News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by gumballindie on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:33AM (#36058701)
Interesting. Copyright applies to regular folks but not to corporations ingesting our content for model training.
Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by dark-star on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:53AM (#36058980)
the corollary is that if you download a movie not to watch it, but to train an AI on it, then copyright does not apply.

So when someone knocks on your door and accuses you of illegal streaming, just tell them you "trained an AI" on it ;-)

Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by troglotit on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:28AM (#36059462)
unix `cp` command is AI
Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by kwhitefoot on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:56AM (#36059891)
> scientific research is usually exempt from copyright.

Is it? Everywhere?

Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by neximo64 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:56AM (#36059017)
Maybe its that governments should train AI models to be fair with copyright.

One could argue that people ingest copyrighted content too and spit it back out too.

Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by gumballindie on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:58AM (#36059910)
> One could argue that people ingest copyrighted content too and spit it back out too.

Well then we should be allowed to store entire movies, since we can memorise just like hard drives do.

Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by jeroenhd on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:58AM (#36059039)
That's still an open question. The AI people here sure claim it doesn't.

The typical workaround is that scientific research is usually exempt from copyright. If you train a model for research, and then use that model for your business, your business didn't take part in the violation step.

Unless the model you trained is a derived work, of course. If it is, you need to pay for every scrap of copyrighted work you use, same as with music samples (fair use probably doesn't apply here but IANAL).

There are two American lawsuits about this going on at the moment that I know of. I think the lawsuit against the stable diffusion people can bring the clearest answer to this question, though I wouldn't be surprised if the case goes through various courts because of the implications for the AI industry as a whole.

Actually having to pay for the stuff you use would ruin a lot of AI startups. Then again, having to pay for the stuff you use also ruined Napster.

Re:European Commission Calls for Pirate Site Blocking Around... by globular-toast on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:27AM (#36059454)
Which is especially amusing because when copyright was invented it was only corporations that could realistically own copying machines (ie. printing presses). It was never meant to stop individuals copying things.