Elephants may be domesticating themselves

Re:Elephants may be domesticating themselves by jjk166 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @05:29PM (#36064100)

The point is that a sudden change in climate can't be blamed on them continuing to do what they've been doing for millions of years.

Now I highly doubt that an elephant occasionally knocking over a tree is the only thing holding back the continent from being forested, especially given that many elephants live in densely forested areas, but if for the sake of argument we assume that their behavior is a major factor, you still need to explain why their behavior, and thus that forcing function acting on the environment, would suddenly change.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Elephants may be domesticating themselves by User23 on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:50PM (#36086655)

> Now I highly doubt that an elephant occasionally knocking over a tree is the only thing holding back the continent from being forested, especially given that many elephants live in densely forested areas

Indian and African elephants are quite different ecologically speaking.

> but if for the sake of argument we assume that their behavior is a major factor, you still need to explain why their behavior, and thus that forcing function acting on the environment, would suddenly change

I never claimed it would suddenly change, I claimed that it's been consistent and has maintained a status quo.

Am I misunderstanding you?

[ Parent | on HN ]