News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:40PM (#35734225)
What? What exactly is the benefit of SpaceX specifically? What was won here? Is there a point at which it starts being a large price?

If we don't know the impact of it on the habitat, how is it a "small price"?

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by myth_drannon on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:47PM (#35734318)
The benefit is, when Earth is polluted beyond help, Musk and his progeny can escape our planet and live on Mars.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by ben_w on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:56PM (#35734445)
The minimum level of pollution where Mars looks good on that basis is:

1. killed literally, not metaphorically, everything

2. and literally boiled off all the oceans, rivers, and lakes, top the bottom

3. and strip mined literally, not metaphorically, everywhere to a depth of 3,000 km

4. and removed almost everything from the atmosphere except the current level of CO2/m^3

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by yamtaddle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:12PM (#35734679)
Yes, but if Earth suffers several unlikely global catastrophes at the same time, it might almost be harder to live here than on Mars!
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by NoGravitas on Friday April 28, 2023 @10:35AM (#35741760)
Yeah, I'll believe Mars colonization makes sense once the much closer and more hospitable environments of interior Antarctica and the ocean floor are settled.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by ben_w on Friday April 28, 2023 @11:47AM (#35742789)
Ocean floor is a different kind of problem, and Antarctica (and Greenland) have settlements.

But for similar reasons, I think we should aim for the Moon before Mars: closer, so when (and it is "when" not "if") something goes fatally wrong, it will be easier to get help.

That said, if Starship delivers on Musk's vision, we'll probably get both.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by pjscott on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:02PM (#35734533)
Even a "polluted beyond help" Earth would be easier to live on than Mars. We have liquid water, a nice thick atmosphere that isn't 95% carbon dioxide, a better ionosphere, easy access to nitrogen as a synthetic fertilizer feedstock, and various other advantages. Musk knows this; he's not an idiot, nor is he a cartoon villain motivated by a desire to be Evil.

It bothers me when people just make up outlandish accusations.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by NoGravitas on Friday April 28, 2023 @10:36AM (#35741772)
Actually, the available evidence does suggest that Musk is an idiot.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by apendleton on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:55PM (#35734438)
Even assuming an absolute worst-case scenario climate-wise (no mitigations whatsoever, massive sea-level rise, etc.), Earth will still be dramatically more hospitable to human life than Mars for the entirety of Musk's lifetime, and very likely his children's and grandchildren's lifetimes as well, barring some mass-extinction event like a nuclear war. Even if a colonization effort begins soon, living on Mars is likely to be extremely difficult for centuries -- we can't breathe the air or grow anything in the soil, our biology is likely ill-adapted to the gravity, there is no liquid surface water, etc. -- and the idea that there will come a point in the foreseeable future where it makes sense to escape there because it's easier than being here (because of pollution or whatever other reason) is difficult to fathom.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by Litost on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:57PM (#35734456)
I guess it's always worth having a Plan B, but Nate Hagens and Kim Stanley Robinson (sci-fi writer of the Mars Trilogy) discuss this and don't necessarily agree, obviously depending on what definition of "polluted beyond help" you're using etc. [1]

Nate Hagens (00:43:15):

"And to me it's very smart and famous people, Stephen Hawking, Elon Musk among them say, "We're screwing up Earth. Climate is going to be bad. We need to colonize outer space and head to Mars." And that makes just zero sense to me, because on the worst thermonuclear runaway-climate scenario, Earth is still going to be a paradise next to Mars. I mean-"

Kim Stanley Robinson (00:43:43):

"I agree with you completely. That is a case that has to be made. And the thing about people like Hawkings, the thing about people like Elon Musk is they're smart, they aren't that smart. They aren't wise, they aren't philosophers, and they're not ecologists. Very often physicists will assume that ecology is just physics in action, and that they've got it all sussed out because they know the rules of physics and they can do rocketry. But you can't do plant biology just knowing rocketry. It's more complex, it's more interconnected, it's a more-complex science. And many physicists will arrogantly say that, "Because I know the laws of physics, I know everything." But they don't know how a marsh works. They haven't studied biology enough to understand their own ignorance. So how smart are you if you don't know how ignorant you are?"

[1] - https://www.thegreatsimplification.com/episode/66-kim-stanle...

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by skrowl on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:48PM (#35734353)
We're one killer global war / pandemic / etc away from extinction

Being on multiple planets (and eventually multiple solar systems) prevents a species from going extinct if something catastrophic happens to their home world

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by jliptzin on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:58PM (#35734474)
The sun is gonna blow up anyway and eat the whole solar system
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by ben_w on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:03PM (#35734557)
Yeah, but even the sun getting too hot for complex life on Earth in particular is something like 2 billion years before that.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by vkou on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:55PM (#35734430)
> We're one killer global war / pandemic / etc away from extinction

No, we're not. And whatever we end up doing to the Earth, it's still going to be vastly more suitable for human life than anywhere else in the solar system.

If you care about preventing extinction, stop looking at the stars, and start digging bunkers. Or building undersea cities, or whatever.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by ben_w on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:01PM (#35734525)
All true, but I say a backup plan is better than no backup plan, especially as this is one (admittedly rich) sci-fi nerd's hobby project.

As even that specific nerd is also doing a big project to reduce environmental damage, this isn't an "either/or", it's an "and".

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by timeon on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:21PM (#35735281)
Why is this important?
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by taejavu on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:49PM (#35734356)
What was won is a small but vital step toward humans becoming a multiplanetary species. From this angle, the impact of this launch is obviously a small price.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by bonzini on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:58PM (#35734475)
A multiplanetary species is simply not going to happen, since there are no plans to figure out a way to not make your blood boil (literally) on the surface of Mars or the Moon.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dgrin91 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:25PM (#35734820)
Except for the multiple studies exploring how to build habitats on mars/moon and how to build spacesuits that would function on mars/moon.

Listen, I get it. We're not going to have a million person utopian colony on Mars in 2026. That doesn't mean we shouldn't try to shoot for a small 4 person colony in 2032 to start doing research. This is currently our most promising way to get there.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by aenis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:11PM (#35734659)
Progress happens iteratively. We figure out how to get there first, we'll - or future generations will - figure out how to live there comfortably. Dead cats and birds, well, small price to pay for getting us off this rock.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:13PM (#35734681)
Is being a multiplanetary species the plan? I don't really care or believe it will happen - or that it would have actual benefits.

So we just suffer until the people that want to colonize other planets and trash this one?

Bit odd no?

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:13PM (#35734693)
And wait where do you think we're going then? Not leaving the solar system are you?
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by bonzini on Friday April 28, 2023 @10:04AM (#35741400)
I am content with not screwing up Earth beyond the point of no return. Seems hard enough.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by politician on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:07PM (#35734612)
Did you know that there are many activities that you can do on the Earth that, without appropriate technical equipment, are fatal? From diving to mountaineering or living in deserts, mankind has overcome many challenging environments.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by bonzini on Friday April 28, 2023 @02:39AM (#35738194)
I know, I am a decent scuba diver. Any of those activities is not something you do 24/7/365. Even underwater it takes more time to die than on Mars (where it's instant as soon as the airlock fails).
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by politician on Friday April 28, 2023 @10:49AM (#35741944)
Consider the Tibetans who evolved unique genetic adaptations that allow them to better survive in the low oxygen environment of the Himalayas. Or the Inca, who developed specific architecture and agricultural technologies to deal with the high winds, limited arable lands, and harsh weather in the Andes. These are dangerous environments that supported a significant population 24/7/365.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by bonzini on Friday April 28, 2023 @11:37AM (#35742581)
Again, dangerous != instantly killing you. At least there were animals and plants in the Andes, and oxygen in the Himalayas.

(BTW it was the Denisovans not the Tibetans. Tibetans got the mutation from the Denisovans).

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:54PM (#35734419)
What was the step?

In this specific explosion?

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by taejavu on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:00PM (#35735580)
One less explosion before they figure out how to fly and reuse the rocket. You understand how learning works, right?
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:30PM (#35735809)
Thanks for the snark

You understand that this test was too early, proved nothing and had little to no way to mitigate the likely explosion that they expected?

And that the impact on the nearby residents, the wildlife were not taken in consideration?

But it's fine because "surely they learned something"?

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by taejavu on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:51PM (#35735943)
You're welcome. That's correct, it's a worthwhile tradeoff.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:04PM (#35736025)
You'd be great at the head of a totalitarian regime!

You should move next to the test site, I'm sure you'll be glad to be one of the people affected.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by taejavu on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:22PM (#35736139)
I tried, but turns out they won't let people live too close to a rocket launch site. Something about safety concerns. Who knew?!
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:36PM (#35736234)
I just learned the launch was on 4/20, and the tanks spelled 420 as well.

I'm sure this did not rush the launch. I'm sure people aren't going to get cancer because of a 420 bit.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:25PM (#35736167)
You know, google is free, everybody can use it:https://www.cnbc.com/2023/04/24/spacex-starship-explosion-sp...
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:32PM (#35736211)
Sike
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by elil17 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:59PM (#35734497)
I'd rather take care of the one planet we have right now. Not that it has to be mutually exclusive.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by B4CKlash on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:58PM (#35734477)
There's something deeply ironic about a person commenting from a highly-engineered device, operating on a highly-engineered network, sitting inside of a highly-engineered building, in a highly-engineered city debating the merits of progress.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by Clamchop on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:23PM (#35734800)
I read their comment as underlining the uncertainty about what the cost or the reward is. Maybe we can't flippantly declare that it's "a small price" if we don't know what we're paying or what we're going to get in return. (I have no position on that.)

Didn't spot any ludditism.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:15PM (#35734714)
I'd love for you to make a link between the "progress" here and what you mentionned!
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by rio517 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:02PM (#35734530)
No everyone is aware, but SpaceX mass to orbit is close to the rest of the world put together. Hey are massively reducing costs to access space. The point of the starship is to continue to reduce costs.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:14PM (#35734707)
But why? When costs are low... What then? Tourism?
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by couchdive on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#35735868)
honestly, this is all to plunder the solar system further. Mining asteroids, etc. Of course the R&D is tax payer publicly funded and the future profits privatized. This is the way it has always been.
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:09PM (#35736050)
I guess I just don't see the point. We're not leaving earth, no one wants to life in orbital stations or habitats - nonobstant all the issues with making that happen, so why plunder the solar system? There is more matter to plunder on earth than we would need to cover the whole globe with people, what's the point of trying get our great-great-great-great-grandkids to mine asteroids? Even more questionable if it makes our own and the life of the people coming next to be measurably worse
Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by Ancapistani on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:14PM (#35735239)
Access to orbit is a requirement for our current level of technological civilization.

SpaceX's launch capability is not only much greater than that of competitors (including states), they're using methane fuel and do not use solid fuel boosters.

For context, ESA's Ariane 5 uses solid fuel boosters (ammonium perchlorate, aluminum, hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene) and a liquid fuel second stage (monomethylhydrazine, nitrogen tetroxide). NASA's SLS uses solid fuel boosters of the same composition and Ariane 5's. So does JAXA's H3.

If, as a species, we're going to be launching things into orbit, doing so using the SpaceX's tech is significantly cleaner than what we're using today. That's true even before considering reuse.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:01PM (#35735601)
When was it determined that access to orbit was a requirement? And a requirement to what?

I feel like many are living in a world of sci fi.

Our orbit is already littered with orbital trash, we are worried we wont be able to leave orbit if it keeps going.

I don't see how this is justifiable in any way. There are very few worthwile things to do in space.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by Ancapistani on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:32PM (#35736564)
> When was it determined that access to orbit was a requirement?

I’d say for the general public, some time in the 90s. For states, as far back as the 60s or 70s I’d say.

> And a requirement to what?

Off the top of my head? Current uses would include communications, navigation/positioning, remote sensing, research, and exploration.

Future uses will almost certainly include access to the resources of the rest of the solar system. In the grand scheme of things, we’re not that far away from being able to capture, relocate, and mine asteroids. Many of those contain resources that are extremely rare or difficult to obtain on Earth.

For example - I think we can agree that moving automobiles from ICE to EV will be a good thing for our biosphere. Cobalt is one of the raw materials that is in short supply. There are two near-Earth asteroids that combined are believed to exceed the Earth’s reserves for cobalt:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamiecartereurope/2021/10/19/th...

If SpaceX does succeed in driving down the cost to orbit, mining those (and others like them) will be much more practical.

> Our orbit is already littered with orbital trash, we are worried we wont be able to leave orbit if it keeps going.

We’re a long way from risking Kessler Syndrome, and have the technology and experience to prevent it from occurring.

Re:Photos from the SpaceX Debris Field by dmbche on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:17PM (#35736828)
Thanks for the reply. I didn't know we weren't near Kessler syndrome, I'll look into it!

EDIT: Looking at your name, are you ancap??

When do you think (ballpark) it would be realistic? I'm seeing so many problems with it - how do you get the stuff from asteroids to earth? (Mass drivers are a nice idea, but in practice I doubt the public would accept hurling tons of material towards earth). There are so many problems that we have a hard time expecting, like lunar dust[0], issues with the code used to run the equipement, as it is often to far away to be reliably controled remotely (The cassini mission is a good example if I remember correctly)

While I agree that for communications and the likes, sattelite coverage is a net benefit, you have to agree that the material benefits of exploration and research in space are undefined at best - it's entirely possible we'll find nothing useful for a bit.

I think it's important to keep things in perspective - how many order of magnitude is SpaceX better compared to the old tech? How many launches do we actually need to do yearly? Is there a point where the environemental cost starts to be equivalent?

I'd like to see how much the current space race is damaging to the environnement compared to using the old designs - imagine it's equivalent to 50 years of launches (not a real number), it then becomes much less excusable. Imagine if we stalled the current space race for 15-20 years and had everybody forced to only run simulations, I'm certain there wouldn't be as many botched tests and designs as we are seeing, other compagnies included.(For reference, since the nuclear bomb test ban all nuke design is made in simulators [1]

[0]:https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.bbc.com/future/arti...

[1] :https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/virtual-nuclear-weapons-d...