If the weed-out classes were having a statistical effect, then we’d see it in the outcomes. So either we are seeing it, and the success rate of a college degree would be even higher without the weed-out classes, or your contrived example in reality has little to no effect on the outcomes. Either way, your example might disenfranchise a few people who aren’t prepared or capable of handling college at all, but on the whole most people fare well with the education. Maybe the weeder classes don’t matter because people try again, or switch majors, or continue without transferring. Or maybe the number of people hitting such a weeder class is low, or maybe the 12% pass rate is very exaggerated and not at all representative of the average pass rate?
No it doesn't. You are wrong. There are a number of well understood ways where you would not see deviations like this in the statistical outcomes. Flawed, skewed, or under-representing metrics being one, as I mentioned in another post. Garbage in Garbage out.
If you compare the success rate of US college against the EU, there are big differences but this is apples to oranges comparison with arguably the same outcomes.
I fared well with education in every class except the structured to fail classes. What does it say when you have a student who passes Calculus 3 and above with a high 90, and can't pass Mechanics that solely tests Math in 3 question, two test format with causality properties between the questions on each test.
Honestly it just sounds like you are trying to make excuses like most people do because you want to believe that college is a solid investment. In my experience, and many others; its not.
Its a drain on financial resources with moving goal posts with no determinable way to pass for those classes that are structured to fail.
Any value-based research that neglects these is just junk science.