News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by bilqis on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @07:27AM (#35960290)
They say they don’t
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by az226 on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @07:41AM (#35960428)
I’m sure you think this is a clever reply but the reality is that GitHub wouldn’t even begin to think if that were even technically possible. If it got out that it trained on confidential customer data, it would be game over. The risk is so stupidly large nobody in their right mind would take it. So yeah, if they say they don’t, they don’t.
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by account42 on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @12:05PM (#35963792)
Yet its ok to train of copyleft code?
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by aleph_minus_one on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @01:07PM (#35964745)
Copyleft code is (typically) not confidential.
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by esrauch on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @07:39AM (#35960408)
Why would they possibly lie about that?
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by ChatGTP on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @07:48AM (#35960496)
Because they do shady shit, like, by default Copilot would "sample" code for training while using it. Maybe this is no longer the default, maybe it still is, but it was the default.

This type of thing erodes trust? Why should my proprietary code be used for training by default?

I was really annoyed by this.

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by scrollaway on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @08:03AM (#35960633)
OpenAI is not the same company as GitHub, and it has always been pretty clear that chats on ChatGPT are recorded and used for training (unless you now opt out).
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by ChatGTP on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @08:14AM (#35960757)
Not sure why you're bringing OpenAI into it. My comment and the article is about "Copilot"

I'm talking about when using "Github Copilot" and you ask for a code suggestion, it would send the "context" back to GitHub / Microsoft and use that code as training.

Your comment is interesting to me though because there does seem to be a surprisingly large amount of defending OpenAI going on. Almost seems automatic now.

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by EwanToo on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @08:27AM (#35960895)
Because Github Copilot is an interface into OpenAI Codex:

"GitHub Copilot is powered by OpenAI Codex, a new AI system created by OpenAI."

https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/overview-of-github-copilo...

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by semiquaver on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @09:22AM (#35961526)
> it would send the "context" back to GitHub / Microsoft

Because this is fundamentally how the system works. The context is the prompt.

> and use that code as training

This part has never been true. It’s not how these systems work. Do you have anything to back up your claim?

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by unreal37 on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @07:45AM (#35960466)
I don't understand why people just automatically doubt things that companies say when they can be sued (or would otherwise destroy their business) if they are lying about it. Seems unnecessarily pessimistic.
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by yulaow on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @08:23AM (#35960856)
I mean, we discovered that the whole car industry was lying flagrantly on their emission tests which had the potential of destroying the whole business and there were A LOT of people who knew about it and could talk anytime

Why wouldn't sw companies do the same?

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by phpisthebest on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @09:01AM (#35961287)
And how many of those companies were materially impacted or had more than a couple quarters of negative consumer backlash?

None.... so the grandparents comment is with out evidence that either consumers or regulators hold companies to account

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by bilqis on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @08:05AM (#35960646)
But will that actually be against ToS or copyright? Many people tend to say that copilot learning from OSS doesn’t infringe any copyright and is no different from a person just learning from someone else’s work. So how is it different if copilot is learning from private repositories? Or eg from leaked source code?
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by circuit10 on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @09:10AM (#35961377)
Isn’t it illegal to learn from leaked source code? Or even to view it at all?
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by alwaysbeconsing on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @11:50AM (#35963527)
It is not, at least in the US. Distribution is illegal; possession may or may not be prosecuted; and if you read the code and provably reuse it or make use of trade secrets you could lose a lawsuit. But if you "somehow" have access and don't do anything associated with the code, the basic act of reading it carries no penalties.
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by Timwi on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @12:18PM (#35963992)
I fully expect the answer to this vary wildly from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by nindalf on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @08:07AM (#35960677)
I'm frequently told on HN that Big Tech would willingly, flagrantly violate GDPR like its nothing. Even if the upside of collecting that info was minimal and the downside was 4% of global revenue.

I guess if they can do that, then what's a small lie about private repos between friends.

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by sshumaker on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @10:30AM (#35962403)
I’m fairly confident this is untrue. At Microsoft at least, it’s a big deal when there is a privacy issue, even a small localized one on a single product - and creates a small firestorm.

We’ll get engineers working long hours focused on it, consulting closely with our legal and trust teams. One of the first questions we ask legal when we suspect a privacy issue is “Is this a notifiable event?”

It’s not really about getting slapped by regulators - it’s the fact that much of Microsoft’s business is built by earning the trust of large companies and small ones. Many of them are in the EU of course, but we have strict compliance we apply broadly. It’s just not worth damaging our reputation (and hurting our business) for some shortcut somewhere, as trust takes a long time to build and is easily broken.

Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by phpisthebest on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @08:59AM (#35961267)
Normally because history shows us that redress via the court systems is rarely punitive to a company the size of Microsoft, further Microsoft has a long history of lying to its customers with seemingly no impact on its business.
Re:Why are there no antitrust claims vs. GitHub Copilot, whe... by Lio on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @10:22AM (#35962300)
People doubt Microsoft because they've historically run a very aggressive business and done things of questionable morality many times.

They've been to court and they've lost and it definitely hasn't destroyed their business one bit.

For example, Microsoft subsidiary LinkedIn routed customer email through their servers so that they could scrape it. They did that without customer knowledge via a dark patten.

They later apologised for doing it but still used it to propel the company's growth. In the end it didn't hurt anything but their reputation for respecting people's privacy.

Microsoft's own anti-trust history is littered with exceptional behaviour too. They are the size they are now by dint of super aggressive business practices.