2. Nearly the entire reduction in poverty the last few decades has taken place in China
and the united states has caused a ton of chaos and violence throughout the world. arguably they're one of the main causes of instability in a lot of countries.
Every societal consensus believes itself to be the fountain of net progress.
And every societal consensus looks on its predecessors and peers as hairy barbarians.
Plenty of ancient civilisations celebrated their cruelty and capacity to deal violence as a competitive advantage (e.g. the Spartans, Vikings, Nazis, Mongols and Aztecs, et cetera). Even contemporary American society celebrates its military power. (No civilization celebrates its chaos, almost by definition, as that’s the antithesis of statehood.)
But most of them are very cruel, within and without.
Spartans, Nazis and Aztecs were proudly cruel to their own. Hyper-masculine societies have historically celebrated this as a way of culling the weak from their ranks, a necessary evil. If anything, not being an honour-bound and sacrificial culture is something of a modern phenomenon.
We're comparing dividends to child sacrifice. If that doesn't encapsulate progress, I don't know what does.
This is hyperbole. We have hungry kids in America, and that's a tragedy. But they're not dying en masse, and we're certainly not celebrating that as a necessary sacrifice.
We absolutely celebrate the slow death of the poor as a necessary sacrifice in the face of economic growth and dividends. Just not always in the same breath. The fittest grow and the weakest adapt, or don't. Believing that when they don't is a tragedy, is not an effective way of mitigating tragedy, and indeed can serve as an affirming and normalizing act in and of itself.
"That's a tragedy, but that's the way it is"
Invade Iraq? "Justified" revenge for a guy from Saudi Arabia attacking a building.
Torture a random dude grabbed from the middle east? He must have been doing something wrong.
Drone bomb a wedding? Don't make the mistake of living in a country the US thinks might have a terrorist.
Kill a black guy? "He looked suspicious" or "he had a criminal record".
This is a single metric. Number goes up. What other numbers went up? What numbers went down? What do these directions mean?
It does seem like fewer child deaths is a good thing. It does seem like modern medicine in general is probably a really good thing. There are a lot of other things in this world that are good things.
I'm not trying to deny goodness here. Just asking for more perspective, to better mitigate hubris.
I would guess that maybe less than a third of the total workforce is doing things we actually want and need as a society, and 90% of that third are jobs that are close to being automated.
As one example, the US alone has nearly $300 billion a year in revenue for the advertising industry and employees a quarter million people. When looking at the list of things humanity needs, ads aren't very high. There is a lot that exists to facilitate the other shit that doesn't need to exist.
point of clarification: people have value regardless of their profession and regardless of whether it becomes automated
At scale, is "less destructive" a synonym for "more productive"..?
Capitalism has a cost, and it's extremely high. Higher than any war in history.