Plus the fact that scientists are typically paid by tax payers', in a stable governmental position (at least in Europe), and many never held any real job in their whole lives, only adds to my doubts.
Regarding your first point, the scientists who are not pragmatic will take severe hits to their reputations down the road. Data and methodology is what matters, not personal opinion.
Except for the experimentation part, that could describe a lawyer. Which begs the question,
Where does it go wrong?
Why do people from an evidence-based career become embroiled in the kind of back[stabbing/scratching] politics that seems to be the norm today? And how can it be fixed?
We may sink as low as anybody else, rhetorically speaking, but when we choose to we can do a lot better than the average person.
I'm curious though what you consider a to be "real" job.
Having work done in the field of science, imo, is a plus
However I am not sure about how relevant it is for the Singaporean examples to have had "scientific background". If you do not work in the actual science field and never used it, your background is worthless. If your everyday occupation is to gather support to get elected, I question the validity of the term "Scientist" in this case.