If as a board you unduly punish executives when bets they make don't pan out, you risk causing a culture of fear that prevents innovation and big bets.
Obviously there's a limit, and the reasoning is important behind the bets.
That being said it's not like all of the tech ceos were perfectly competent - that's not what I'm saying. But the knee-jerk "well, fire them too" reaction from the internet is mostly an emotional response.
People are paid based on opportunity cost. Executives are paid very highly because the cost of them making a poor decision, or not making a good decision, is very high. Meanwhile, the cost of hiring me and me not performing to expectations is low. It's not because they're God's or anything. The supply of people with leadership experience is also definitionally low.
Of course there's a lot of old boys club in executive roles in reality but that's the boards and shareholders problem when they do a bad job.
And under-hiring today because your crystal ball says market conditions will deteriorate in the future is also not always the best course of action.
The myriad causes which lead Intel to this point exist at many levels from individual, corporate, competitive, and macroeconomic.
It’s overly reductive to assume a layoff is due to some mistake, that a layoff is due to over-hiring, or that a layoff’s root cause is the executives who mapped out a past hiring plan.
For starters, the hiring plan will be based on revenue projections which will be based on technical market analysis overlaid with a technical roadmap. This is a distributed effort and major analysis at the level of a corporation like Intel spread across potentially dozens of business units. The hiring plan could easily have been “perfect” based on faulty product roadmaps / product performance projections or any number of other factors.
What is beneficial to management may or may not actually be in the best interest of shareholders (and neither incentive necessarily aligns with the interests of either customers or employees).
If you believe Intel will be profitable again in the near future then paying the dividend really does make sense. Unfortunately there have been lots of companies that thought that was true when it wasn't and the dividend is how they ran out of runway quick.
If you believe your company will be profitable you should reinvest all avaliable capital into the business to grow it.
What you are advocating is contrary to every shred of logic and common sence.
No, because being profitable doesn’t mean marginal profits from expansion are available. Your plan would have all profitable firms expanding until they collapse from overextension.
This should not be true for microchip manufacturer during global computerisation. We now have microchips in sofas and handbags.
No? Then they are under investing in R&D. It's been a while since M1 came out and intel CPUs still havent caught up.
They GPUs are lacking too. Apply has AI inference functionality in their chips and great ML software support.
You don't get to tell me that they have nowhwre to invest when they are losing on multiple fronts.
I am not even mentioning the fact that they should be finding foundamentally new opportunities ahead of their competitors.
A month ago, would you would have believed that management team is right hire these people?
Did they make a mistake when they were hiring or did they make a mistake now when they are firing?
You cant believe both simultaneously.
Alternatively, maybe management team is just out for themselves, doesn't care. , and is just riding the wave. Pumo the share price.
Or maybe they are incompetent, don't know how to apply a large team, are out of ideas on how to invest 1.6 billion dollars profitably.
Now I dont have proof for my hypothesis b, but at least I am mot contradicting myslelf.
No it's entirely plausible that hiring then was the right decision and firing now is the right decision. There's no universal law that says you must hire people for eternity.
Why do you feel the urge to make excuses for managerial incompetence.
Like when you are a worker, they must be scruitinised to make sure they arent lazy or incompetent, but the day you get promoted to executive you gain godlike immunity from criticism
In the past 40 years several FTSE 250 companies have collapsed, gone bancrupt or suffered some other disaster.
I can't name any example where shareholders replaced upper management before it was too late. Can you?
They could show up with a RISC-V for a new socket AM6, called Zen7, with x86 acceleration: An actual x86 mode to support legacy applications during the transition to the best and industry standard ISA.
Or they could, alternatively, fall into irrelevance on the CPU side. Which would be a waste.
> Intel's earnings report for the first quarter of 2023 was one of the worst in the company's history. Its revenue dropped by 36% annually and the firm also posted a loss per share of four cents. These losses came as the firm ensured that its investors were happy and paid $1.5 billion in dividends out of pocket during Q1, keeping the payments nearly similar to the year ago quarter's figures.
Corporations are supposed to what's best for the shareholders. Milton Friedman equated it to maximizing profit, but it's not necessarily so.
Even if you assume that the profit is the sole reason for the corporation, it's not clear laying off 20% worker would necessarily lead to maximizing shareholder profit in the following years (e.g., it could lead to stifled innovation, lower employee morale, etc).