News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Mass Effect is the Most Important Science Fiction Uni... by Legion on Saturday February 18, 2012 @03:22AM (#3606238)
I enjoyed Mass Effect, but Mass Effect 2 undid my interest in the series.

Mass Effect's locations offered some freedom of movement - they felt like actual places.

Mass Effect 2's settings were extremely constrained by comparison - no longer living locations to explore, but very much tight funnels that might as well have had "== One Way =>" signs posted.

Re:Why Mass Effect is the Most Important Science Fiction Uni... by vacri on Saturday February 18, 2012 @05:00AM (#3606327)
If you mean the ability to land on planets and then spend more time fighting the bouncy vertical movement of your vehicle than actually moving around the map, then yes, I guess ME1 had more freedom. I found them about the same in terms of linearity, but I was very glad I didn't have the bounce-o-matic sessions anymore.
Re:Why Mass Effect is the Most Important Science Fiction Uni... by Legion on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @07:37PM (#3623250)
No, I mean the on-foot areas.

"Levels" (for lack of better word) were extremely "follow the only road" in ME2. Yes, missions generally had a single start point and a single end point in ME1 as well, but the point is that the path from A to B was MUCH more free an unencumbered in ME1. It was, well, sort of the difference between an RPG and an almost-FPS.

Of course, I wish FPS games themselves would return to that kind of free-roaming level design. As put brilliantly in this image: http://www.geardiary.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/fps-desi...

Re:Why Mass Effect is the Most Important Science Fiction Uni... by jakeonthemove on Saturday February 18, 2012 @05:30AM (#3606363)
What platform were you playing it on? I have the PC version and enjoyed every moment in the Mako - it goes up, down and side to side like a boss, and you don't even have to maneuver around obstacles :-)
Re:Why Mass Effect is the Most Important Science Fiction Uni... by vacri on Saturday February 18, 2012 @05:13PM (#3607891)
PC here as well. Sure, you can drive over all but the nearly vertical mountains... but hit the slightest bump and the Mako is like a superball. Mako was fun at first, but planetside gets tedious fast: loading screen - bounce - bounce - hit anomoly 1/2/3 and do same minigame for all - bounce - short, unsatisfying vehicle firefight - loading screen. ME2 was much better - here's a planet, grab the resources, if there's a special mission, then you get a loading screen.
Re:Why Mass Effect is the Most Important Science Fiction Uni... by drostie on Saturday February 18, 2012 @08:18AM (#3606536)
I had a somewhat similar experience when I played Prince of Persia: The Warrior Within.

I remember it being very pretty, engaging, with wide open spaces and interesting combat... and then you would get to a dead end. You would look around a corner and find the way forward. It might sometimes take a while, but there was always exactly one path through the level (and game!) on reflection.

I would contrast this with some of my favorite moments in Portal: you can either get yourself accidentally utterly stuck (and the game has to detect that and let you out), or you can find clever ways with a risky approach to bypass an entire level.

I guess I'm saying that as a general principle, every level should have at least four paths: one is risky and difficult and unconventional but will lead you to the end result a little bit quicker; one is the longer, slower way; and one looks like the longer, slower way but in fact goes nowhere or leads to a trap; and one leads you to a secret which might help.

(I also appreciate situations like Zelda where you don't tell me what order to complete the dungeons in -- maybe dungeon A has an item which is important for solving dungeon C; if so then consider building the risky-difficult pathways through C to not require this item.)