News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Don't Americans Elect Scientists? by ekianjo on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @02:56AM (#3589092)
Not all scientists are government-employed. It may be a majority in some countries, but I would not disregard the amount of scientists employed in the private industries as well. They may not be involved in fundamental research, rather "applied sciences", but they are scientists nonetheless. Anyone who produces data through experimentation, analyses it, uses critical judgment and appropriate tools to make evidence-based decisions is basically, in my eyes, a "scientist", no matter the exact field of work.

Regarding your first point, the scientists who are not pragmatic will take severe hits to their reputations down the road. Data and methodology is what matters, not personal opinion.

Re:Why Don't Americans Elect Scientists? by bjnortier_hn on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @04:48AM (#3589366)
'Anyone who [...] uses critical judgment and appropriate tools to make evidence-based decisions'

Except for the experimentation part, that could describe a lawyer. Which begs the question,

Where does it go wrong?

Why do people from an evidence-based career become embroiled in the kind of back[stabbing/scratching] politics that seems to be the norm today? And how can it be fixed?

Re:Why Don't Americans Elect Scientists? by ekianjo on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @05:15AM (#3589416)
Experimentation is mandatory to conduct Science. You need to be able to form theories or hypotheses from data or observation, and then conduct a controlled experiment to validate your point. There can be no science without validation and repeatability.