News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by latch on Thursday February 16, 2012 @10:57AM (#3599192)
Paul Vick, whose name appears on the patent, had a great blog post about this. Had to dig it out of archive.org: https://gist.github.com/1846067

FWIW, as much as I hate[d] VB.NET, Paul Vick was (is?) clearly a superstar - both in terms of coding and writing.

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by sriramk on Thursday February 16, 2012 @12:45PM (#3599782)
Disclaimer: ex-MSFT, have several patents pending from during my time there.

His blog post reminds me why I get so mad at Microsoft using patents against Android OEMs. During all my years at MSFT, employees were always told that patents were necessary for the reasons Paul Vick stated - you had people like Eolas and zillions of other trolls trying to get you and you needed a portfolio to play defence.

With the Android issue, that changed. MSFT suddenly started using patents offensively as a strategic tool. While I totally get why this is smart ( and I'm stunned at how effective it has been), I feel they violated an implicit social contract with a lot of people who worked to get them those patents.

It's going to be interesting to see whether Google does the same swerve down the line and not just stick to using patents in defence.

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by iclelland on Thursday February 16, 2012 @03:31PM (#3600519)
> During all my years at MSFT, employees were always told that patents were necessary for the reasons Paul Vick stated - you had people like Eolas and zillions of other trolls trying to get you and you needed a portfolio to play defence.

No, that can't be right. I hope you're just misremembering that, but the whole problem with patent trolls is that you can't use your own portfolio for defense.

A large patent portfolio is a good weapon against other giants in your industry: IBM, Apple, Oracle, Google, (and once upon a time) Sun. Those people basically can't sue you for violating one of their patents if you have several thousand of your own: they're bound to be in violation of at least one of yours, and it's a mutually-assured-destruction scenario.

A patent troll, on the other hand, doesn't do anything. They can sue you with relative impunity, since there's almost no chance that they're doing anything that you can use against them. The size of your own patent portfolio doesn't even enter the picture.

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by redthrowaway on Thursday February 16, 2012 @04:42PM (#3600788)
There's two ways you can use patents for defense:

1) patent it before the other guy does, so the troll has nothing to sue you with, and

2) patent everything and hope that one of your patents overlaps with the troll's.

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by asmithmd1 on Thursday February 16, 2012 @05:13PM (#3600938)
There is another strategy - just publish your invention for all to see rendering it un-patentable.

IBM of all people used to do this for ideas they did not think were worth patenting. By publishing them they stopped anyone else from getting a patent on those ideas. IBM published a magazine for 40 years that is a treasure trove of prior art: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Technical_Disclosure_Bullet...

Now anyone can do defensive publication on this site

http://priorartdatabase.com/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_publication

I used this strategy with some GPS cell phone ideas I had in 2003 and I "published" them myself

http://web.archive.org/web/20031211124028/http://www.gadgete...

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by redthrowaway on Thursday February 16, 2012 @05:28PM (#3601003)
Unfortunately, that (rather noble) act is untenable in a world where everyone's suing everyone in the big boy department. If Apple and Microsoft weren't trying to kill Android with lawsuits, I could see a gentleman's agreement between the lot of them making this a fairly effective strategy. With the current state of affairs, everyone needs all the linked list patents they can get.
Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by asmithmd1 on Thursday February 16, 2012 @05:42PM (#3601045)
I see it less as being noble and more of a practical strategy for a small business. You can't afford to apply for a patent on everything you think up so why not publish it so at least you will not be locked out of using your own idea by someone who comes along later and does apply for a patent.
Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by betterth on Thursday February 16, 2012 @02:51PM (#3600337)
"It's going to be interesting to see whether Google does the same swerve down the line and not just stick to using patents in defence."

Google is already swerving. They're interested in utilizing the Moto patent portfolio to implement 2.25% of total device cost fees on FRAND patents.

In fact, they're already moving forward with that against Apple, which would net them (based on Q42011 sales) over $500,000,000 a quarter, or in the $1.5-2.0B per year on the iPhone alone.

It's no wonder Google is moving forward: That's likely as much or more money than they make on their own Android OS!

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by abrahamsen on Thursday February 16, 2012 @03:36PM (#3600529)
Apple and Motorola is suing each other. The 2.25% claim against Apple is from Motorola. Google has stated that they do not intend to drop it. Even if Google were unselfish angels, dropping their claim without getting a cross license agreement first would be plain silly.
Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by betterth on Thursday March 01, 2012 @03:02PM (#3653758)
Doesn't matter. Google signed off on it, Google supports it. Don't try to let Google dodge the bullet.

When presented with a portfolio of patents, Google behaved not like it has spent years telling everyone they should behave, but instead exactly like they have long since fought against.

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by MoMo999 on Thursday February 16, 2012 @06:16PM (#3601180)
"...I feel they violated an implicit social contract..."

Violated what? LOL...Patents are for protecting you from infringement, so you retort/attack when you're patents are abused...What the hell is Apple doing when Samsung/Google got "inspiration" from the iPhone?

MS is built on selling Software and protecting it is their responsibility to their Shareholders!

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by marssaxman on Thursday February 16, 2012 @11:50AM (#3599497)
Totally agree; I went to Microsoft and joined the VB.NET team in no small part because he worked there.

(Didn't work out so well: he left a couple of months later, and that job turned into a nightmare for other reasons.)

Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by danabramov on Thursday February 16, 2012 @04:43PM (#3600794)
Just wondering if you can elaborate on what made your job a nightmare.
Re:Microsoft's 2003 patent application for the "Is Not" oper... by gkn on Thursday February 16, 2012 @05:01PM (#3600878)
Paul Vick made a new blog post about this today http://panopticoncentral.net/2012/02/16/software-patents-rev...