News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by lotsofpulp on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:52PM (#35995365)
Yes, that is what public domain is. What reason is there for society to give RR Martin more than 10 years of copyright protection? He is free to shop around his story to movie makers in that time. And if it is so good, someone will jump on it.

After that, it is not “exploitation”, it is using something in the public domain.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by jjcon on Saturday May 20, 2023 @01:15AM (#36009552)
> And if it is so good, someone will jump on it

No they will just wait for the timer to tick away and monopolize on a community that someone else spent years building. Just because you change the law in your thought experiment for it to be legal doesn’t make it not exploitative. If we legalize slavery you can’t just say, “well its no longer exploitative, its the law”

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 20, 2023 @09:08AM (#36011644)
People do not “own” communities that they have a right to profit from indefinitely.

And yes, if it is good, people will jump on it. Evidence being that HBO did not wait 170 years to start making game of thrones. They saw a story they could sell, so they paid the author to make it. If they did not, another media maker could and would have. Warner brothers did not wait until Harry Potter copyrights expire. I am sure other media makers were bidding for Harry Potter rights too.

Of course, Martin and Rowling have been paid less if copyright was 10 years. But would they have written the stories if they earned $10M instead of $100M or $1B or whatever they earned? I would err on the side of yes.