News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pharo 11 by klibertp on Thursday May 11, 2023 @03:24PM (#35907150)
Ah, yes. "Entitlement"...

I'd say: to show that its authors have a sense of decency, at least. But let's not assassinate the lads any more than this.

Re:Pharo 11 by sfpotter on Thursday May 11, 2023 @07:05PM (#35909521)
Authors of open source projects don’t owe you anything. If you want something changed, do it yourself, or ask them. You could even go so far as to offer to pay them. If you aren’t up for any of that, well… not sure what to tell you!
Re:Pharo 11 by klibertp on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:32AM (#35917637)
> If you want something changed, do it yourself, or ask them.

I did ask. See my other comment[1]. The only thing I got out of asking was name calling, dismissive and rude remarks, and the immortal "do it yourself". Before the package manager thing, I did the same - years earlier - asking on the mailing list how to bind keys to commands. What I got out of this was name calling, dismissive and rude remarks, and the immortal "learn to use the mouse already!"

Sure, nobody owes anything to anybody, not even not being toxic and abrasive. But I also don't owe the toxic and abrasive community anything - certainly not avoiding criticizing it. Right?

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35906419

Re:Pharo 11 by bowsamic on Friday May 12, 2023 @03:38AM (#35913158)
So, to be clear, you are saying that it is indecent that the notice on their page saying "this project is not for lazy people. Please go away if you are too lazy to find the tutorial"? I really don't think that is more decent
Re:Pharo 11 by klibertp on Friday May 12, 2023 @12:06PM (#35918143)
Well, I do. As it is right now, the front page is misleading. They say there that Pharo is made by "an incredible community" (oh, the humility!). Someone might read it and think that there's a helpful, friendly community that they could (politely) ask for support without fear of being called "entitled" and without a barrage of "you just don't understand how glorious our way of doing things is!" following. Well, they would be wrong.

As in the reply to a sibling comment, yeah, nobody owes anything to anybody. But, you know, we do things we don't owe to anybody every day. I don't owe my neighbor saying "hi" when I meet them, but I still do. I don't owe my guests anything, but I still offer them a seat. Pharo community tries to do it both ways: they appear to want new users, but when you come closer you'll see what they actually want is new fanatics. Screw that. They don't owe me anything, but neither do I owe them keeping quiet about what I've been through.

Smalltalk is beautiful. And, Smalltalk is not just Pharo. There are other communities, and there are much better Smalltalks out there. Cincom (no affiliation) Visual Works is so much better an implementation that it's scary. Pharo could be like that, if only the "incredible community" stopped killing all semblance of stability with constant rewrites of everything, stopped treating users like unwanted baggage, stopped insulting people whose use cases don't completely fit the community's idea of what's good and bad.

Pharo community is a museum that preserved the culture of Smug Lisp Weenies intact. Good for them. Meanwhile, Pharo being advertised as "the most actively developed and most advanced Smalltalk" - which means that it's first, and very often last Smalltalk tried out by people - hurts the wider community and hurts Smalltalk adoption. They don't care. Is this a decent behavior? I think it's irresponsible, at the very least.

Re:Pharo 11 by bowsamic on Saturday May 13, 2023 @03:51AM (#35926492)
Let me find the world's smallest violin for you. We can write a song about how the FOSS community did not immediately present you with a clear tutorial to prevent you from deleting their piece of software that you clearly don't care at all about after a few minutes
Re:Pharo 11 by klibertp on Saturday May 13, 2023 @06:23AM (#35927082)
Look, I spent 5 years trying to work with Pharo. Not a few minutes. Yeah, I don't care about Pharo anymore. At all. That's because of what I've been through with it and its community. So please stop telling me I'm lazy, entitled, or that I "don't care after a few minutes". I've been giving Pharo chances for years - it just never got any better.
[dead]
Re:Pharo 11 by dang on Sunday May 14, 2023 @03:07PM (#35940481)
You broke the site guidelines badly and repeatedly in this thread. We ban accounts that do that.

This has been a problem before:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32121722 (July 2022)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31418768 (May 2022)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31418760 (May 2022)

I'm not going to ban you right now because I didn't see other cases of this in your recent history, but please fix this going forward so we don't have to.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Pharo 11 by igouy on Saturday May 13, 2023 @01:20PM (#35930484)
In case you haven't found this mailing list https://lists.cs.illinois.edu/lists/info/vwnc
Re:Pharo 11 by klibertp on Saturday May 13, 2023 @03:40PM (#35931957)
I didn't, but isn't this for educational use only (I'm guessing, I can't access the archive of the list)? Cincom seems to offer separate license for students and teachers, I'm unfortunately unaffiliated with any educational institution :(

But I did try to get commercial license, once. I had a project and a client for it, and a seemingly ideal use case. However, I wasn't able to sell the client the kind of licensing scheme Cincom wanted (they weren't unreasonable, just not what the client was willing to have). I ultimately abandoned the idea. Still, even knowing that I'm just a solo developer that's not going to earn them much, my contact with an account from Cincom was very pleasant and helpful. I saw the changelog for the next version of VW - there was a lot of really nice stuff there! Welcome fixes, improvements in many important packages, new functionalities - the product is evidently alive and getting better, but there was one thing missing. There were No. Breaking. Changes. I could reasonably expect my app to work if I built with 8.x version and later upgraded to 9.x. Can you imagine this?

Cincom is, of course, a company targeting big corporations - a for-profit organization, and the most important part of VW is closed source. If Cincom dies, VW will probably also die, along with my projects. It's a risk, and it's not ideal. The fact that the PUL version is 6 years old at this point also isn't nice. And, above all, I don't wear suits and neckties. So, I'd really prefer fully open source Smalltalk (the only reasonable alternative, Smalltalk/X, also has the compiler distributed only as a binary blob) Unfortunately, Pharo simply cannot be that Smalltalk for me.

To the dead sibling commenter: sure, I don't event want anybody to care. I'm writing all this for my own satisfaction, so please, just do your job of not caring properly and ignore it all.

Re:Pharo 11 by igouy on Saturday May 13, 2023 @09:36PM (#35934526)
VisualWorks Non-commercial iow PUL. When you have technical questions.
Re:Pharo 11 by dang on Sunday May 14, 2023 @03:09PM (#35940492)
Please don't perpetuate flamewars on HN, regardless of how bad other comments are or you feel they are. Please make your substantive points without swipes and attacks, no matter how bad a programming community is or you feel it is.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Edit: This kind of thing has been a problem before:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33024799 (Sept 2022)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22714938 (March 2020)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11301279 (March 2016)

Please review the rules and stick to them from now on.

p.s. I appreciate your love for Smalltalk but if you express it using swipes and attacks, you're actually discrediting it to less knowledgeable readers (i.e. most of us). It's not in your interest to turn people off of something you love, so you should follow the rules out of self-interest too.