News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:53PM (#35755880)
>With so few people having children in the Netherlands

Has the Netherlands tried to address its housing crisis first?

In most of Europe, lack of affordability and quality family friendly housing, is the number one reason for couples not having kids.

Everyone spends their fertile years trying to get that well paying job that can get you up the housing ladder or just taps out of the race completely and chooses to not have any kids.

You can't complain people aren't having kids when you're collectively treating them like cash cows, monetizing them so that you can make a bigger return on your housing investment.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by meeuwer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:09PM (#35756080)
Bingo. Housing in the Netherlands has become a cult demanding increasingly more human sacrifice.

Sometimes I wonder if “demographic transition” in the developed world is nothing more than a side effect of the neoliberal housing policies.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by toomuchtodo on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:17PM (#35756150)
A friend emigrated to the rural US Midwest because making a life and supporting a family in the Netherlands was financially untenable. As always, n=1.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by thriftwy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:05PM (#35756026)
Just give a blanket license to PIK or LSR and watch the market flooded with line after line of 25-storey cheap studio apartments until you beg for forgiveness.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by nashashmi on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:02PM (#35755978)
Then people should be humble enough to live on the very little. Not ask for some other entity to provide its people with so much more (like full housing).
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:32PM (#35756287)
> Then people should be humble enough to live on the very little. Not ask for some other entity to provide its people with so much more (like full housing).

This applies to all people, not just those at the bottom. Yet those at the top keep charging high rates, or NIMBY against building more housing because of the effect of that housing on their quality of life and net worth. When you NIMBY, or charge high rates, you are asking other entities (those at the bottom) to provide you with so much more.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by beebeepka on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:04PM (#35756612)
Maybe I am too quick to judge but this strikes me as a completely uncalled for US-centric know it all take.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:10PM (#35756674)
This is a standard critique of capitalism, mercantilism, feudalism, state communism, and whatever your -ism of choice is. It's been done the world over for millennia. Every time someone in power or privilege has said "we must all sacrifice for the greater good" - the sacrifice is disproportionate, and those disproportionately affected have grumbled about it. Every time someone has said "we must preserve this particular thing", the preservation has been at the disproportionate expense of others, and those so affected have grumbled about it.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:56PM (#35757110)
Of course, "sacrifice for thee, not for mee".

See the Bank of England chief telling everyone they need to accept we're now all poorer otherwise inflation will never stop. Of course, by "us all being poorer" he most likely didn't include the wealthy elites and asset owning class that have made bank these past years and are in no way poorer than before, quite the contrary.

It was the same during covid. "We all need to scarifice to ...." meant something else entirely.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:59PM (#35757124)
Oh, we must all sacrifice the right to sleep on the street. Even the richest among us. :D
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by thriftwy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:13PM (#35756115)
People living humble are reluctant to have more children. But the ability to start your adult life humbly is definitely very important. I am talking about access to cheap rent small apartments to move off your parents' and then perhaps acquire one instead of renting.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by nashashmi on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:33PM (#35756298)
* * *
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by thriftwy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:25PM (#35756814)
People don't owe you children in exchange for your desire to treat them like exploited illegal immigrants. With that attitide, go and have all these children yourself.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by effingwewt on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:59PM (#35757127)
You did not just use the destitution Charlie lived in as a example of how poor people should live.

Poor people already live in squalor and are packed in like sardines, especially since housing costs keep rising.

How about the rich pay their fair share, or stop stealing money from the poor via wage theft, or stop conspiring to keep wages lower than ever, or how about stop people deciding about housing stopping NIMBYism, or how about putting a ceiling on CEO comp and stock buybacks, or how about dealing with the ever-widening wage gap.

Also, you've obviously never been to at least latin america, as their poverty is so bad they literally risk their lives getting anywhere else.

The mental gymnastics to blame the poor in your comments on this thread are Olympic level.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by nashashmi on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:35PM (#35757447)
* * *
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by eragmus on Sunday April 30, 2023 @06:06AM (#35761154)
Breadwinning is quickly becoming a foreign concept in the Western world, as the new strategy is simply breadtaking. Why work hard to win, when you can simply take?

What you need to understand is they are simply shameless, like they feel no shame to be dependent on others to provide for them. Historically people actually had shame, they would feel it hurts their dignity to accept even charity (voluntary donation of money)! But now, people in the West are even happy to take money even forcefully through the tax system. No more dignity, no more shame.

And this behavior is incentivized by our political system and tax system.

More details on this perspective, in my response to him, here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35761106

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by nashashmi on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:36PM (#35764194)
* * *
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by eragmus on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:55AM (#35761106)
Found the economically-illiterate entitled socialist, who refuses to think about personal responsibility (to actually become competitive in the global economy, to save money by being frugal and then to invest money to grow savings — you know, the things others on Earth do to become successful in life, doesn’t happen by magic!) as the answer to lower class financial problems… who instead only ever has his hand out trying to steal from the productive (and ready to blame the productive instead of himself at every opportunity!) to satisfy the unproductive’s natural urge to get money for nothing.

Meanwhile, in reality land in 2022:

>> The bottom 43% of US income tax filers pay -4.8% of federal income taxes (negative b/c they get a tax refund credit on average because of tax law).

>> The top 10% of taxpayers pay 80% of federal taxes.

But muh “rIcH nEeD tO pAy ThEiR fAiR sHaRe”!!!11

How about the bottom 43% of America actually sacrifices (studies during childhood to actually learn in and out of school + and actually works hard in first job to make good impression and get better job and actually learns on the job + maybe even starts their own company from learnings, all the while being frugal to maximize savings and then invest in a diversified stock index fund to grow savings over time with compound interest, and so on…) to build useful skills and become competitive in the global economy, the way people all around the world take responsibility to do?

Nahhh, way too much hard work!

Better to just waste childhood not valuing education, and then be a goodfornothing at your low-wage job so no one values you (IF indeed you are even capable of getting and holding the low-wage job), and then take your entitled personality that you carefully developed over all those years onto hackernews! (to complain about the small 10% minority who actually lived responsibly and made something of their lives and now pays 80% of federal taxes!)

This system is literally already socialist/communist in philosophy, in the distribution of percent of people paying taxes that sustains the system, but no, even this isn’t good enough. Why? Because of course it’s never good enough for the spoiled brat who is incentivized by the system to always be a spoiled brat, while 10% of the country literally carries them on their back.

Shameless!

You feel no shame to be dependent on others to provide for you. Historically people actually had shame, they would feel it hurts their dignity to accept even charity (voluntary donation of money)! But now, people in the West like you are even happy to take money even forcefully through the tax system. No more dignity, no more shame.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by thriftwy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:50AM (#35763052)
If everybody studies a lot, who will do all the menial, low paid jobs?

There are a couple of bad answers to this, ranging from making all white collar jobs way more competitive and still forcing now-educated people take menial jobs and be poor; to bringing illegal immigrants in to exploit.

The good answer is to pay good money to less educated people doing somple jobs. Bonus point, they will contribute taxes.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by Gareth321 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:45PM (#35756421)
> In most of Europe, lack of affordability and quality family friendly housing, is the number one reason for couples not having kids.

This is not correct. The poorest households are having the most kids. It has clearly little to do with income or housing affordability, even if you found a survey which indicated this. I say this as someone who delayed having a family until I could afford a home, so I have a dog in this fight.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:55PM (#35756543)
The poorest do because they have little education in terms of contraception and safe sex and because they have low standards for QoL for their kids and just hump away like mammals without thinking about it, but the educated middle class, or what's left of it anyway, practice safe sex and want good conditions for their kids therefore only make them if they can guarantee good conditions for the, .
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by mensetmanusman on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:47PM (#35759306)
At some point we probably won’t label a dying/negative-growth subset of the population that can’t figure out how to procreate or even create the pertinent conditions to procreate ‘educated’
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by dragonwriter on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:59PM (#35759350)
> At some point we probably won’t label a dying/negative-growth subset of the population that can’t figure out how to procreate or even create the pertinent conditions to procreate ‘educated’

Yeah, society probably will, because those are the people putting energy into preserving and propagating their ideas.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:59AM (#35760826)
Society doesn't care about helping to procreate the educated. For society, you're just a number in an balance sheet, you're just a consumer and a tax payer, cannon fodder for the economy basically.

Your country needs more and more numbers in that balance sheet, to funnel into the economic meat grinder, and whether those extra numbers come from your offspring or from someone else's, it's irelevant to them.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by Gareth321 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:43AM (#35784523)
I agree with some of your conclusions, but the premise holds. There are lots of reasons for low fertility, and income/cost of living isn't actually a major factor.
Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by kypro on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:45PM (#35756426)
Time and families are also a problem today.

People have less relatives to help raise children and grandparents tend to be older. Both parents are also more likely to want and need to work full-time jobs.

I don't know why but here in the UK there seems to be a kind of culture war on parenthood too. Young women who want kids and don't want to work tend to be shamed for this decision, while women who remain single and focus on their careers are celebrated. If people want careers over children, that's fine, but that shouldn't be seen and pushed as the only respectable path by society.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:53PM (#35756520)
>Young women who want kids and don't want to work tend to be shamed for this decision, while women who remain single and focus on their careers are celebrated.

That's only toxic feminism pushing for this narrative but pretty sure it's just a loud minority in certain echo chambers and not a national narrative.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:01PM (#35757684)
Anyone opining on pre-historic nature and evolution is spinning a just-so story, unless they're literally data-mining paleontologic or genomic evidence, and if they're doing the later they're talking about the results and conclusions in a much different manner.

> Once you push the sex responsible for birth to do a lot of the breadwinning, procreation of the species starts to fall apart.

There's no reason to assume that single-mothers weren't common in the past, absent direct paleontological evidence. There's no reason to assume that a supported mother isn't being supported by her blood relatives, while the father of her child(ren) is off doing his own thing (there are actually societies which function this way). And absent very short period of time in the few months immediately around actual childbirth, hunter-gatherer women were probably quite capable of supporting themselves.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:27PM (#35758306)
>Anyone opining on pre-historic nature and evolution is spinning a just-so story

Nobody was talking about hunter gatherer societies but you.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:33PM (#35758336)
>>> nature and evolution

Evolution of humans doesn't happen so fast that it doesn't encompass hunter-gatherer cultures (or pre-historic cultures in general, the latest of which were agricultural).

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:54AM (#35760484)
Except women have been entering the workforce en-masse only about 70 or so years ago, in the post-WW2 industrialization.

No need to bring up evolution for that.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by anonymouskimmer on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:28PM (#35764674)
You brought evolution up. And women exiting the workforce was a modern, temporary convenience, primarily for the middle classes. The only thing genuinely new is that women and men now have exactly the same job opportunities (with only minimal exceptions).

https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1345/women-in-the-middl...

> women worked alongside men in the fields and in the medieval guilds as equals or near-equals.

> Throughout the Middle Ages, lower-class women were bakers, brewers, milkmaids, barmaids, artisans, weavers and, primarily, tenant farmers who worked alongside their husbands and children in the fields.

https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1136/women-in-ancient-c...

> Women of lower status, such as farmer's wives, were expected to work in the fields - especially in regions where rice was cultivated.

> Many women were forced into prostitution in times of drought or crop failure. Women worked in the home weaving silk and caring for the silkworms that produced it. Some were called upon, like men, to perform the labour service which acted as a form of taxation in many periods of ancient China, but this was only in exceptional circumstances. By the Song dynasty (960-1279 CE) women had more freedom and were running inns and acting as midwives amongst other professions.

https://www.worldhistory.org/article/623/women-in-ancient-eg...

> Women, therefore, were regularly employed as weavers, bakers, brewers, professional mourners, sandal-makers, launderers, basket weavers, cooks, waitresses, or as a "Mistress of the House," known today as an estate owner or property manager. Female brewers and launderers frequently supervised male workers.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by dragonwriter on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:13PM (#35759393)
> In most of Europe, lack of affordability and quality family friendly housing, is the number one reason for couples not having kids.

Its the number one reason people cite, but if you look at the stats, fertility (and this is also true in the US) drops pretty consistently with income. So, its not really driven by affordability in the simple, direct sense. So, are people lying? Maybe not: stress and precarious conditions often explain within-species shifts further toward r-strategy (produce more offsprinf with lower investment in each) vs. K-strategy (fewer offspring with higher investment). We may just be witnessing that in humans.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by bradlys on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:49PM (#35759548)
When you have a high income - you have more to lose by having children. When you have a low to no income - you don’t lose as much.

It’s why poor people always seem to have more kids. There are other factors but it’s one of the large ones.

Re:Sperm donor who fathered 550 children ordered to stop by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:41AM (#35760735)
High income doesn't mean rich millionaires with McMansions. In Europe high income is basically middle class where half you money goes in taxes, and half of what's left goes on rent, then good luck buying a house.

Poor people have nothing to loose from having kids, they already live or are used to poor and difficult conditions, but the middle class has the most to loose from bringing up kids as it means a QoL sacrifice and/or more stress of finding a career that enables them to keep the QoL with kids.

For rich people that's not a problem.