I have just reached the limits of what freedoms I am comfortable with relinquishing to Apple. Having to ask Apple for the permission to be able to write and distribute software that can actually be used on the majority of computers crosses that line for me.
I don't care if apple has anything to gain from closing OSX, because it has become too closed for me to consider it a serious option anymore. That wasn't always the case. I've loved all my macs, including this snow leopard MBP i am writing this on.
To boycott something would mean not buying something that you might have bought otherwise. 'as punishment'.. That's really not what is going on here. OSX has changed in ways that make it no longer meet my requirements for what a computing device needs to be, so i won't buy another one. that's all.
I wasn't OK with it when they introduced the mac app store, I got really unhappy with it when random open source tools suddenly disappeared offline and became $2 pay-to-play software on the mac store. Then the sandboxing restrictions and now the signature things.
I never wanted to play in apple's walled garden. It was fine when it was all the way over there on ios. But the walls are going up around OSX as we speak, and someday they might even remove the back gate, but at that point it will be too late.
Because you will already be living in a world where to get into the nickle-and-dime scam that is the mac app store, you need to bow to apple's wishes, which get even more erratic as it gets more powerful (see sandboxing).
For anyone who doesn't want to play on the app store they now have to now get 'certified' by apple that they are allowed to write software for the mac. If you don't play by those rules, you can expect your software to be widely ignored regardless of the quality or malware status.
And really, the operating system is so much less important than the browser these days.
*edit: typo
The Mac App Store sandboxing rules, while not perfect, are obviously a good thing. Complicated pieces of software should come with ACLs. I really don't want to trust Adobe's stuff to not mess up my system or phone home with all my data. As long as the option remains to acquire software elsewhere (which it will!), the sandboxing thing is nothing to complain about.
And why do you assume that Gatekeeper will be so much more effective than UAC at stopping unsigned software from running? It really won't be hard for users to learn to open an app through the context menu when Gatekeeper complains.
This has nothing to do with Apple.
"For anyone who doesn't want to play on the app store they now have to now get 'certified' by apple that they are allowed to write software for the mac. If you don't play by those rules, you can expect your software to be widely ignored regardless of the quality or malware status."
Sensationalist drama. The people who will be looking for software outside of the Mac App Store are the people who will know how to click to disable needing signing.
So that's Apple's fault? You wouldn't be referring to Growl, would you? They're complying with open source licenses; you can get the source code and build it yourself: http://growl.info/documentation/developer/growl-source-insta...
That's not how it seems to me. From what I can tell, "cancel" simply doesn't move it to Trash, it doesn't let you launch it.
Ah, but they are asking me to cede power to them. To trust them with saying whether or not the majority of users can, by default, run software that I may write.
Sure, they haven't yet abused that power, but I find their asking for it to be a bit objectionable on its own.
That is the situation today. But a few years down the line, when the vast majority of apps are signed, we find ourselves in a completely different environment. One were it becomes possible to prevent untrusted apps altogether, because there's not that many of them, and it will help "protect" users.
They're doing this now, to create an environment where they can do more in future. This may not actually be their plan, but it strikes me to be a very likely outcome.
There will be OSX jailbreaks of course. But how many people are going to feel comfortable voiding their warranty on an expensive Macbook?
If you're boycotting Apple over this, you're no longer being pragmatic, you're being fanatic. Yes, Apple has closed platforms (iOS, iTunes, Mac App Store), but they aren't adding Macs to that list or doing anything else objectionable yet. If you were ok, you should still be. Macs are, and will continue to be, awesome Unix workstations that you can run whatever you want on.
Apple also has nothing to gain from completely closing off OS X. It would destroy their developer base and be really bad PR, with only potentially a bit of added revenue (and Apple is anything but financially desperate).
If you're pissed that Apple is merely capable of acting unethically, and you're going to boycott them because of that, then don't call yourself "pragmatic".