News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How ‘open’ should your open source be? by ksec on Sunday May 14, 2023 @09:12AM (#35937689)
Unpopular Opinion.

>> Johnson closed the project to contributions in January 2021, explaining in a section of the README titled "Open-Source, not Open-Contribution" that dealing with even small code contributions was too time-consuming.

Well according to comments on HN and Twitter from around 2016 - 2022. The rarely disputed ( Or disputed but downvoted ) definition of Open Sources means building a community around the project. If it doesn't accept outside contribution and the code doesn't give back and stays within the community ( ~GPL ) it is not true open source.

So I am glad How "open" could open source be is finally back on the table of discussions. But it is sad as it is often the case most people learn it the hard way.

Re:How ‘open’ should your open source be? by zozbot234 on Sunday May 14, 2023 @09:26AM (#35937766)
If the license for the code gives the users' community the right to fork (as with every legitimate FLOSS license) that's enough. Whether to accept outside countributions or not is simply a maintainership concern, that can be addressed by forking the project. For instance, the current GCC project is the outcome of what was originally a fork (Egcs) since the original GCC project was perceived as not being open to outside contributors.
Re:How ‘open’ should your open source be? by onlypositive on Sunday May 14, 2023 @09:20AM (#35937730)
open-source /əʊp(ə)nˈsɔːs/ adjective denoting software for which the original source code is made freely available and may be redistributed and modified

Adding community to this definition is a stretch.

It really doesn't matter if in practice communities form around projects, there are far more open source repositories on GitHub that have zero outside contributions, those projects are still open source.

[dead]
Re:How ‘open’ should your open source be? by onlypositive on Monday May 15, 2023 @05:04AM (#35945437)
I stopped caring what those people think a decade ago.