News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by mwint on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:02AM (#35815480)
It makes no sense in a world where collectives of people can make sane decisions in a timely manner.

We don't live in that world - for anything to get done, there must be a very small group of people with authority to decide what color to paint the bike shed. Land ownership is important exactly because it gives responsibility over what happens in a geographic area to a single entity, and excludes most people from providing paralyzing "input".

Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by kqr on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:29AM (#35815918)
Maybe you don't live in that world, but I sure do. Only few people actually care enough to show up for any decision, and they can usually come to agreement fairly quickly.

The only times I have experienced trouble has been when people have had the prejudice that "democracy obviously doesn't work" so they make a big stink about not getting their way (how ironic!) instead of focusing on the decision at hand. Those people can usually be trained out of that mindset with a little skilled facilitation. Those that cannot are free to move somewhere where a third party owns the land they're on.

Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by tshaddox on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:17AM (#35815713)
Don’t collectives of people still need to decide how property rights work and how they’re enforced?
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by mwint on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:21AM (#35815790)
Indeed - but it's much easier to get a collective of people to discuss something once in general terms ("property rights") than every little decision ("we can't build the factory until we agree on the color of the paint in the breakroom")
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by nunuvit on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:26AM (#35815866)
I think you'll get more out of the article if you read it as more of a philosophical exploration than a literal policy proposal.
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by mwint on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:28AM (#35815905)
These philosophical explorations have a really nasty pattern of being picked up as the policy platform of political strongmen riding a wave of discontentment to power. Then the philosophical exploration becomes poorly-implemented policy.
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by nunuvit on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:36AM (#35816033)
Nobody is stopping you from talking about what you value and how to incorporate those values into policy design. The people you don't like are participating in public discourse the way they want. If you don't participate the way you want, that's on you.
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by xbar on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:22AM (#35815809)
Collectives make a lot of decisions in a timely manner. Why not, specifically, about land use? When did the collectives all "run out of time" to decide who gets to manage land, as a specific resource? 1980? 4000 BC?
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by nabergh on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:46AM (#35816195)
The article proposes taxing the unimproved value of land at 100% which I think gets around that problem totally.
Re:Land Ownership Makes No Sense by mindslight on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:49AM (#35816235)
I'll echo your sentiment, but it's not really relevant here. Georgism doesn't say much about restricting the right to use a piece of land. Rather it's about what it costs to maintain that right (and isn't actually a huge departure from the current state of things where that cost is generally nonzero except in the rare cases of allodial title).

For example, homeowners associations are a significant source of tyranny, that often literally regulate what color you can paint your shed. It's probable that under Georgism the lack of desire to keep one's abstract property value high would lead to a lot fewer of them, and homeowners would actually end up more free.