Backblaze team verifying that their unlimited personal backup is indeed unlimited, with one single user storing 430TB for $6/month. The users spending $6/month who use a couple GB more than offset the cost of the 430TB guy. If your business model doesn't support the ability to get in the black, you have a failing business. This isn't the user's responsibility to fix, it's the failing service with a bad business model.

> As you can see, we lose money on a few customers at the high end (we cannot store 430TB of data for only $6/month), but since more customers just want to be reasonable and backup their laptops we are profitable and fully sustainable on the "average"

> Somebody who is costing Backblaze $2,150/month and is only paying $6/month :-)

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/b6lbew/comment/ejlbsq...

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by Prickle on Monday May 29, 2023 @04:29AM (#36111944)
You can say that the local community water well has "unlimited uses", then complain when Nestle comes over and takes all the water.

No difference here.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by ricardobayes on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:46AM (#36095241)
Can you imagine a fast food restaurant franchise CEO to complain how annoying it is that people ask for copious amounts of free ketchup? If you don't have a policy or anti-abuse measures, don't complain that "people are using too much" of the free stuff. That's ridiculous and detached from real life.
Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by misnome on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:09AM (#36092937)
You absolutely can. Nobody has an obligation to serve you if you are an asshole.
Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by johnisgood on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:18AM (#36092976)
Why complain instead of mitigating? Or why not complain AND mitigate at the very least?

Do not serve it to assholes?

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by misnome on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:28AM (#36093016)
> Or why not complain AND mitigate at the very least?

You mean, like they say they have been trying to do, in the complaint?

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by johnisgood on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:16PM (#36099832)
I am replying to you saying that "you absolutely can [complain]". The comment to which I replied simply states that you can complain. Sure, you can. shrugs
Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by wiseowise on Saturday May 27, 2023 @06:58AM (#36093673)
I’ll never understand “no complain” argument.

Person has a valid complaint, goddamnit, they have all the rights to complain.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by johnisgood on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:15PM (#36099817)
Sure, feel free to complain away if that makes you feel better.
Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by CPLX on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:44AM (#36093900)
I mean, we've all got a right to grievances.
Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by GuB-42 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:34AM (#36094224)
I would have agreed if it was a piece of source code. For example if you put a bit of code on the internet using a permissive license and it is good, don't complain that some tech giant took all your work for themselves without giving you anything in return. By choosing that licence you explicitly told the world that doing this is fine. Also, using someone else source code doesn't incur recurring costs on the author's part.

But here, you are actually taking resources from the author. That's something that is not only rude, but also puts the user at risk. The author is really nice for maintaining service, he could have just stopped it, or even served malicious payloads. After all, there is no contract saying that he should be nice. Here, despite the strong language, he is trying to stay nice instead of just cutting a service that many people rely on, which he has all right to do.

Throttling and daily query limits would make the service unreliable and not so different from cutting it off completely. Keep in mind that it is not a single user abusing the service, it is many users who got redirected there by an abusive app. He could have used the "API key" that is suggested here, but it is a hurdle that will affect usability.

Re:[418] I'm a Teapot by ricardobayes on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:42AM (#36095202)
Yeah maybe, but in this day and age it's completely unreasonable to expect anything from users. You need to expect the worst and if your system is not prepared for it, then sorry, it's badly designed. There are many anti-abuse measures and if you're deliberately not using any of them, then that's on you.