Re:Reddit: a necessary change in policy
by sliverstorm on Sunday February 12, 2012 @07:47PM
(#3583639)
Not to mention the sinister side-effect of allowing CP to reduce abuse- last I heard, much of it is produced via children from second-world countries. So in the end, we internalize all the benefit within the USA, and externalize all the suffering to downtrodden nations and their children.
Re:Reddit: a necessary change in policy
by yummyfajitas on Sunday February 12, 2012 @09:46PM
(#3583969)
I see little reason why we couldn't ban CP which was produced with real children, but legalize CP which was not (e.g., cartoons, CGI, etc).
Note that /r/lolicon is one of the banned subreddits.
So in the end, we internalize all the benefit within the USA, and externalize all the suffering to downtrodden nations
Kind like what happens with industrial production, natural resources and democracy, then?
Re:Reddit: a necessary change in policy
by Dylan16807 on Sunday February 12, 2012 @07:58PM
(#3583669)
Nobody is excusing the abuse of children. The only thing being petitioned for the title of 'okay' is image linking.
But there are definite flaws in the plan, especially when it comes to the rights of the victims.
That's a distinction without a difference.
Re:Reddit: a necessary change in policy
by Dylan16807 on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:23AM
(#3584480)
You make no distinction between actively hurting children and copying photos of someone else hurting a child in the past?
Re:Reddit: a necessary change in policy
by ThaddeusQuay2 on Monday February 13, 2012 @12:22PM
(#3586374)
I recently made the same distinction on HN, but there's not much point to it because the Moral Majority has made real discussion of CP so toxic that pretty much everyone avoids it. The situation is so bad that your very question might get you branded as a "pedophile". I believe that what Reddit is doing represents a slippery slope, one made out of legal convenience, and that the above distinction, rather than issues of copyright, represents the real battlefield for online freedom of speech.
Whether it significantly reduces the rates of child sexual abuse is besides the point. If someone thinks it's okay for one child to be abused so another may or may not be abused later, they need to check into the nearest psychiatric ward immediately.
We are human beings, for fucks sake. We should be holding ourselves to a higher standard than that.
Someone should make a site to permanently enshrine all the bugfuck insanity these people are trying to use to defend the indefensible.