The most effective people I worked for didn't try to dictate the solution to the conflict. They were effective at moving the disagreeing engineers past their conflict. Dictating a solution was always the last resort if the engineers had just "dug in their heals" instead of discussing rationally.
About China's presumptive next leader, Xi Jinping
His subtle and pragmatic style was seen in the way he handled a landmark power project teetering on the edge of failure in 2002, when he was governor of Fujian, a coastal province. The American company Bechtel and other foreign investors had poured in nearly $700 million. But the investors became mired in a dispute with planning officials.
After ducking foreign executives’ repeated requests for a meeting, Mr. Xi agreed to chat one night in the governor’s compound with an American business consultant on the project whose father had befriended Mr. Xi’s father in the 1940s.
Mr. Xi explained that he could not interfere in a dispute involving other powerful officials. But he showed that he knew the project intimately and supported it, promising to meet the investors “after the two sides have reached an agreement.” That spurred a compromise that allowed the power plant to begin operating.
“I thought, ‘This person is a brilliant politician,’ ” said the consultant, Sidney Rittenberg Jr.
> http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/24/world/asia/24leader.html
It's possible. I know quite a few very talented ex-Apple engineers that left because they felt the environment was oppressive and stifling. Was Apple a better place without them?
I don't know. Jobs was crazy successful at what he did, but there's nothing in that to suggest that it was for the most visible reasons.
Administration is part of what management do but it's a little demeaning to suggest that it's all that they do. Done right it should be closer to enabling and informing.
But I'll take it that it's a slightly exaggerated position to make people think about things differently which is fine.
Indeed, the word 'management' itself connotes a perspective incompatible with Joel's philosophy.
In terms of informing, I wasn't wild about the word but couldn't find anything better quickly. Where I was coming from is that in many cases developers and technicians don't have knowledge of the market, don't have much interest in liaising directly with customers and so on. That information should be fed back into the team and customers and others outside the technical team should have a voice which is another function one of the manager should provide.
I've always seen management in an ideal world as a peer role with different responsibilities.
I loved the swipe at the fake Steve Jobs's out there. I worked for one, although he wasn't young and it wasn't in Mountain View. He would cite Steve Jobs to defend defective practices. It was ridiculous.
It's a great essay, and I like Spolsky's management philosophy a lot, but I don't entirely agree. A business isn't academia. Businesses have to ship products and please their customers, and leaving these tasks to "the crowd" doesn't work. "The crowd", when we're talking about software engineers, produces brilliant chaos. That's great sometimes, and it can produce excellent products, but it's not good when you need focus or to meet a ship date. Sometimes a CEO or CTO needs to decide what gets worked on, how people do it, and to motivate people to make sure it happens.
Likewise, sometimes a leader needs to step in and resolve bike-shedding conflicts among two equally smart, strongly opinionated engineers who disagree on a core question, and to look for a compromise. "Management fiat" shouldn't be used lightly, but it's not without purpose.
That said, I think Spolsky deserves a lot of props for pointing out that the managerial relationship is two-sided. A lot of companies and bosses don't figure this out until they face uncontrollable talent bleed, and even then there's a lot of self-deception (I've known some ineffective managers to become bitter about their best reports "abandoning" them, as if it were some ethical lapse, but never to own up to their role).