News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by kspacewalk2 on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:08PM (#35775817)
Potentially controversial view: until kids get to high school, and if they're good students anyway, just have them skip school for a week and go on a trip. They're likely not missing anything important in one week of schooling.

For example, I'm definitely not figuring my son's grade 2 timelines into my travel plans. He loves school and everything, but he can skip it for a week somewhere if that literally saves the family thousands.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by benjaminpv on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:29PM (#35776187)
Absolutely this. My parents would take an impromptu vacation toward the tail end of winter and every time they basically just told the school 'we're leaving, give him the homework he'll be missing, end communication.'

Years later I was having dinner with a coworker and his teacher wife and explained it to her. "Yeah we'd go to like science exhibits and museums and all, it was really fun!" She was just aghast. Like 'y-you can't just t-take kids out of school?!'

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by ghaff on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:38PM (#35776328)
It occurred to me probably years later that there were a ton of things my parents with respect to my brother and I growing up that were, at a minimum, quite unconventional.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by antisthenes on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:41PM (#35776387)
> Years later I was having dinner with a coworker and his teacher wife and explained it to her. "Yeah we'd go to like science exhibits and museums and all, it was really fun!" She was just aghast. Like 'y-you can't just t-take kids out of school?!'

Some people treat their job as if it's the most important thing in the world, to everyone.

Dentists still can't realize that flossing isn't everyone's #1 priority every single day :P

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by munificent on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:25PM (#35776113)
We did that for a while when they were in elementary school, but by the time you get to middle school, it's much harder. The kids start to have long-term group projects that are a significant part of their grade. Lessons become more linear where missing a step means you can get lost further in.

Thankfully, school systems do tend to stagger their spring breaks so at least there's some variation there.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by carlosjobim on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:35PM (#35776281)
Grades mean nothing in middle school. You passed through middle school, so how can you not know this?
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by munificent on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:52PM (#35776539)
You're thinking of the children as objects and not people.

Grades and school projects mean a lot to my kids and one of the most important things I'm trying to teach them right now is to have a sense of responsibility and respect for their own work and commitments.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by carlosjobim on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:54PM (#35776592)
Fair enough, nothing wrong with prioritizing it for the sake of the kid - not for the sake of the school.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by wing-_-nuts on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:57PM (#35776628)
Grades might not mean anything, but the knowledge is foundational and really starts to build from middle school onward.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by ghaff on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:08PM (#35777599)
I skipped an entire year of middle school (8th grade), spent a few weeks studying a bit, and it was fine.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by munificent on Monday May 01, 2023 @05:56PM (#35779761)
Your singular data point may not generalize to all children and all educational settings.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by smugma on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:01AM (#35787521)
Grades often determine placement for classes in HS. If you want to be in advanced math or honors English, you need good grades in middle school.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by scythe on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:42PM (#35776402)
This is what my family did in the '90s. In the beginning, it was easy: we handed the teachers a note and we were on our way. As I got older, the school was less cooperative, and focused on boosting attendance statistics. The ability of parents to request excused absences slowly declined.

Just another casualty of Goodhart's law, it would seem.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:23PM (#35789983)
My school simply gets informed via the School Messenger app. Reason: "Parent-approved absence". End of story.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by fhub on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:35PM (#35776278)
At least for me my thinking is often "Well if I'm going to take time off work to fill the childcare gap then I'd prefer to to go on some adventure with them".
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by lozenge on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:32PM (#35776243)
In the UK, people do this, but it can result in fines and being taken to court. Schools are measured by their attendance, and parents want to maintain good relations with the school staff, so there's that aspect as well.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by disgruntledphd2 on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:17PM (#35775986)
The trouble with this approach is that it only works because basically nobody does it, so there'll be no kids around his age there to play with.

That might be an acceptable tradeoff for you, but it's worth knowing about beforehand.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by mattgreenrocks on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:29PM (#35776193)
> there'll be no kids around his age there to play with

So, like every other trip ever that doesn't involve meeting people we know?

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by hombre_fatal on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:25PM (#35776122)
I don't get the scenario you're imagining. Each friend goes away for a week 1-2 times per school year and that's somehow catastrophic?
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by incone123 on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:30PM (#35776206)
I take it to mean no other children at the holiday destination to play with
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by chimeracoder on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:41PM (#35776376)
> I don't get the scenario you're imagining. Each friend goes away for a week 1-2 times per school year and that's somehow catastrophic?

No, they're saying that there's nobody else for them to play with while on vacation.

Some people, particularly with younger kids, plan vacations that have some sort of child care component to them, which gives the kid opportunity to socialize with other kids their own age (and also gives the parent some free time to do things that they can't do while taking care of their kids). Some hotels offer this as part of the package, as do cruise ships, etc.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by hombre_fatal on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:16PM (#35776882)
I see, because it's not on holiday. Wouldn't everyone doing this make it more likely that your kid meets a playmate, then?

If I have two strikes after this comment, I'll just see myself out.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by chimeracoder on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:23PM (#35776981)
> I see, because it's not on holiday. Wouldn't everyone doing this make it more likely that your kid meets a playmate, then?

Currently, everyone with kids takes vacations at the same time. That means that all kids go on vacation at the same time, so whenever they're on vacation, there are likely to be lots of other kids there.

If everyone with kids took vacations at staggered times, fewer kids would be on vacation at any given time, meaning whenever they're on vacation, there are likely to be fewer kids there.

That is the tradeoff that OP is referring to.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by hombre_fatal on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:28PM (#35777044)
That makes sense. I hope OP learned their lesson. I demand spoonfeeding.
Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:47AM (#35786097)
I'll remember that in future ;)

More generally, if you have a small child, the probability of sleep deprivation is pretty high, so i should have taken that into account.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by arbitrage on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:37PM (#35776313)
In some localities it is illegal to do this.

Also, schooling for younger children isn't exclusively about the obtaining of actionable knowledge. For some children, it can be disruptive to yank them out of school.

Other families might have a problem that this teaches their children the lesson of "rules for thee, but not for me" --- that it can be okay to ignore rules just because you don't want to follow them. That isn't something that everyone is okay with.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:20PM (#35789947)
>In some localities it is illegal to do this.

Can you elaborate, so I can strike them off my to-move list forever?

>Also, schooling for younger children isn't exclusively about the obtaining of actionable knowledge. For some children, it can be disruptive to yank them out of school.

Yes. Your child-mileage may vary. My kid doesn't care, one week out of school does not impact him negatively, whereas travel impacts him positively.

>this teaches their children the lesson of "rules for thee, but not for me" --- that it can be okay to ignore rules just because you don't want to follow them.

They can then take great care to ensure the kids understand that this is not, in fact, the lesson. My kid doesn't attend school because "that's the rule, gotta go to school", he enjoys it for the social and the learning aspect, so his showing up to class does not rest upon compulsion either by the parents or the school. If this ever changes, I'll deal with that then. Also, it is of course completely okay to ignore rules you do not think of as important if there are no consequences to breaking them. My responsibility as a parent is to carefully curate the consequences bit to ensure I only enforce non-stupid rules. I want my kids to learn that too.

Re:American travelers are being charged up to 3 times more f... by sdwr on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:11PM (#35775878)
Jesus yes.