Value of assets on the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve in 2007: 0.9 trillion
Value of assets on the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve in 2022: 9 trillion
The anti-liquidists (also gold bugs or digital gold bugs) never came to terms with the fact that the human economy - like the human body - is mostly made out of water.
There is a goldilocks hydration level but its not a simple thing to identify as there are countless other complex things going on.
You can say that borrowing from the markets is riskless for the Fed, because it can always pay back with the printing press.
But lending to the markets is still risky: because market participants don't have a printing press to help fall back on.
(In this case, the Fed often also bought some assets and later sold them; that's financially equivalent enough to lending that it doesn't make a difference here.
Especially if the assets you are buying and selling are bonds.)
It's like a conspiracy theory, except the "conspiracy" part is actually true (the Fed was exactly trying to create inflation), but the consequences are fanciful and legion.
(Seemingly) paradoxically, the big Fed balance sheet is also a consequence of not doing enough QE fast enough.
Of course, the Fed isn't responsible for everything. For example, the Fed has nothing to do with the Jones Act.
In the olden days of 2007, banks would only hold as many reserves at the Fed as they legally needed. They would instead invest any extra (or make their deposits less attractive, so that they have fewer excess reserves).
In 2008 the Fed started paying interest on reserves above the legally minimum (so called excess reserves).
Excess reserves parked at the Fed don't contribute to the economy, but are still counted in the Fed balance sheet.
You can see on https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=15mr6 how the level of reserves at the Fed shot from about 0.050 trillion USD in 2007 to about 3 trillion USD today.
It's much weirder. Economics is even fuller of anti-lags, ie clever economic actors are constantly planning for the future and anticipating. Eg if the Fed announces today, that they are going to run the printing presses red-hot next year, you'd already see inflation starting now.
That anticipation is why stock prices started to recover when we were still in the very middle of the pandemic. Contrary to popular opinion, investors are rather long sighted and forward looking. (They just don't always believe managers when they say 'trust me bro, our long term plan might lose money now, but it's totally gonna pay off anytime soon'; and that's why they demand regular quarterly profits from run-of-the-mill management, but let Bezos run Amazon for decades without anything in the way of dividends.)
Contrary to popular opinion investors are a very inhomogeneous crowd: From real economy investors, like the shipping company that tries to anticipate long-term global economic supply and demand patterns and orders massively expensive ships that will only be delivered years down the line, to bloomberg types or crypto speculators or HFT algos, that basically just look at financial timeseries going up or down, detached from any economic, environmental or social reality.
To abuse the liquid analogy just bit more, the fluid is composed of all sorts of molecules. Heavy ones with lots of inertia but also lots of small scale noise. As things are, the incoherent noise sometimes turns coherent (hypes, manias and other delusions) and then the tail wags the dog (to finally switch metaphor :-)
But those that anticipate the future correctly get rewarded with more money, so that over time the average dollar belongs to a smarter investor.
I know the pandemic was new and disorienting, but do these people have no contrarian instincts at all? They just look at what everyone else is doing and do that, lest they stand out and be singled out? If you're in a leadership position and you play the "everyone thought X so you can understand why I did too" card you should be fired.
You mean it is learning? Hysteresis is "local learning".
Its like throwing a stone in a stagnant pond and watching the waves go up and down.
Except the economic fluid is far more complex, full of lags and hysteresis. E.g. shipping rates have gone down but not the costs (indicated as fuel and labor). Why not?
Nobody wants to leave a crisis go to waste (i.e. groups of people will try to maximize and make their monetary gains permanent) but there are restoring forces towards the underlying equilibrium supply and demand balances.