News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State agrees the only witness cannot be believed, court t... by mulmen on Monday May 01, 2023 @06:35PM (#35780211)
The system seems to be working just fine. The justice system interprets law as enacted by the legislature. This is the balance of power. The governor can still issue a pardon to stop the execution. The legislature can change the law to avoid this situation in the future. The solution here isn't to give judges absolute power.
Re:State agrees the only witness cannot be believed, court t... by giantg2 on Monday May 01, 2023 @06:49PM (#35780362)
Dear God, in what world is the current system "fine". 2-10% of the incarcerated population is innocent. My own minor experiences with the courts has uncovered extreme incompetence on even minor issues, and a system that grants judges damn near the absolute power you mention. There's practically no oversight and the system is designed to hide mistakes and misconduct (judicial review boards).

"The solution here isn't to give judges absolute power."

It's seems all parties are on board - defense, prosecution, etc, so it would not be absolute power.

Re:State agrees the only witness cannot be believed, court t... by mulmen on Monday May 01, 2023 @06:52PM (#35780397)
There is already a remedy here. The executive can simply decide not to go through with the execution. There's not benefit to allowing judges to selectively interpret the law. The price of that precedent is too high. If you think the system already makes poor decisions (I agree) then the solution is certainly not to give judges even more power.
Re:State agrees the only witness cannot be believed, court t... by giantg2 on Monday May 01, 2023 @07:00PM (#35780476)
"There's not benefit to allowing judges to selectively interpret the law."

I agree, but they already do.

When the entirety of the system has failed and it's down to the executive, that's a problem. We want a system that's fail-safe, not fail-fatal.

Re:State agrees the only witness cannot be believed, court t... by mulmen on Monday May 01, 2023 @07:05PM (#35780532)
The entirety of the system hasn't failed though. The legislature can still change the law and the executive can still refuse to enforce the death penalty.
Re:State agrees the only witness cannot be believed, court t... by giantg2 on Monday May 01, 2023 @07:59PM (#35781136)
Yeah... in only one of the many cases. How about the ones that aren't national news?