Re:Apple is rewriting Foundation in Swift
by xedrac on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:30PM
(#36026771)
Catch data races at compiler time?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Apple is rewriting Foundation in Swift
by turdprincess on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:34PM
(#36026805)
I don’t know much about Rust, but Swift can prevent data races at compile time by using the Actor type.
It could catch them before that using ownership, at the cost of lower performance.
Though Swift concurrency is mostly about "concurrency" not "parallelism", which is the one that has data races.
Ownership hasn’t shipped yet.
It has an ABI-level ownership thing already. What's missing is ways to control it.
Re:Apple is rewriting Foundation in Swift
by tialaramex on Monday May 22, 2023 @01:58PM
(#36034550)
If your concurrency strictly can't involve parallelism then sure, no data races, but also then your performance is miserable on modern hardware.
If your concurrency can invoke parallelism, then you need to explicitly protect against data races, or else you need to define what happens (Java does this, nobody else has) or else you shrug and say too bad now the program is nonsense, you lose (C, C++, Go, many modern languages do this, it is easier)
> If your concurrency strictly can't involve parallelism then sure, no data races, but also then your performance is miserable on modern hardware.
Often worth it when that hardware is battery-powered though. Using those extra cores isn't free.