My 76 yr old dad can't do it. His phone is some shitty android trash that when he's setting up his biometrics, he shakes a bit, and it never stores the finger data correctly. I have to hold his finger and his phone at the same time to even scan it. Then, unlocking is also super unreliable because of the shaking. He refuses to get a better phone cause this one "works well enough."
It's no surprise that the tech industry, which largely employs urban, educated 20-somethings and 30-somethings, tends to produce products aimed at urban, educated 20-somethings and 30-somethings.
Stick your finger inside of dynamically sizing aperture, or clip a finger reader onto your finger? If both the finger and the reader shake the same there shouldn't be a problem.
That doesn't solve the general touch issue, but it solves this particular case.
But sure, I agree (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35790638 ). I'm just trying to come up with some workable solution. Not trying to make the best of all possible worlds.
Essentially every biometric has a population they won't function well with.
Security is HARD. There's no getting around that. Your data is valuable and protecting it is not an easy task. At some level, security and convenience is a zero-sum game.
As for old people, my dad writes down his passwords on a text file in his laptop and has a printed backup in the house.
And, yes, he does have to bug me sometimes to re-login or change a password, but we've never had a security problem, which is way more than can be said for a lot of people who tried the INHERENTLY unsafe "3rd party manager" thing.
No it's not.
The security triad is "something you are", "something you know", and "something you have". Fingerprints are something you are. Usernames are something you claim to be.
The username is the "claim" you are this person. The password is the "proof" you are.
If I'm fingerprinted by any federal agency today (and my fingerprints have been on file with the government since the 90's for a security clearance), then my fingerprints can serve as absolute proof of my identity. This is helpful to me should my identity ever be stolen and I need to show absolute proof of who I am.
But given the relatively high level of laziness, capriciousness, and general failure all around that is "IT security by means of companies who are rarely held accountable," it's good to point out that this is what makes biometrics worse than usernames and should probably mostly be avoided, or at least optional.
Sure fingerprints, face scans, and iris scans can be stolen as well. But certain things are really hard to fake, including potentially, scans of faces and an iris scan at the same time -- unless you can somehow graft a new iris and grow a new face.
Put it like this: a dead victim is found naked along the side of the road. Which leg(s) of the security triad can the police use to prove the identity of the victim?
Google, who I don't pay and doesn't owe me much, not so much.
I think you should stop giving out this daily reminder. This meme has outlived its usefulness.
Using face id to unlock a local key store to enable my device to sign a signed challenge from a site I want to log into with the private key stored on my device is not a 'username' in any meaningful sense.
The problem is, the metaphor about passwords and usernames is not a good, structure-preserving simplification of the actual problem of authentication.
The biometric data and/or pin code are not being used to prove that you are you to Gmail, it's being used to unlock the set of private keys you have on your device. This doesn't fit into the metaphor at all.
If my non-technical parents said they were migrating all their accounts to passkeys, I would be very pleased. I wouldn't be worried about their inability to change their biometrics and that causing a problem following some sort of breach in the future. I am highly worried about their extreme susceptibility to phishing, especially in their inability to distinguish phishing sites from real sites, or real account maintence contacts via email and SMS from phishing contacts, their reuse of very simple passwords that are probably circulating in combolists already, and their general inability to retain username/password pairs. I have a lot of sympathy for them when I try to talk them through something like logging in to an Apple device with their apple id, when their appleid username is their email, which ends with @gmail.com. "But...why would i log in to apple with my gmail?" nevermind how confused they are about 'log in with google', 'log in with facebook', etc.
Moving to a model where their devices store webauthn credentials and guard them with a pin or faceid-style biometric shortcut is a _massive_ improvement in practical resistance to account takeover for my parents, and I don't think continuing to say 'biometrics are usernames in authn' is accurate or helpful.