That's genius!
Neat idea, same with carplay, having it reliably imitate the voice of the person who sent the message would make it a lot nicer.
Though they would need to get all the TTS and intonation right first, which IME is not the case, I think having the right voice but the wrong intonation entirely would be one hell of an uncanny valley.
There's already some version of this in "Hey Siri" detection -- if I record myself with a prompt and play it back, my HomePod briefly wakes up at the "Hey Siri" but turns off mid-prompt. I guessed it was some loudspeaker detection using the microphone array, but it could be a mix of both?
And then you can use voice to text to text her back, and she can hear it in your voice! It's just like a phone call from 30 years ago, but one that requires infinitely more processing power!
There are folks who couldn’t, for a variety of reasons, do that thirty years ago. This feature is for them. The rest of us get to e.g. more naturally text a response to a call we’re listening into on a flight.
Voice memos? No. I would have to, at some point, speak it. If you’re referring to text-to-speech, there is a difference between having your speech read in a different voice and your own.
And latency!
See it as data compression on the wire.
It's worth noting this is already how iPhones work and people already love it. What I'm suggesting additionally is substituting Siri's voice for a DIFFERENT customized synthetic voice in a very specific circumstance. I'm not advocating for using synthetic voices where there currently aren't any here.
Disagree that it's the same at all. Sending discrete messages at your leisure is quite a different experience than a real-time conversation.
Other consequences of this feature:
- typos and autocorrect become even more hilarious
- you can still use her voice after you break up; heck, you probably don't ever need to date the person
- at this point: why wouldn't you pick Scarlett Johansson?
Which is potentially quite problematic as you could abuse this for all sorts of social engineering purposes.
This vector was recently highlighted as a weakness of the Australian "Voiceprint" system(1)
It's also an excellent point to make that these tools can be useful for everyone. I find myself using a number of the accessibility tools simply to speed up some of my common interactions with the phone and watch.
I've also noticed that these technologies end up in other products. For example livetext is now a standard feature on macOS/iOS yet it's an accessibility feature originating in the screenreader to deal with text flattened in images. This technology sharing also gives us a bit of a preview of what they're working on (e.g. AR)
(1) https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/mar/16/voice-sys...
Live Speech: I actually answer unknown phone numbers (usually) and would like text-to-speech on my calls because I've started to get concerned about what can be done, fraud-wise, with even small samples of my voice. So in this case, using another's voice is fine, even preferred. (Edit: I suppose I'd actually prefer a voice-changer here, which is less related to this accessibility feature. But I think Apple is unlikely to do that.)
Personal Voice: When my girlfriend texts me when I'm out with my AirPods, I think we'd both like me to hear her message in her actual voice rather than Siri's. This feature doesn't allow for that yet, but the pieces are all there.
Finally, Apple needs to detect and tell me when I'm listening to a synthetic voice, including when it's not being generated by Apple. There's fraud potential here. I'm clearly excited about this tech, but I want to know more on this front.