Good questions. I'm not sure, but that line needs to be drawn somewhere. Thousands of experts should be pouring over questions like these, and likely will.
War is deeply in human nature, it is not going away, question is; how to make it more humane and minimize indiscriminate killings and sufferings in most cases poorest populations on earth.
In modern warfare, civilians have always been the main casualties of war. Whether this really counts as "indiscriminate" is for war lawyers to argue over, but the fact remains that the civilian toll far exceeds the military toll, and for the victims and their families it matters little whether their deaths were "justified" to some lawyer or politician.
As technology advances, more and more power is going to be concentrated in the hands of individuals, many of whom won't be bothered by niceties such as the Geneva convention, and will target those they hate, be they civilian or military. High tech weapons will only make this easier.
We are headed for a very dark time.
For example, hellfire missile is more effective and substantially less destructive then carpet bombing few cities blocks, furthermore video feeds from drones provide some accountability.
Tell that to the 387,000 civilians killed in the "war on terror", roughly equal to the number of "opposition fighters"
https://watson.brown.edu/costsofwar/figures/2019/direct-war-...
> Precision munitions contribute heavily to this reduction.
Tell that to all the wedding parties blown up by precision munitions launched from drones because somebody's uncle, who exchanged texts with an "opposition fighter" and keeps an AK in the bed of his truck, showed up.
Shall we include people drafted into a war they didn't want to fight? People shot by their own countrymen because they didn't want to go over the top as they were a scared civilian with minimal training being used as cannon fodder? Those same scared civvies with minimal training who did go over the top and got mowed down by machine guns and shells?
Shall we do civilian resistance groups next? Whole villages of France that were shot dead? You can still visit at least one of them and see it as it was left. It's shocking, and it's left like that as a reminder of how shit things were.
Yes, proxy wars are terrible, as are all wars. All loss of life is horrible. Nobody is saying anything to the contrary. But saying it isn't less terrible is blatant denialism. These are all people who are all someone's son or daughter, both now, and then.
Civilians deaths per combatant deaths: ---
WW2 Allied Forces = 2.8
WW2 Axis Powers = 0.5
Iraq War Iraqis = 12.7
---
Modern wars are smaller in scale (for now), but much worse on civilians as a ratio where they do happen. The reason is because of the nature of wars we get into. We invade countries which cannot competently defend themselves, and so it immediately transforms into an asymmetric Guerilla style defense against an occupying force. And in these scenarios its impossible for the invader to know who is an enemy and who is a civilian, so civilians suffer just terribly and over very long periods of time.
The final drone strike of Afghanistan [1] is quite a symbolic one that will certainly go down in history written when "we" are no longer the authors. The US military initially claimed they killed a group of Islamic State forces planning an attack on US forces, after observing an ISIS militant placing explosives in his trunk. In reality they killed 1 man, 2 adult members of his family, and 7 children from the local neighborhood (who ran out after he honked his horn when getting home). Those "explosives" were bottles of water, and the "ISIS militant" was a longterm humanitarian aid worker, who was working for a US NGO and applying for a US visa. If not for the excessive media attention on the final strike of the war, that would likely have just been marked up as another successful strike, with some unfortunate collateral damage. And that was one day in a 20 year occupation.
[1] - https://apnews.com/article/afghanistan-kabul-taliban-strikes...
And that's extremely surprising to me. When you look at things like WW2 civilian deaths you're not only looking at violent deaths caused by the enemy. You're looking at deaths caused by all involved powers as well as indirect deaths caused by the nature of war - starvation, disease, despair, etc. The fact that one side, alone, in modern warfare can cause more violent civilian deaths (as a ratio) than all of those factors combined, in past wars, really emphasizes the notion that the concept of modern war being better for civilians is just exceptionally misguided.
The history books of the future are going to look back on the present in a way I think few can imagine today.
[1] - https://sci-hub.ru/https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet...
"Altogether, more than 2 million people were killed in Belarus during the three years of Nazi occupation, almost a quarter of the region's population,[1] including 500,000 to 550,000 Jews in the Holocaust in Belarus.[2]"
"At least 5,295 Byelorussian settlements were destroyed by the Nazis and some or all their inhabitants killed (out of 9,200 settlements that were burned or otherwise destroyed in Belarus during World War II),[3] and more than 600 villages like Khatyn had their entire population annihilated.[3]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_occupation_of_Byeloruss...
I'm Ashkenazi Jewish myself, and I don't like to be the guy invoking The Holocaust at every opportunity because there's plenty of other demographics usually overlooked, and The Holocaust itself wasn't as civilian war casualties, it was state-sponsored murder, and the topic at-hand is civilians getting killed through the war itself, thus invoking The Holocaust would skew the stats on wartime civilian casualties if it was to be included relative to more recent conflicts. Commonly, the victims are counted separately: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties
But yes, it's horrifying, and I find it difficult to understand the true scale of. I've been in stadiums with tens of thousands of people, that certainly seems like a lot of lives, a lot of families, a lot of humanity. Hundreds of thousands or millions? Yeah, it boggles my mind, and it really wasn't very long ago whatsoever.
The fact things aren't perfect doesn't mean they're not objectively better.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Dresden_in_World_Wa...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_a...
Arguably more destructive than Hiroshima.
Precision guided munition is 90's technology, this removes any need/justification to carpet bomb anything, today even artillery shells are guided (is in biggest, longest range guns have accuracy in meters).
You totally missed the point. The mass bombing in WW2 was intentional. That was specifically the goal, to kill as many civilians as possible.
[1] for specific interpretations of "indiscriminately".
This is:
* Not a consensus view * Impossible to prove with regard to the future nature of humanity * Not the working assumption for those of us innovating around peacetime tech
War Before Civilization: The Myth of the Peaceful Savage
Are you trolling? Because it's exactly this sort of "righteous war" rationale that props up empires and totalitarian dictatorships alike.
It's also human nature to rationalize evil and wish it into "good".
These things are generally classified, but algorithms are nowhere close to being considered decision-capable and human-in-the-loop targeting will be the norm for quite some time.
Even next generation systems that are being considered are still human queued and the AI comes in during the engagement step.
If you look at the stages of the F3EA cycle (Find, Fix, Finish, Analyze) there is no single step which is currently offloaded to an algorithm.
There are two things I wish I could make you and your friends understand: one is how deep you've dug that credibility hole. There was a price to pay for all that secrecy.
The other is, when you're out here trying to manage the non-classified public's perceptions, why on earth would you trust that your bosses aren't managing yours? Why would you think you get to know what the long term plans are?
> one is how deep you've dug that credibility hole. There was a price to pay for all that secrecy.
It’s a weird thing that the public thinks the defense sector doesn’t know this. They’re aware. I could try and reason with you on the internet, but this isn’t a place for changing people’s opinions.
I would instead tell you that people who work in defense tech tend to be motivated by morals and any argument that what they’re doing is dangerous is an implicit argument that they’re intelligent (otherwise, it wouldn’t seem too dangerous).
So, given those two facts — you can probably do a better job of reasoning about their motives than this.
> The other is, when you're out here trying to manage the non-classified public's perceptions, why on earth would you trust that your bosses aren't managing yours? Why would you think you get to know what the long term plans are?
Just bored on HN on a Monday. Same as anyone. Obviously not working on classified stuff, or I wouldn’t have access to HN.
Just because things are secret from the public doesn’t mean the defense industry is some cloak and dagger affair. It’s painfully boring bureaucracy. Decisions happen on the order of weeks to years, across many meetings. Everyone in the room knows the long term plans.
Their actions aren't consistent with being aware. Your post wasn't consistent with being aware. They think they understand, but they act in exactly the way they should not act, digging the hole of distrust deeper.
Look at Keith Alexander going to work for Mohammed bin Salman and Saud al-Qahtani. Is that consistent with being "motivated by morals"? Do you think everyone working under him understood that such were his personal long-term plans?
Keith Alexander retired from active duty 10 years ago. He’s now, currently, on the Amazon board of directors. Does this make every Amazon employee culpable for his actions?
Generally speaking, yes, it is not uncommon for leadership to contract with Saudi Arabia. I did not and continue to not offer any opinion about this nonsequitur. I do not think it’s at all common for them to share secrets. Further, I have no idea what this has to do with the morality of secrets as whole.
The point is not that your organization gets "tainted" by Alexander's actions. You must answer for your own sins, whoever your leader is.
The point is that he was always that sort of person, and that's the sort of people who become your leaders. Yes, it's a problem that completely amoral people get high positions in business too, but Amazon board members are not quite as powerful as NSA chiefs - among other things, because Amazon is not as good at convincing its workers to identify with it, like you identify with your mil-int employers.
Joke of the year
The SKYNET project was linked with drone systems, thus creating the potential for false-positives to lead to deaths.[1][5]"
I'd expect that mine manufacturers jump on the A.I. bandwagon to suggest that weapons are designed to be less harmful to civilians, and should not be subject to bans on certain types of mines.
Decision-capable is entirely subjective, and thus imperfectly controlled by bureaucracy.
You don't know for sure no one is already doing this.
A2A missiles used to lock on radar signature leading to huge risks related to accidentally shooting airliners/friendly craft. Now antiship missiles dynamically select their target over 300km away to maximize the chance of hitting a big ship.
During the war on terror, ML models would decide which phone to blow up. We’re probably going to see ai driven target selection and prioritization for fire control within the next few months of the Ukraine war. The US’s new Rapid dragon program almost demands ai control of target selection and flight trajectories.
Where do you draw the line? What would an appropriate agreement look like?