News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by hgsgm on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @07:59PM (#36065518)
Obfuscation is itself a malware signature.
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by Hnaomyiph on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @08:57PM (#36065928)
Until it’s standard practice by all companies to protect up under the guise of consumer protection with all closed sourced software.
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by hulahoof on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:49PM (#36066242)
like that time sony gave everyone a rootkit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk...
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by RockRobotRock on Thursday May 25, 2023 @03:12AM (#36067899)
similar to starforce for those that don't know: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p-wyIalhdPU
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by Vervious on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:51PM (#36066570)
I mean, the same argument has been applied to other cryptographic tools. Why encrypt your messages, unless you're sending something sketchy? Why obfuscate programs, unless you're hiding something?

Yet I think the utility of encryption is well-demonstrated, and not just theoretical. It can be used by good people to defend against adversarial intent. And it may well be that obfuscation (in its most direct application) has the same effect. (e.g. companies sharing proprietary algorithms for you to run at home, without revealing the secret sauce; or me delegating computation to AWS without revealing secrets)

Note that this is not why indistinguishability obfuscation (iO) is a crown jewel, here. Practically, iO is nowhere close to obfuscating anything larger than a tiny circuit. But it can still be useful to do things like obfuscate secret keys when designing cryptographic protocols. Theoretically, iO allows us to derive essentially every cryptographic primitive, which is why this paper is interesting, and why iO is called a crown jewel. And now, we can build iO for the first time from well-studied hardness assumptions.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday May 25, 2023 @01:29AM (#36067319)
> I mean, the same argument has been applied to other cryptographic tools. Why encrypt your messages, unless you're sending something sketchy? Why obfuscate programs, unless you're hiding something?

It's easy to argue that everyone has legitimate interest in hiding some things in data, but what would be a legitimate case for hiding things in code?

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by Brotkrumen on Thursday May 25, 2023 @02:33AM (#36067669)
"This is a trade secret. We have not patented it, because it's so clever and valuable that it needs to be protected longer than a patent lasts"
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by Xelynega on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:16AM (#36068900)
Except we know(and have example from cryptocurrency) that the problems with ownership in real life have little to do with cryptography.

The reason coca cola doesn't use Pepsi's recipe isnt because mixing the ingredients under heat creates an irreversible mixture that you can seperate to find the recipe. They don't use pepsis recipe because its illegal.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by Attrecomet on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:29AM (#36068979)
That's true for a recipe that was developed in a past millennium. Trade secrets are still very much relevant for companies that work with more modern technologies than soda from before the Great War, and a useful protection against competition. Even if you do believe that companies within the US or EU wouldn't touch other's IP with a 10 foot pole due to strong laws, you'd have to be very naive to think this is valid in all parts of the globe.

Edit: it's also trivially not true for trade secrets in the legal sense -- if you upload your trade secret willingly to AWS, it's no longer a trade secret, unless you have extra contracts in place. With obfuscation, you could skip a lot of red tape to keep it secret.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by liminvorous on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:48AM (#36070075)
You can't copyright a recipe, the thing reason it doesn't make sense for Pepsi to make an exact duplicate of coke is that Coke is better at selling Coke that Pepsi is, and it's better for them to be a niche alternative some people prefer than to be an undifferentiated competititor. Reverse engineering trade secrets is perfectly legal if you haven't agreed otherwise.
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by andrewflnr on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:27AM (#36071148)
Since when is coca cola niche?
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by pxc on Thursday May 25, 2023 @11:25AM (#36071964)
That remains a fundamentally anti-social motivation...
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by joelfried on Thursday May 25, 2023 @11:54AM (#36072346)
Making it harder for bad actors to create malware would seem like one legitimate case.
Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by moring on Thursday May 25, 2023 @02:15AM (#36067564)
> I mean, the same argument has been applied to other cryptographic tools. Why encrypt your messages, unless you're sending something sketchy? Why obfuscate programs, unless you're hiding something?

There is a huge difference: Encryption is used to hide something from a third party, while obfuscation is used to hide something from the intended recipient.

Or, if you'd like to argue that the intended recipient is the computer, not the user: To turn that computer into a deputy of the sender, while still formally belonging to the recipient.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by consp on Thursday May 25, 2023 @02:29AM (#36067642)
> while obfuscation is used to hide something from the intended recipient.

No. Most obfuscation is done to increase the time needed to reverse the source of publicly available programs. Not the user (99% of the recipients) but the adversary is the intended target. The users are just cought in the crossfire.

Unless you consider every user of apps as someone who has both the skill and the need to reverse engineer your app.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by Xelynega on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:13AM (#36068887)
> No. Most obfuscation is done to increase the time needed to reverse the source of publicly available programs.

So to stop the intended recipient from deciphering the program.

"Adversaries" are the strawman used to hurt legitimate customers who are left with black boxes for device drivers and no functioning hardware since the manufacturers make it impossible to open source firmware updates.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by ilyt on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:47AM (#36069518)
In case of DRM sure, but there are cases like online games where "adversaries" are players (intended users of the app) trying to use cheat programs on game binary to get an advantage over other players.

I share the sentiment that in most cases it just serves DRM vendors and is disservice to users but that's not all the cases.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by denton-scratch on Thursday May 25, 2023 @05:58AM (#36068792)
> and why iO is called a crown jewel.

Ah, thanks. That's far from clear in the article.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by ilyt on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:27AM (#36068966)
> I mean, the same argument has been applied to other cryptographic tools.

Intent matters.

> Why encrypt your messages, unless you're sending something sketchy?

Because I am sending something private, I can't believe people bring this dumbass argument still, and even here.

> Why obfuscate programs, unless you're hiding something?

Why indeed. This one is the red flag, not message in your e-mail client being encrypted. Again. Intent, and context, matters.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by Vervious on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:05AM (#36079753)
You say the intent is different but don’t show why. What about obfuscation implies malicious intent? How come it doesn’t apply to encryption?

It can’t be about applications, because I can come up with a thousand applications for obfuscation with benign intent. Such as delegating private computation to AWS without Amazon learning my personal information.

Re:UCLA Computer Grad Constructs “Crown Jewel of Cryptography” by jrpt on Thursday May 25, 2023 @03:01PM (#36074648)
Sure but it's a very weak signal.