News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Get Started Making Music by antmaper on Monday May 15, 2023 @08:51PM (#35956522)
Ableton Live, while a respected tool in music production, appears to be falling behind in terms of embracing new technologies and features.
Re:Get Started Making Music by dcist on Monday May 15, 2023 @09:33PM (#35956792)
Who is pulling ahead?
Re:Get Started Making Music by dottjt on Monday May 15, 2023 @09:44PM (#35956873)
Bitwig, by far.

It's more-or-less the same program (made by ex-Ableton devs), just well designed for 2023.

With that said, Ableton has the advantage of being more mature. What I mean by that, is that the stock plugins are generally better, and it has a bigger use-base, which I would argue is important if you're starting out.

If on the other hand you're a medium/advanced user, then Bitwig is a much better choice.

Re:Get Started Making Music by morserer on Monday May 15, 2023 @09:48PM (#35956903)
Check out Bitwig and the Bitwig Grid. Made by some of the Ableton devs who ditched the company to make their own DAW.
Re:Get Started Making Music by dkh on Monday May 15, 2023 @08:52PM (#35956528)
How so?
Re:Get Started Making Music by dottjt on Monday May 15, 2023 @09:42PM (#35956855)
I've switched from Ableton to Bitwig and man, you don't realise how behind Ableton is until you try Bitwig.

I think it's a case of death by a thousand cuts with Ableton. For example, Ableton does not have customisable shortcuts! Which is a huge workflow blocker.

Arguably, a lot of the issues are UX related, as opposed to feature related. But UX is a core part of the product and subsequent usability of the product.

Re:Get Started Making Music by notmypenguin on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @05:08AM (#35959311)
Meh, I disagree. I’ve owned Bitwig for about a year now and there are some frustrations with it I didn’t have with Ableton. Nothing is perfect, neither is ahead of the other. If I wasn’t on Linux I would go back to Ableton, to be honest. Bitwig has the synthesizer thing and effects thing down pat, but it’s audio editing is frustrating to say the least. I want to turn of this track comping nonsense but I can’t, I hate track comping and have used DAWs since they were invented so…
Re:Get Started Making Music by dottjt on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @04:36PM (#35980953)
You can turn off track comping, you need to turn off the overdub button (that big plus sign in the top left).

What parts of the audio editing is weak to you? In my opinion, it's one of the strongest things it offers. I assume you're trying to edit the audio in the arranger, instead of in the clip view. What makes it so strong, is that you can chop it up in the clip view, and your audio in the arranger remains one contiguous piece of audio.

It sounds like you're either trying to use the software like Ableton and you're getting frustrated that it's not Ableton, or you don't understand how Bitwig works.

Re:Get Started Making Music by moth-fuzz on Monday May 15, 2023 @10:05PM (#35957025)
I think ARA2 is the big thing for me. Melodyne and VocAlign would be a huge step up for Ableton since it doesn't have any native pitch correction (despite having top-class time correction). I keep trying to go back to Ableton since I love the 'jammability' of the environment, but when I actually want to sit down and compose, record, mix, and actually release something, I head for Studio One or another linear DAW that has those features. I mean, it only just got comping a couple releases ago.

I also dislike the 1 track = 1 instrument = 1 mixer channel workflow. I have a lot of outboard synths and they're midi-chained on different channels and summed into my audio interface. I also have multitimbral synth modules and VSTs, but Ableton is very idealist in its design, assuming I have exactly 1 midi track and 1 audio insert for every 'sound'.

Also, personal gripe, but the reverbs don't cut it even on an entry-level, they're just awful

I can definitely get over these issues, none of them are dealbreakers, but Ableton keeps trying to be a 'performance-oriented' DAW but really I think they could benefit from taking a cue from the other linear DAWs out there!