See this post [0] from 2019. Things don't seem to have got much better in recent years [1] [2] [3].
[0] https://xeiaso.net/blog/v-vaporware-2019-06-23
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20230351
Seems like I've been listening to Crystal Castles too much these days.
As far as I can see V is well placed on TechEmpower so it must be doing something right at least: https://www.techempower.com/benchmarks/#section=data-r21&tes...
Maybe they didn't deliver on all their claims yet, so what? They seem to be trying something cool. Certainly not reason for all the vitrol.
> hasn't reached any remotely usable state
The language is in beta. So by that logic languages such as Zig, Jai, Odin, Mojo, Red, etc... are all smoke and mirrors too.
V is clearly in a usable enough state and people use it (https://github.com/vlang/awesome-v), thus (as of today) has over 33,000 GitHub stars (ranking #10 for programming languages on GitHub by OSS). That's more than Zig, Odin, and Red combined.
And that should be combined with their 2,000 forks and 630 contributors on GitHub as well. So clearly they are doing something right.
You've been in every conversation about V I've ever had on HackerNews, every time with that same aggressive tone, which is exactly the reason I don't have any interest in ever giving V a time of my day.
It's odd how obvious slanderous remarks and insults directed at developers (like grifter), in addition to provably false statements (like vaporware) are being pushed about the project (like language is unusable), don't seem to get removed. Somehow, that gets left up. Not just here, but other threads too.
Yet, attempts to directly refute or at least push back on the barrage of misinformation about a clearly popular GitHub project get flagged, downvoted, or removed. Don't think that would at all be tolerated if such was done to other open source developers and languages, nor for as long (years). Doing and allowing such isn't right nor is it fair.
Not to mention, this is criticism (or attack) based on an open source language being released on its 1st day. Hello, 1st day the language was released to the public. V came out on June 22, 2019, and this blog post is from June 23, 2019. That is absolute madness to keep reposting links to it, 4 years later.
You will notice that nearly any time V is mentioned on HN, a competitor or evangelist drags out the old irrelevant Xe/Xeiaso/Christine post, which is clearly highly suspicious and seems to serve no purpose other than to direct traffic towards itself for profit and resume views.
What is sad and a demonstration of gullibility, are enthusiasts of competing languages allowing themselves to be programmed to do somebody else's unethical dirty work to character assassinate and push misinformation about developers. Most people know that's wrong. What is the malfunction to be obsessed with something one is not using. If a person doesn't like some other programming language, then don't use it and stop worrying about it. Allow others the freedom to enjoy what they like.
oh and, v-lang does have GC. they use boehm gc.
> They should have reached 1.0 by now...
These are strange statements. People having any familiarity with newer programming languages are likely to not know or be confused by where this is coming from.
V is a relatively new language that came out in 2019 and is in beta. So comparatively speaking, V has progressed well at the least, debatably quite fast. V also has more GitHub stars than all the listed below languages (in beta) combined (per OSS Github language rankings). Let's look at the starting dates for these popular and newer languages:
1) Zig came out in 2016 and is still in beta.
2) Odin came out in 2016 and is still in beta.
3) Jai started in 2014 (full time around 2017) and is still in beta.
4) Red came out in 2011 and is still in beta.
The languages that we see today, which are popular and at the top of the rankings (like TIOBE) are significantly to quite old. Among the youngest languages in the top 20 (your post mentions Rust and Go), they came out in 2015 (Rust), 2014 (Swift), and 2009 (Go). All of these have huge corporate support.
No, because C was derived from B. B was created in 1969 and was much of the basis of what would become C, which is given the release date of 1972. So we can make the argument of at least around 3 years of development, of what would be named C, before reaching a stable or usable enough state.
Languages and goals were much simpler in the past. Stages of development like alpha, beta, or what was 1.0 get kind of mixed up. It's not as clear a process, as we have today.
> Except for jai, because jblow has other things todo
Surely the other language creators had/have other things going on too. One of the main differences, that was attempting to clarify in the previous post, is that certain programming languages have huge corporate backing, which affects their development time. C (AT&T), Go (Google), Rust (Mozilla), and Swift (Apple) have reached 1.0 or stability faster, because of who they have supporting and pushing them.
Independent and more grassroots projects can sometimes achieve 1.0 in comparable times. But, this seems related to how exceptionally talented the lead developers are, experienced (as created other languages before), goals of the project (simpler is often easier), popularity, or how many contributors and sponsors got involved.
1) Uses GC as a convenient default and is optional (can be turned off with -gc none)
2) Can use autofree (enabled with -autofree)
3) Can use arena allocation (enabled with -prealloc)
4) Can be managed manually (-gc none)
The way to do it I think is to properly mentor / monitor juniors rather than tying up hands of experienced developers.
> Rust: Rust right now might be the best language out there right now. It's hard for us to criticize them because we lack the experience of building big rust projects. We do however think rust has a really slow compiler. We also think that rust might be too idealistic where it restricts the developer too much.
> C: C is obviously the best but... we dont always want to manage our own memory. Also their std-lib lacks alot of basic functions. You are forced to work with makefiles or similar build tools and most of those tools are very badly designed.
> C++: C++ is like a worse version of c. They do have the most features of any language, which allows the developers to write the greatest code and also the worst code. You let a developer work on a project for a year and suddenly you are looking at a codebase full of OOP, templates and the most hacky preprocessor logic you've ever seen. That developer says it's built using todays greatest standards, yet no one is able to understand the code at all. Sometimes you have to limit bad practices.
> Other: All other languages use garbage collection which makes them hard to use for millisecond realtime applications. Secondly, most languages allow you to have undefined behaviour.
I'm not sure if this section is really making the case you wanted to make. Either this needs to be rephrased or scrapped all together, it doesn't present the best foot forward because ideally you are recruiting people from these languages, and in your descriptions of them you make some very facile comparisons.