News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by wk_end on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:36PM (#36090685)
In no way defending the sloppy conference planning or how the former keynote speaker got screwed here, but...unless I'm missing something it seems pretty disproportionate to completely leave a community you've invested over seven years of your life in over sloppy conference planning, doesn't it? I feel like I'm missing something.
Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by imran-iq on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:40PM (#36090705)
Allegedly this isn't the first time something like this has happened[0].

Just feels like more open source drama tbh.

---

https://twitter.com/__phantomderp/status/1662235332375347202

Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by netaustin on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:40PM (#36090715)
What you're describing may be the sunk cost fallacy [https://thedecisionlab.com/biases/the-sunk-cost-fallacy].
Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by lo_zamoyski on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:10PM (#36090889)
No. The sunk cost fallacy involves sticking with something you know is the worse option (sticking with that option is the worse option) by appealing to the investment already made in that option as a justification. It does not mean that all appeals to investment are fallacious. If I invested 5 years in graduate school, and I'm a few months away from receiving my doctorate, it would not be categorically fallacious to argue that since I've already invested this much time, I should stick it out even if I'm thinking of pivoting. You would be losing a degree for what could be a vanishingly small benefit of leaving.

In line with that, the comment above is asking for some reason that could explain why someone who has invested so much time in something would leave so abruptly. A person who has worked on a project for so long derives (and provides) many benefits for having been involved for so long, and even when people change course, they don't typically do so this abruptly without a proportional reason. Hence, the mystery.

Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by dom96 on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:39PM (#36090702)
I really doubt this is the sole reason. It’s likely simply what broke the camel’s back so to speak.
Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by jasmer on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:19PM (#36090936)
Or it's one side of the story.
Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by dahdum on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:50PM (#36090771)
They reached out to him to give a talk he wasn’t ready to do. He obliges, works to make it happen, and gets blindsided by organizational politics. If he feels the organization and leadership neither respect him personally or his efforts, it’s a perfectly proportionate response.

Not sure how I’d react in his exact situation, but once trust and mutual respect are gone, so am I.

Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by jasmer on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:19PM (#36090933)
I know this will seem glib at first glance - but it's actually a petty move.

Obviously, it seems as though he is being mistreated, he probably is -in which case, he is being petty and he has the high ground here.

And nominally he does.

But the thing is - complex orgs are complex - it's the nature of the beast. They don't act perfectly and often their actions are the result of a 'mediocre actor', unknown/unseen forces, or just systemic issues, they make mistakes.

In this case, it's not a big slight, it's a minor, bureaucratic slight.

The 'winning move' is to 'roll with it' - not quit in a huff and puff.

An M&A guy on a team gave me a project to take on, he offered a vendor something we could not follow on with. I had to tell the vendor we were not going to move forward. That vendor was upset, and had invested in the project. But that was our legit position. We probably should have characterised the risk better, but so should have the vendor - there was no contract or anything, just some verbal agreements.

I learned about this much earlier in the Army, where you see very clearly how plans never work as you want, and at the moment of contact, it's more about training and skills than it is plans (like a startup!), and when you're on the opposite end of some weird order - well that's why. But you get enough exposure after a while to very materially see why this is, and the second you organise your first project, it's like an 'aha' moment of why there's inherently so much chaos. You're indoctrinated to 'not complain' and 'make the best out of it', at most, you can be 'nominally curmudgeon, but then do it'. Of course that can have downsides (and sometimes bad one's), but on the whole it's necessary in that context.

I can't say in this case that there was some great legitimacy around Rust Org's needs, but they also didn't seem like a big deal at the end of the day.

'Shift your speaking slot and add this thing to your talking mentioning that it's not Orthodoxy' ... is a 1 out of 10 on the level of concern. I suggest it's very well within the boundaries of 'bumpy roads' and to repeat: I'm not saying he's not in the right, rather, trying to characterise the proportionality here.

"If I give the talk after it has been downgraded, then I acquiesce that this grotesque behavior"

It's not not 'grotesque'.

Russian missiles hit a mental hospital in Dnipro today, that's 'grotesque'.

Roll with it.

Even better, put it in your back pocket for a 'maybe favour' next year - hey you bumped me for very little good reason, I'd like to talk about such and such!

Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by riceart on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:27PM (#36091510)
You realize you are speaking about 2 different people as if they are one?
Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by hxugufjfjf on Saturday May 27, 2023 @02:15AM (#36092478)
Most likely not. This whole ordeal is confusing.
Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by cjbprime on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:50PM (#36090774)
> sloppy conference planning

FWIW, the quoted thread makes it sound like the actual conference planners were no more than messengers here, so it may be fairer to summarize as ".. over capricious meddling in conference planning" or something like that.

Re:I have resigned from all roles in rustlang, effective imm... by 1lint on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:28PM (#36090977)
I agree it seems like a disproportionate act to take given the situation as the author described it, but this certainly does seem like the kind of scenario that involves a lot of context that goes unmentioned.

One explanation for this sequence of events is that the conference planners had since found a new compelling topic reflective of the project's direction to be covered in a keynote speech, in which case the natural topic to replace is one that discusses a "possible"/hypothetical idea. I'm sure there was a better way for leadership to handle this, in particular around communicating their intentions, but this shortcoming seems much more likely a case of incompetence rather than malice towards the speaker, given the lack of information to support the latter.