Re:Passkeys: The Beginning of the End of the Password
by ilyt on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @02:18PM
(#35805790)
The devices are far from being security bastion.
Re:Passkeys: The Beginning of the End of the Password
by jjav on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @05:12PM
(#35807875)
> more secure because it is tied to a device
Tied to a phone (as opposed to some security-specific device like a Yubikey) is a terrible idea.
It ties your authentication to something that is often lost or damages, but more importantly, something that is controlled by a third party (apple or google) and requires an expensive monthly subscription to yet another third party (your cellphone company).
TOTP is not tied to a device which is why it's a beautiful solution. You can store it where you wish under the controls you wish and back it up as you wish. You are fully in control, dependent on nobody.
2FA via SMS is still vulnerable. 2FA with an app like Google Authenticator or VIPAccess is more secure because it is tied to a device.