News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:17AM (#36012625)
UPI has no dispute resolution (as of now). So if you pay with UPI to someone and have a dispute, good luck. You have to approach the Indian courts to get your money back, which, given the Indian justice system, is… difficult.

By contrast, dispute resolution with cards is much easier. Also, I don’t recognise this 3% figure — not in all geographies.

Eg Europe under PSD2 has 0.3% for credit cards, and 0.2% for debit cards. In Canada, Visa and MC recently agreed to a 1% cap.

That said, I’d be very interested in seeing where the conversations around dispute resolution in UPI leads. Context: Indian banks have already begun to complain about UPI being free, and the Indian authorities had to quickly walk back a consultation around potential merchant-side charges to UPI.

I guess this tension between business, customers, and digital intermediaries is what makes payments an interesting space.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by hocuspocus on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:27AM (#36012706)
The EEA cap on fees only applies to interchange in 4-party schemes, i.e. the part that goes back to the issuing bank. PSPs typically charge between 0.7 and 1.5%. But yes, it's possible to do much better than countries like the US. For starters because card-present fraud is virtually nonexistent, and online fraud is drastically lower thanks to SCA.

That said, you're right, there's a fundamental difference between moving funds in an immutable way (whose marginal price tends to zero) and a payment system.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by toomuchtodo on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:28AM (#36012711)
Which means bifurcation will occur. Payments where you have high trust and confidence you won’t need a dispute will use UPI or similar instant payment rails. Transactions where you are not confident or are concerned a dispute is going to be required, you’ll pay the transaction fee to use CC rails. Credit cards will become “insured payment” rails for lower trust transactions.

I’d never dispute a payment to my mortgage servicer or electrical utility, but I absolutely might for a rando Facebook ad sale.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:49AM (#36012901)
> I’d never dispute a payment to my mortgage servicer or electrical utility,

Er. “Never” is a strong word and it depends on scope. There have been numerous cases of overcharging. Sure, I might not dispute the payment itself, but the amount? Frequency? These get disputed all the time.

Many jurisdictions have good consumer protections for this, though, so overcharging will cause penalties— that does provide incentives for companies to do the right thing.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by vivegi on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:25AM (#36012681)
> UPI has no dispute resolution (as of now)

Not true. [1]

[1]: https://www.npci.org.in/what-we-do/upi/dispute-redressal-mec...

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:31AM (#36012736)
Sure. The process you link to is Indian bureaucracy at its finest. It also focuses on disputes surrounding UPI payments, ie “I paid via UPI and the money didn’t arrive”.

By “dispute resolution”, most people in payments mean “I paid for a chicken, you sent me an egg” type disputes. Or didn’t send anything at all.

That’s hard to deal with in UPI, last I checked. But I could be wrong! But then — why do all these UPI scams keep cropping up?

Or deal with a fraudulent withdrawal (no matter how it happens) by getting a refund with one phone call. The driver for this is that under most consumer-friendly legal systems, the customer gets a near-immediate refund for any unauthorised withdrawal. UPI => no. It’s damned difficult.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by vivegi on Saturday May 20, 2023 @12:48PM (#36013468)
I use UPI daily.

1. In scenarios where UPI is replacing a cash transaction e.g., purchasing fruits from a fruit vendor on the street (just did it a few hours ago), the transaction is immediate. Disputes are settled exactly as how it would be done with a cash transaction i.e., discuss and settle with the vendor in situ.

India had a separate settlement mechanism called Cash-On-Delivery that was needed for companies like Amazon/FlipKart etc., to penetrate the ecommerce space before UPI came into being. Even Amazon does returns and refunds through their online/app-based customer service process.

2. In scenarios where UPI is replacing a credit card e.g., I order food through a food delivery app and an item is missing. The food delivery app provides a customer service option where they are able to resolve the issue (they could a. deliver the missing item at no charge, b. give me a cash coupon for the inconvenience that I can use on their app, c. refuse to resolve the issue). I haven't had a scenario where the service provider has refused to resolve the issue.

3. As far as fraud is concerned, a couple of months ago the local police visited our apartment complex for a brief meeting to educate people on frauds and safety. They focused on digital crimes and told us about the national helpline for cybercrime. [1] Residents can dial 1930 to reach the national cybercrime helpline to report crimes, including online frauds -- this also includes the QR code scams that you hear about in the media. They register the complaint and guide you with the process for recovering lost funds. I haven't done this myself, but what the officer explained is that based on the transaction details, the national cybercrime control center coordinates with the participating banks on both sides of the transaction to immediately freeze funds. You can also take the complaint number to the nearest police station and get an FIR (First Information Report) filed to get the fraudsters criminally prosecuted.

4. In scenarios involving a buyer-seller dispute, there is the consumer protection laws where the consumer can directly file suit against the provider in a consumer court. These are special courts (separate from the civil and criminal courts) and are very effective in protecting consumer rights. This works for all types of consumer disputes about service/product issues.

This would be the last resort for protecting consumer rights even in cases where a credit card company declines to handle a consumer's complaint on technicalities and is not just for UPI. These courts are at the district level in all states. [2]

People in the west and other developed countries have a lot more of their digital transactions occuring on credit/debit cards and are comparing that with UPI. While what UPI is doing overlaps with a lot of that, it also is more than that in enabling micropayments and p2p payments. So, that is of value for the average Indian resident.

[1]: https://cybercrime.gov.in/Webform/Helpline.aspx

[2]: http://ncdrc.nic.in/districtlist.html

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @12:56PM (#36013564)
I don’t dispute most of what you say. I’ll only say that you’re a little optimistic re (3) and (4).

Speak to regular (not well connected) people who’ve been through the justice system. It’s not pretty.

But then maybe you’re lucky enough to live in a state with super responsive police and courts. After all, a lot of this stuff is a state subject and can vary by state.

But the stories of hellish experiences seem to come from all around the country.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by vivegi on Saturday May 20, 2023 @01:20PM (#36013747)
I agree with your statement above. UPI is looking at also getting credit card accounts linked to the NPCI/UPI network in the future. NPCI itself is trying to push RuPay as an alternative to Visa/Mastercard for domestic card payments.

So, a subtle difference from a payment stack perspective is that the consumer protection offered by credit cards is not necessarily a payment stack functionality but a feature of the credit card (just as credit and loyalty points etc., are a function of the credit card).

It is just a slighly different design goal and honestly most users of UPI are okay with it because they favor the cash-replacement offered by UPI.

I will say this though -- the ease of use in UPI is so smooth that if users fail to double check the QR code they have scanned (actually the UPI virtual address) with the vendor and confirm that it is indeed their account (I do it every time), there is a possibility of hackers diverting the funds at the point-of-sale through the use of fake QR codes. This risk is similar to skimming devices installed on PoS machines/ATM machines to steal credit card data.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by colesantiago on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:28AM (#36012713)
Glad to see it.

It makes me sad that there are so many misconceptions about UPI that people are willing to resort to falsehoods (such as CBDCs and privacy) and it shows that most criticisms are from people that haven't used it in the real world.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:35AM (#36012785)
There are misconceptions about UPI all right, but a lot of it is from UPI proponents who have no idea what dispute resolution means.

When you use the term “falsehoods”, keep in mind that a lot of these criticisms come from people who’ve worked in payments for decades, and know a fair bit about customer protection.

If we’re going to talk about falsehoods, we should also talk about the falsehoods UPI proponents share about card payments.

And to be clear, my focus is customer protection. I don’t give a flying fish about the mechanism.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by 1024core on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:31AM (#36012737)
> UPI has no dispute resolution (as of now).

The world is full of jealous fucks who are surprised and shocked that a "backward" country of beggars and snake-charmers was able to come up with UPI.

Recall the NYT cartoon when India launched a mission to Mars: https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/mcs/media/images/78030000/...

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @12:01PM (#36013023)
The UK’s Faster Payments system predates UPI. Free, near-instant payments round the clock. IMPS, the tech that powers UPI, came around 2 years later.

But UPI as a layer on top of IMPS is great, especially the idea of providing an easy you@bank identifier. By contrast Faster Payments is like 102030-12345678. And being designed post iPhone was actually a blessing because it allowed UPI to have a mobile-first deployment strategy.

But UPI also makes a virtue out of necessity: the reality that cards and a protected e-payment mechanism are difficult to organise, especially for India’s less-well off.

This then turns into nationalistic chest thumping about “jealous foreigners”, while completely ignoring real issues around customer protection and scenarios that UPI doesn’t enable.

To be clear: I wish UPI well. I also want to see less opportunities for scammers in UPI and for people to be able to use UPI with confidence knowing they will be easily refunded if things go wrong.

It’s honestly tiresome to have reasoned conversations with nationalistic chest thumpers.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by 1024core on Saturday May 20, 2023 @12:31PM (#36013302)
> It’s honestly tiresome to have reasoned conversations with nationalistic chest thumpers.

You are referring to yourself here, aren't you?

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by 1024core on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:29AM (#36012720)
> UPI has no dispute resolution (as of now).

And cash does??

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:40AM (#36012829)
If UPI competed with cash, that’d be fine. The problem is that UPI enthusiasts think it’s a perfect replacement for cards. It’s not.

Equally, it is a useful alternative to cards. The real world isn’t black and white.

Finally, cash > UPI anytime there’s an internet shutdown. Of which India has an insane number.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by colesantiago on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:50AM (#36012913)
You can use UPI offline:

https://www.gadgetsnow.com/how-to/how-to-pay-online-using-up...

This is what I mean with so many misconceptions, falsehoods and just outright conspiracy theories, from people who have probably never used UPI.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by signal11 on Saturday May 20, 2023 @12:09PM (#36013100)
> you can use UPI offline

Yes, UPI Lite (local offline wallet) has a transaction limit of INR 200. Yes, 200. With a limit of 4000 per day and the Lite wallet can hold 2000 at any one time.

Good luck doing anything serious with that. Also, good luck reloading the wallet when the internet is blocked.

Note: the context of this thread was a UPI vs Cash comparison. Cash is king when the internet isn’t available. UPI Lite notwithstanding.

And for those unfamiliar with Indian context: internet shutdowns happen at the drop of an hat, at a city or sometimes state/part of a state level. For days or longer. In one notorious instance, for multiple months. There’s little oversight, any local authority can make it happen, with little recourse by the public.

They are a massive failure of local governance in India. And getting defensive about it won’t help you in the long run, if you live in India. Sooner or later, you’ll be affected too.

Re:A digital payments revolution in India by alephnerd on Saturday May 20, 2023 @02:29PM (#36014379)
> They are a massive failure of local governance in India. And getting defensive about it won’t help you in the long run, if you live in India. Sooner or later, you’ll be affected too.

Yep. Welfare Schemes are distributed via UPI, and internet shutdowns often affect regions where there are a number of residents who are eligible for welfare schemes like MGNREGA, PMSBY, etc.

Look at Manipur for example or portions of UP during law and order flairups.

That said, in my ancestral village it is being used as a cash alternative. Almost no one there is eligible for a credit card, and "payment disputes" are resolved with lathis or bandhs.