News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by myshpa on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:30AM (#35917622)
One of the leading reasons why we're in such deep mess are our systems of food production, esp. animal agriculture (75% of agriculture lands, uses more land than forests) & fishing.

- The majority of deforestation (particularly in the Amazon), is driven by livestock farming. By reducing demand for animal products, we could slow or even reverse the trend of habitat destruction, thus preserving biodiversity.

- Growing plants to feed animals and then consuming those animals is an inefficient way of obtaining calories and nutrients. Shifting to a plant-based diet would allow us to feed more people with less land, reducing the pressure on wild habitats.

- Animal agriculture is a significant contributor to greenhouse gas emissions.

- Overfishing is a major threat to marine biodiversity. By reducing our consumption of fish, we can help protect marine ecosystems.

- Animal agriculture is also a significant source of pollution, including runoff from farms that can create dead zones in oceans and rivers, harming aquatic species.

- Intensive animal farming can create conditions ripe for the emergence of new diseases (zoonotic diseases), some of which could potentially leap to humans and cause pandemics, as well as decimate animal populations.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by Aromasin on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:39AM (#35917756)
To add some additional point to yours on animal waste, "barnyard run-off" into our water supplies has led to rapid degradation of our lakes, rivers, oceans, and ground water. Nitrogen, phosphorus, and pathogens are the most common water pollutants from manure. Nitrates that leave Minnesota through the Mississippi River add to the Gulf of Mexico dead zone. Added nitrates cause an excess of ocean plants and algae to grow. When the plants and algae die, they are decomposed by bacteria that use up dissolved oxygen. This causes areas of low oxygen to form where ocean plants and animals cannot live. Phosphorus is a major concern because it causes excessive plant and algae growth in lakes and rivers. This causes an oxygen-depleting reaction similar to what happens in the Gulf of Mexico dead zone. E. coli, Cryptosporidium, and Giardia are just a few pathogens that can cause serious health problems in people and animals that come in contact with contaminated water.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by renewiltord on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:32AM (#35917645)
The real difference will be made by abolishing Europe's cities and returning that entire continent to Nature. All the forests and animals should be restored and the cities razed.

Extant emissions from the people there dwarf the Amazon's deforestation so it's a much better fix.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by PeterisP on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:40AM (#35917772)
Europe has been and still is re-foresting, it's much more forested than 100 or 300 years ago, and in the last 30 years there has been a 9% increase in forested areas (https://resoilfoundation.org/en/environment/eu-forests-growt...)
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by renewiltord on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:49AM (#35917887)
In Roman times, Germany had 70% forest cover. Conveniently chosen timelines of the last 100 years after half of all forest cover was razed are all very nice but ultimately, the Earth pays the price.

What the Germans did then, the Brazilians do a fraction of now.

40% forest cover lost. And now, Germany has almost no primary forest. And Germans burn oil and coal and gas like no other.

The net effect of Germany on the Climate is the effect of an Environmental WMD.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:57AM (#35918009)
Whatever biodiversity (and therefore whatever resilience) was lost by the destruction of Europe's forests is gone forever. There are important species in the Amazon that can still be saved.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by renewiltord on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:11PM (#35918212)
That's fair. Europe should therefore pay Earth Reparations to those who have the opportunity to preserve the Earth. While Europe cannot afford to make good, she can try to hit the market clearing price to keep the Amazon unperturbed. This will likely be a debt never successfully paid, but sufficient hundreds of billions every year will likely work.

What we need is a Green Treaty of Versailles.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:22PM (#35918342)
Materially, helping is helping whatever the reason. But rhetoric matters. You're going to get a lot more participation if you're trying to make the world a liveable place for the children being born right now, and a lot less participation if you're trying to get people to pay off a debt taken out by their ancestors.

Thinking in terms of money and debt is what got us into this situation. I'm doubtful that it will get us out of it.

In fact, turning our backs on the logic of the market is probably part of the fix. We need a jubilee so that the people made powerful by causing these problems aren't powerful anymore.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by renewiltord on Friday May 12, 2023 @01:20PM (#35919125)
A jubilee would only help those who caused these problems since they've reaped the rewards. I, too, would like all my debts forgiven while I retain the profits.

Typical of discourse today is to let off the societies that industrialized first with no complaint while simultaneously moralizing against those who are industrializing now.

Europe hoards nuclear technology and won't share it with the developing world. Europe burns oil and gas and coal in vast quantities to live. All while Europe says that all past carbon emissions must be considered forgiven debt and all present carbon emissions must be considered sin.

The developing world will do as Europe did to get to Europe's standard of living. The developing world will not listen to the moralizing of Europeans who won't do their part. And Europeans can clutch their pearls about the Amazon, but the people who live there will raze it for industry just as the Europeans did. And it will be right.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday May 12, 2023 @01:34PM (#35919324)
> A jubilee would only help those who caused these problems since they've reaped the rewards

Maybe jubilee wasn't the right word. I'm saying we stop accepting money for money's sake. So the reaped rewards would no longer be valuable.

Instead we need a system backed by something auditable, so that when a stranger offers it to you, you can investigate and decide if you actually value the activity that created it. Thus creating an incentive to work on projects that are more solution than problem.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by 0xBombadilo on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:46AM (#35917837)
>Growing plants to feed animals and then consuming those animals is an inefficient way of obtaining calories and nutrients. Shifting to a plant-based diet would allow us to feed more people with less land, reducing the pressure on wild habitats.

Not true. Ruminant grazing animals (like cows) use land that generally is not fit for farming plants that humans would consume. They make land productive that otherwise would not be. Also, farming for the staples of plant-based diets annihilates animal life. In order to farm soy beans or whatever plant you eat, you have to tear up the soil and in doing so you will kill every ground squirrel, ground nesting bird, snake, vole, groundhog and rabbit that lives in that plot. Then you have to spray chemical pesticides that will annihilate anything you haven't already mechanically killed with the combine. Not to mention ruminant grazers enhance the soil through their compaction, manure and urine while plant farming has to constantly add external fertilizer to maintain yields.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by myshpa on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:53AM (#35917947)
Wow.

> grazing animals use land that generally is not fit for farming plants ... make land productive that otherwise would not be

Not every land has to be "productive". This thinking got us where we are.

> In order to farm soy beans or whatever plant you eat, you have to tear up the soil and in doing so you will kill every ground squirrel, ground nesting bird ...

Crop fields do indeed disrupt the habitats of wild animals, and wild animals are also killed when harvesting plants. However, this point makes the case for a plant-based diet and not against it, since many more plants are required to produce a measure of animal flesh for food (often as high as 12:1) than are required to produce an equal measure of plants for food (which is obviously 1:1). Because of this, a plant-based diet causes less suffering and death than one that includes animals.

https://yourveganfallacyis.com/en/vegans-kill-animals-too

> Then you have to spray chemical pesticides that will annihilate anything

Dtto.

> Not to mention ruminant grazers enhance the soil through their compaction, manure and urine

Use compost / compost tea / companion / nitrogen fixing plants.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by 0xBombadilo on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:24PM (#35918371)
This is your brain on veganism. You have no concept of how cattle are actually raised. They are grazed on grassland. No farmer is cultivating food plots of soy beans and bringing them to the cattle. You are thinking of feedlots which cattle go to before slaughter where they are fed corn or soy for a short period of time in order to fatten them up. The existence of a feedlot does not change the fact that for the vast majority of the animal's life it is on a grassland eating grass that would otherwise just grow and die in the winter. The vast majority of the energy that goes into growing cattle would otherwise go completely unused without them. That is why ruminants are special. They turn grass into protein, which is necessary for life, especially brain function. You just want to eat your disgusting soyburger and treat it as some kind of penance so you can then parade around as if you are morally better than people who eat meat. Sorry, we will never stop eating meat and you will never acknowledge the reality that ruminant grazing is good for the environment. You will never consider why there were tens of millions of ruminant bison covering North America for thousands of years. They were a tool of the balance of nature that helped the ecosystem. Keep killing small animals and pretending you're better than everyone else. It will work out really great for you.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by myshpa on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:35PM (#35918521)
> You have no concept of how cattle are actually raised. They are grazed on grassland. No farmer is cultivating food plots of soy beans and bringing them to the cattle. You are thinking of feedlots which cattle go to before slaughter where they are fed corn or soy for a short period of time in order to fatten them up.

While it's true that cattle are often raised on grasslands, the global demand for beef has led to many operations utilizing grain-based feedlots, which do have environmental implications. It's estimated that about a third of the Earth's arable land is used to grow crops for animal feed.

Furthermore, the conversion of forests and other natural habitats to grassland for cattle grazing is a significant driver of deforestation and biodiversity loss, particularly in places like the Amazon.

> The existence of a feedlot does not change the fact that for the vast majority of the animal's life it is on a grassland eating grass that would otherwise just grow and die in the winter. The vast majority of the energy that goes into growing cattle would otherwise go completely unused without them. That is why ruminants are special. They turn grass into protein, which is necessary for life, especially brain function.

Indeed, ruminants play a unique role in converting grass into protein. However, the issue isn't as straightforward as just utilizing grasslands. The environmental footprint of raising cattle, even on grasslands, includes water use, greenhouse gas emissions, and land degradation. This, combined with the growing global demand for meat, creates a sustainability challenge that cannot be overlooked.

> You just want to eat your disgusting soyburger and treat it as some kind of penance so you can then parade around as if you are morally better than people who eat meat. Sorry, we will never stop eating meat and you will never acknowledge the reality that ruminant grazing is good for the environment.

It's not about moral superiority but about finding sustainable and ethical ways to meet our nutritional needs. While ruminant grazing can have some environmental benefits, it's not universally "good" for the environment given the issues like:

- Greenhouse gas emissions

- Deforestation

- Land degradation

- Water pollution

- Water overconsumption

- Loss of biodiversity

- Antibiotic resistance

- Ocean dead zones

- Inefficient land and resource use

- Ethical concerns regarding animal welfare

- Contribution to zoonotic diseases

- Air pollution

- Eutrophication

- Soil erosion

- High energy consumption

- Chemical runoff from pesticides and fertilizers

- Destruction of habitats and ecosystems

- Inequality in global food distribution

- Public health risks from foodborne illnesses

- Nutrient pollution

- Strain on waste management systems

> You will never consider why there were tens of millions of ruminant bison covering North America for thousands of years. They were a tool of the balance of nature that helped the ecosystem.

The comparison between modern cattle farming and historic bison populations is not entirely valid. Bison roamed freely, contributed to nutrient cycling, and didn't contribute to the same environmental problems associated with large-scale livestock farming.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dennis_jeeves1 on Friday May 12, 2023 @06:26PM (#35923296)
I have posted a poll here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35923261

What would your response be to my question 1) and question 2)

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dmbche on Friday May 12, 2023 @04:35PM (#35922003)
For anyone reading this, for having seen and chatted with a farmer raising AAA Angus beef for McDonalds, everything the above commenter is saying is wrong.

The beef are in lots as soon as they are taken from their mothers and are fed from soy and other crops.

Most of the beef production is not fed grass - or it is a byproduct of giving them access to outside, but isn't their main nutrition.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dennis_jeeves1 on Friday May 12, 2023 @06:26PM (#35923290)
I have posted a poll here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35923261

What would your response be to my question 1) and question 2)

Sidenote: I am with you as to what happens to the brains of vegans :)

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by AlexandrB on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:53AM (#35917949)
Ruminant grazing on natural grasslands is not sufficient to meet the demand for meat. This is why chunks of the Amazon are burned down to create more land for raising livestock. And raising crops for people is much more efficient (in terms of calories per acre) than raising those same crops for animals. Any arguments highlighting the destructive effects of industrial crop farming apply ~10x for meat since much of the meat we eat is raised on soy and other feed crops.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by Timon3 on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:50AM (#35917902)
>> Growing plants to feed animals and then consuming those animals is an inefficient way of obtaining calories and nutrients. Shifting to a plant-based diet would allow us to feed more people with less land, reducing the pressure on wild habitats.

> Not true. Ruminant grazing animals (like cows) use land that generally is not fit for farming plants that humans would consume.

You are arguing a different point from GP. They were talking about growing and farming animal food, feeding that to the animals, and then eating the animals. You're talking about feeding animals directly from the land.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by 0xBombadilo on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:25PM (#35918381)
GP doesn't understand how cattle ranching works.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by Timon3 on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:35PM (#35918528)
How much cattle do you think lives free-range compared to how much doesn't?
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:54AM (#35917955)
> They make land productive that otherwise would not be.

Productive according to our fictions re: "value", destructive according to the ecology of systems that we rely on for survival.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by 0xBombadilo on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:27PM (#35918414)
>ecololgy

Why were there tens of millions of bison in North America before human development?

>value

This entire discussion is about the proper use of land. That discussion is impossible without some notion of value, or highest and best use. Any other consideration just ends in "all humans should die". If that's your position then its a waste of time even discussing the situation with you.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:57PM (#35918870)
I'm not saying that grazing animals are a problem, I'm saying that markets and regulators are doing a bad job of managing their location and population size, and that wolves would do it better. Those markets and regulators have a certain values system: they want certain numbers to go up, certain people to be re-elected, etc.

Most humans also want their grandchildren to grow up in an environment that isn't teetering on collapse--which is not something that the dominant values system is considering. So my issue with "value" is not that it's useless, but that we're using it in a way that fails to acknowledge that different people value different outcomes. We're instead encouraged to seek value of an unspecified type and leave it to other people to decided which outcomes actually result from that seeking. It's a sort of blindness and it's leading us off a cliff.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by MadSudaca on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:48AM (#35917866)
> Growing plants to feed animals and then consuming those animals is an inefficient way of obtaining calories and nutrients. Shifting to a plant-based diet would allow us to feed more people with less land, reducing the pressure on wild habitats.

Regarding this point, it's important to remember that animals have the ability to transform materials we can't get any sustenance from, because they're not edible, into food. To get the idea, think how pigs have been historically such a popular food in many countries. They would basically eat anything, the owners get the pig fat, then they eat the pig.

Another thing to remember is that proteins coming from vegetables are low quality compared to their animal counterparts. For the great majority of the world population a vegan diet is inaccessible. You simply don't get all the nutrients you need from vegetables alone. Friends who maintain a vegan diet for ideological reasons have to supplement it with a heavy dose of pills and other compounds lest they have have problem maintaining their energy levels, even if they have calorie rich diets.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by myshpa on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:16PM (#35918261)
> Regarding this point ... they eat the pig.

I'm aware. Not necessary in 21st century (in most of the world).

> proteins coming from vegetables are low quality

Protein "quality" relates to the presence of essential amino acids. Animal proteins contain all nine essential amino acids and are thus considered "complete."

Plant proteins often lack one or more essential amino acids. However, they aren't "low quality" - you just need to consume a variety of plant proteins (like legumes, nuts, seeds, whole grains) to get all the essential amino acids.

This process is called protein combining. As long as you're eating a varied diet throughout the day, your body can assemble the necessary amino acids. Plus, plant proteins provide other nutritional benefits like fiber and antioxidants (as opposed to inflamation-inducing effects of meat and dairy).

> Friends who maintain a vegan diet for ideological reasons have to supplement it with a heavy dose of pills ...

Also not true - only B12 is necessary. It's often a part of animal feed anyway, so why not skip the intermediary.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by MadSudaca on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:32PM (#35918492)
They are low quality precisely because they are less rich in types of amino acids. Given the option of having animal or vegetable-based proteins you would always pick animal, all other things being equal.

Having a “varied” diet is much easier said than done. Even people who are well off, living in rich and developed countries have difficulty maintaining this balance. This is a personal observation, but I suspect a lot of people underestimate how hard it is to maintain this lifestyle.

Another aspect that I don’t see discussed anywhere is that you need to have diversity of vegetables just to maintain a functional diet, what will happen to people when for some reason there are problems in the supply chain of a specific crop, you have a bad year with low yields and the price goes to the roof?

Another false assumption is that everyone can accommodate a purely plant-based diet.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:38PM (#35918576)
> all other things being equal

But all other things will never be equal because animal protein costs 10x more energy to produce.

> what will happen to people when for reason there’s a problem in the supply chain of a specific crop or you have a bad year with low yields and the price goes to the roof?

Have you been to a produce department? Most of them in the US could be reduced to 25% their current size and still have 200% the diversity of the meat department. Being unable to find one or more amino acids is just not a problem that vegetarians have.

The problem is constantly having to cook for yourself because vegetarian options at most restaurants (or prepared by well-meaning carnivore friends) are just "leave the meat off" and not designed from the ground up to be nutritional without meat. Cultural change would make it easy.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by camel-cdr on Friday May 12, 2023 @01:03PM (#35918941)
> Having a “varied” diet is much easier said than done

I think you overestimate what varied means in this context, usually two or three different protein sources are enough.

Consider a random day where I tracked my food intake: I ate some oatmeal for breakfast and dinner, and noodles with chickpeas for for lunch. In the end I had between 120% to 250% of the RDA for the different essential amino acids.

Edit: Also "Another false assumption is that everyone can accommodate a purely plant-based diet". Do you have a source on that, with maybe an estimation to what percent of the population this applies to?

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by yesfitz on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:17PM (#35918277)
To your second point, we'll agree that a plant-based diet with supplements is feasible for human health.

Your first point is misleading because we currently grow a lot of food to feed animals to eat, and clear out forests to make pasture. - "More than three-quarters (77%) of soy is used as feed for livestock."[1] - "Seventy per cent of formerly forested land in the Amazon, and 91% of land deforested since 1970, is used for livestock pasture."[2] - 38.7% of Corn produced in the US is for livestock feed.[3]

1: https://ourworldindata.org/soy#:~:text=More%20than%20three%2.... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_in_Brazil#Rates:.... 3: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-the-uses-of-cor...

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by MadSudaca on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:42PM (#35918644)
It’s feasible, like living in space is feasible. With a lot of effort and a toll on your body.

How much of that land could be used for farming food for humans? Brazil has famously poor soil.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dmbche on Friday May 12, 2023 @04:28PM (#35921920)
Go watch Gamechangers - see how easy it is to thrive on plants
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dennis_jeeves1 on Friday May 12, 2023 @06:29PM (#35923320)
I have posted a poll under the main thread here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35923261

What would your response be to my question 1) and question 2)

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dmbche on Friday May 12, 2023 @07:51PM (#35923947)
I fail to see the point of your thought experiment In reality people are not isolated 10 acres plots of land, they eat what is available at the grocery store, which is part of an industry and a global chain of production. If you remove that, you should provide a valid reason. You're also welcome to go watch gamechangers to see what they have to say about nutrition, they have Phds I believe
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dennis_jeeves1 on Friday May 12, 2023 @08:06PM (#35924047)
>they have Phds I believe

I'm not carried away by credentials. There are some morons around with Phds. And I'm sure that you will find some Phds who will find fault with with what is espoused in gamechangers. My point is just because you look at a documentary, or even published papers, you as an individual cannot decide easily, because there are opposing views even among people with a lot of credentials. Of course most people choose to go with consensus. But then consensus itself can be quite wrong.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dmbche on Friday May 12, 2023 @08:28PM (#35924196)
That's great - feel free to inform yourself about nutrition, Gamechangers is a good source of information about nutrition, using all kinds of evidence. I myself am healthy and have now been vegan for 8 or 9 years, eating a vast majority of cheap and local-ish food (Edit: local ish in the sense that I eat banans and stuff like that like a normal human being)
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by MadSudaca on Saturday May 13, 2023 @12:19PM (#35929847)
The fact that they had to make a movie showing that people can have muscles following a plant-based diet proves my point. If it was widely feasible, they wouldn't have to create propaganda to support the point.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dmbche on Saturday May 13, 2023 @02:41PM (#35931339)
That's kinda circular isn't it? "Since they made a movie it has to be fake"?

Come on my friend, at least try. And without even thinking about my nutrition I am a healthy vegan since 9 years, not taking supplements and eating cheap localish food.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dennis_jeeves1 on Friday May 12, 2023 @06:30PM (#35923330)
I have posted a poll under the main thread here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35923261

What would your response be to my question 1) and question 2)

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by AlexandrB on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:49AM (#35917877)
I think you're absolutely right, but this message is greeted with open hostility in many parts of the internet. Availability of cheap meat is almost seen as a god-given right in developed countries.
Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dennis_jeeves1 on Friday May 12, 2023 @06:28PM (#35923313)
I have posted a poll under the main thread here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35923261

What would your response be to my question 1) and question 2)

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:52AM (#35917930)
> - Growing plants to feed animals and then consuming those animals is an inefficient way of obtaining calories and nutrients. Shifting to a plant-based diet would allow us to feed more people with less land, reducing the pressure on wild habitats.

I think about this all the time. We need to get the US to stop subsidizing beef so that it can be priced according to its trophic level and not according to its favor with lobbyists.

Re:Animals Are Dying in Droves. What Are They Telling Us? by dennis_jeeves1 on Friday May 12, 2023 @06:25PM (#35923277)
I have posted a poll here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35923261

What would your response be to my question 1) and question 2)