News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by Kye on Sunday May 21, 2023 @12:42PM (#36022626)
>> "Yes, lots and lots of idiots have banned perfectly good books. No, we shouldn’t hide sex education from children. But should 5 year olds be told that if they’re not feeling normal, they might not a boy or a girl, but something else?"

It would have helped me avoid a lot of confusion, conflict, and awkwardness growing up. I was always nonbinary. I just didn't have the language to talk about how I was feeling. Finally encountering other people whose specific experience matched mine in the 2010s was eye-opening.

Not only can you be something other than two possibilities, there's a whole space of possibilities inside, outside, and around them! Amazing. I needed that when I was 5.

Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by rastignack on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:34PM (#36023581)
You needed that when you were five, perhaps.

But maybe it would have been detrimental for other to read this. Let’s say for example a child is depressed and by reading this material, wrongly assumes it’s a gender issue and then takes hormones, causing its physical aspect to be awkward at best. There have been such cases.

Who shall we sacrifice ?

Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by adrienthebo on Sunday May 21, 2023 @03:05PM (#36023812)
Receiving puberty blockers isn't something any child casually does after reading a book. Going off the Mayo clinic:

  To begin using pubertal blockers, a child must:

    Show a long-lasting and intense pattern of gender nonconformity or gender dysphoria

    Have gender dysphoria that began or worsened at the start of puberty

    Address any psychological, medical or social problems that could interfere with treatment
    Have entered the early stage of puberty
    Provide informed consent

  Particularly when a child hasn't reached the age of medical consent, parents or other caretakers or guardians must consent to the treatment and support the adolescent through the treatment process.
Source: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/gender-dyspho...

The process of going on hormones/puberty blockers is a labor intensive process and typically requires the sign-off from a doctor and therapist. Nobody's getting sacrificed that isn't willing to jump through a number of significant bundles.

[dead]
Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by rastignack on Sunday May 21, 2023 @04:39PM (#36024494)
Maybe reading those books when you were 4 years old would have helped you to deal with your agressive feelings more gracefully.
Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by n4alre on Sunday May 21, 2023 @09:20PM (#36026346)
Everyone is non-binary. The culture-bound stereotypes that are attached to and imposed upon female and male aren't enacted fully by anyone. One does not need an additional identity outside of woman or man to do this.
Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by erulabs on Sunday May 21, 2023 @09:37PM (#36026454)
Well said. I’ve had a friend, who is non binary, tell me “they didn’t feel like themselves”. We had a very good chat wherein I revealed, as a straight white male, I too am plagued by the thought that I am the wrong person living the wrong life.

My choices are my own and I do not presume to judge anyone else's choices. But “thrown-ness” is not an indication of your sexuality - it’s an indication of your humanity.

Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by Kye on Sunday May 21, 2023 @09:48PM (#36026511)
This is about gender, not sexuality. Your confusion is understandable, but common among those who have not done the work required to have an opinion[0].

[0] https://fs.blog/the-work-required-to-have-an-opinion/

Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by erulabs on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:06PM (#36026624)
I don’t think telling people they don’t know enough about the human experience is the convincing argument you think it is. I do respect you and your opinion though - how can you possibly know what I’ve been through? It applies equally, you see?

Edit: the person who replied to me does not want me reply to them. Ideally, I’ve already said enough. Pedantically, you can assume “sexuality and gender” is the implication of the word “sexuality” above. Requiring homework or ideological preagreement before “being allowed to have an opinion” is among the most concerning things I’ve read that has been written in my lifetime.

Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by Kye on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:16PM (#36026698)
>> "I don’t think telling people they don’t know enough about the human experience"

I'm going to stop you right there. I didn't say that. Let's back up to the post you replied to.

>> "Everyone is non-binary. The culture-bound stereotypes that are attached to and imposed upon female and male aren't enacted fully by anyone. One does not need an additional identity outside of woman or man to do this."

This isn't about "the human experience." This is about a specific human experience that you may have, but clearly need to process a bit more before you go around trying to dismiss--or participate in the dismissal--of others' experiences.

You do not know what you don't know and you reveal that in conflating gender and sexuality.

edit: I already responded to their post, so I won't be discussing this further. I've said all there is to say.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36026470

Re:Sex Ed Books Don't “Groom” Kids and Teens. They Protect Them by Kye on Sunday May 21, 2023 @09:41PM (#36026470)
It's a nice sentiment, but no.

I've tried on man and woman. Both cause dysphoria the same way the wrong binary does for binary trans people. There are aspects of one or the other I do mesh with, but I've talked to enough enbies and binary trans and cis people to be confident that one does in fact need an additional identity to cover it. My experience is unlike that of the many men and women I've talked to about this.