News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google DeepMind CEO Says Some Form of AGI Possible in a F... by ogogmad on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @08:30AM (#35801566)
That would suggest that 1-Hidden-Layer neural nets would work fine, because they are also universal function approximators. But no -- when people talk about "deep learning", the word "deep" refers to having lots of hidden layers.

I'm not an expert, but the motivation seems more like this:

- Linear regression and SVM sometimes work. But they apply to very few problems.

- We can fit those models using gradient descent. Alternatives to gradient descent do exist, but they become less useful as the above models get varied and generalised.

- Empirically, if we compose with some simple non-linearities, we get very good results on otherwise seemingly intractable problems like OCR. See Kernel SVM and Krieging.

- Initially, one might choose this non-linearity from a known list. And then fit the model using specialised optimisation algorithms. But gradient descent still works fine.

- To improve results, the choice of non-linearity must itself be optimised. Call the non-linearity F. We break F into three parts: F' o L o F'', where L is linear, and F' and F'' are "simpler" non-linearities. We recursively factorise the F' and F'' in a similar way. Eventually, we get a deep feedforward neural network. We cannot use fancy algorithms to fit such a model anymore.

- Somehow, gradient descent, despite being a very generic optimisation algorithm, works much better than expected at successfully fitting the above model. We have derived Deep Learning.

Re:Google DeepMind CEO Says Some Form of AGI Possible in a F... by VHRanger on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @08:49AM (#35801769)
RE: 1-layer neural nets, yes, that's the point.

Deep learning has been a series of *engineering* successes stacking over each other rather than theory being applied rigorously.

It's hard to scale training on the "dumb" approximators like a kitchen sink regression, and balancing overfitting becomes a nightmare.

Re:Google DeepMind CEO Says Some Form of AGI Possible in a F... by theGnuMe on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @02:00PM (#35805569)
1-layer nets are equivalent in theory and universal approximators, they are just hard to train.
Re:Google DeepMind CEO Says Some Form of AGI Possible in a F... by ogogmad on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @03:43PM (#35806743)
Read the first sentence, you idiot.
Re:Google DeepMind CEO Says Some Form of AGI Possible in a F... by ogogmad on Thursday May 04, 2023 @05:43AM (#35813104)
Read the first sentence