Re:Kafka vs. Redpanda Performance – Do the claims add up?
by comet-engine on Monday May 15, 2023 @12:19PM
(#35950652)
I had to go to the repo to see the benchmarking setup to get an answer. Looks like 3 Kafka nodes.
https://github.com/Vanlightly/openmessaging-benchmark-custom...
Re:Kafka vs. Redpanda Performance – Do the claims add up?
by jvanlightly on Monday May 15, 2023 @12:21PM
(#35950689)
Author here. Yes both Kafka and Redpanda were deployed on identical hardware: three i3en.6xlarge.
Re:Kafka vs. Redpanda Performance – Do the claims add up?
by jpgvm on Monday May 15, 2023 @12:11PM
(#35950549)
I'm not sure which of us read it correctly.
I -think- they are saying the original benchmark results done by RedPanda show a 9 node Kafka cluster being beaten by a 3 node RP cluster.
This new benchmark I assume is being done on identical hardware just with less terrible Kafka settings.
Re:Kafka vs. Redpanda Performance – Do the claims add up?
by globalreset on Monday May 15, 2023 @12:18PM
(#35950635)
I'm confused because it's never clarified, and it starts with:
> According to their Redpanda vs Kafka benchmark and their Total Cost of Ownership analysis, if you have a 1 GB/s workload, you only need three i3en.6xlarge instances with Redpanda, whereas Apache Kafka needs nine and still has poor performance.
but scanning it again, I think they are in fact doing 3 node vs 3 node benchmark. It's just a bit unclear.
Re:Kafka vs. Redpanda Performance – Do the claims add up?
by AtNightWeCode on Monday May 15, 2023 @01:55PM
(#35951999)
Surely nobody runs 3 Kafka nodes in production, no?
Does this benchmark compare both 3 node Kafka against 3 node Redpanda cluster? It's unclear.