News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bottom line, a college degree is worth the cost and then ... by dahart on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:47AM (#35714495)
> what about causality?

A bunch of researchers have asked that question and tried to answer it the best they can, by using statistical methods to discount for things like high family income, race, family history of college attendance.

From what I’ve seen (and I’ll try to dig up links in a minute if I can) papers often conclude that the causality is definitely not 100% responsible for the income difference between grads and non-grads, but they also generally find the number is much higher than 0% too. It’s somewhere in the middle.

It’s not really a stretch to suggest that something happens during college, right? People do learn things when they spend their time learning, and we have plenty of data to show that people who get an elementary and secondary education are better off than people who get no education… or take it a step further and look at basic literacy. Why is it hard to believe there’s value in college when it’s not hard to believe that literacy and pre-college education has value?

> consider not going to college and achieving great things without burning 4-5 years of opportunity cost

While that can be true for a few naturally motivated and smart (or lucky) people, the aggregate stats don’t really support that view. Most people end up better off going to school, and opening the door to the many higher paying jobs that require a degree.

* edit: here’s an example: https://www.stlouisfed.org/-/media/project/frbstl/stlouisfed...

See “Section III: “The True (Causal) Return on a College Education: Evidence from the 2016 SCF”

The conclusion: “In order to examine the effect of these variables in accounting for some of the relationship between education, income and wealth, we utilized multiple regression. All variables, including age variables, own education, parents’ education, and financial acumen, were regressed onto income and wealth. This model was compared to the simple model of only lifecycle and own education. Results are in Tables 6 and 7. (See Tables B1-B6 for black, Hispanic and other race results).

“Clearly, parents’ education and financial acumen were important variables previously omitted in estimations of the college and post-graduate premiums (see Table 8). Together, these variables reduced the income premium by 32 percent for white terminal bachelor’s degree holders and by 29 percent for white postgraduate degree holders. The reductions of the wealth premium were even starker, with this premium being reduced by over half for graduates and postgraduates (54.4 percent and 60.4 percent, respectively).”

Re:Bottom line, a college degree is worth the cost and then ... by than3 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:28AM (#35750853)
Well none of those studies take into account US-style weed-out classes where there may be a 12% pass rate for a bottleneck transfer class, and the class is structured to fail students.

Any value-based research that neglects these is just junk science.

Re:Bottom line, a college degree is worth the cost and then ... by dahart on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:41AM (#35763607)
That’s not true. The study I cited does account for your pet-peeve example, because they’re treating university as a black box and examining the outcomes. This captures all the weed-out classes along with everything else that happens in college.

If the weed-out classes were having a statistical effect, then we’d see it in the outcomes. So either we are seeing it, and the success rate of a college degree would be even higher without the weed-out classes, or your contrived example in reality has little to no effect on the outcomes. Either way, your example might disenfranchise a few people who aren’t prepared or capable of handling college at all, but on the whole most people fare well with the education. Maybe the weeder classes don’t matter because people try again, or switch majors, or continue without transferring. Or maybe the number of people hitting such a weeder class is low, or maybe the 12% pass rate is very exaggerated and not at all representative of the average pass rate?

Re:Bottom line, a college degree is worth the cost and then ... by than3 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:38PM (#35766392)
> That's not true. This captures all the weed-out classes.

No it doesn't. You are wrong. There are a number of well understood ways where you would not see deviations like this in the statistical outcomes. Flawed, skewed, or under-representing metrics being one, as I mentioned in another post. Garbage in Garbage out.

If you compare the success rate of US college against the EU, there are big differences but this is apples to oranges comparison with arguably the same outcomes.

I fared well with education in every class except the structured to fail classes. What does it say when you have a student who passes Calculus 3 and above with a high 90, and can't pass Mechanics that solely tests Math in 3 question, two test format with causality properties between the questions on each test.

Honestly it just sounds like you are trying to make excuses like most people do because you want to believe that college is a solid investment. In my experience, and many others; its not.

Its a drain on financial resources with moving goal posts with no determinable way to pass for those classes that are structured to fail.

Re:Bottom line, a college degree is worth the cost and then ... by dahart on Monday May 01, 2023 @04:14PM (#35778519)
I don’t know what you’re talking about, but you’ve said next to nothing that is verifiable and haven’t included any links to references or stats in your rant, so with nothing verifiable, you’ve left me with no choice but to mostly ignore the comment. FWIW, using words like ‘lies’ and ‘fraud’ and ‘junk science’ are all red flags to me and make it sound like you have more of a bone to pick than an objective viewpoint. I have no idea what your experience is, it’s not possible for me to minimize it intentionally, and I’m sincerely sorry you feel that way as it’s not my intention, but it should be as obvious to you as it is to me that your experience could have deviated from the norm, maybe you were unlucky. In any case I’m left completely unconvinced by your argument that there’s anything missing from the Fed’s statistics relating to weeder classes that affects the broad outcomes of students. Even part of your explanation, under-represented metrics, is exactly what I suggested as well. Maybe the weeder classes aren’t experienced by most people, and therefore aren’t detrimental to the overall outcomes, in average. Or- and your wall of text failed to consider this possibility- that weeder classes are affecting outcomes negatively, and the outcomes would be even better without such classes. It’s possible that you’re right and the statistics are also right.