Are you people talking about installing from a GNOME-based live image or something? I think most people use the netinstall image, which uses no DE and, I'm about 90% sure, has no graphical environment selected by default.
There are also KDE, XFCE, LXDE, and maybe others, to also install; but the user has to select those instead of the default desktop task.
Dismissing things as "bizzar takes" is a good way to miss very clear signs.
As in, they sometimes have good ideas, and then just entirely butcher the implementation: either they do it directly (Unity and Mir's in-house development), or they adopt an external source of bad implementations (Redhat's pulseaudio and systemd initiatives; both good ideas on paper, but then just become a thorn in everyone's side for a decade until better alternatives appear ).
You mean the most widely used distributions which together account for the overwhelming majority of desktop Linux users?
> saddled with their defaults?
How exactly is having a default a burden? The niche alternatives you listed also have defaults, just different ones.
> Dismissing things as "bizzar takes" is a good way to miss very clear signs.
On the other hand, having bizzare takes is a sign of being misinformed.
This is a bizzare take. Debian, Ubuntu, Fedora, RedHat and its spinoffs all default to GNOME.