News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Did Google Brain Exist? by khazhoux on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:51PM (#35719032)
I totally get why people act this way. Because it's Very Important That Everyone Knows What I Think.

But there is no inequity or conflict of interest here. None of that about being trapped in a capitalist economy is to the point here. He has probably a couple million dollars in his bank account that wasn't there before, and the deal was to not talk publicly about internals (which includes promotions process, internal motivations and decision-making, etc).

Re:Why Did Google Brain Exist? by pessimizer on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:59PM (#35719152)
You don't think there's any inequity between somebody with a couple million in the bank and google, or any conflict of interest between my desire to talk about my work and my employer's desire that I do not? Your position is valid enough without being willfully obtuse.
Re:Why Did Google Brain Exist? by khazhoux on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:27PM (#35719493)
Once you agree to not talk about it (as part of the employment terms), then there is zero conflict of interest.

"Yes, I agree to not share internal info, in exchange for this money. And by the way, I will still share internal info, because inequity."

Re:Why Did Google Brain Exist? by bbor on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:41PM (#35720947)
You're thinking about employment contracts like an abstract economic exchange between two free parties, which is very micro. Try thinking about it instead like a bargain with the (macro) devil.

In other words, consider someone's perspective who has society split into two camps: the people who do all the work, and the corrupt elite that make their living through theft and oppression. In such a world, signing a contract with an employer (i.e. capitalist i.e. elite) is more of a practical step than a sacrosanct bond. There's a level of "what's reasonable" and "what legally enforceable" beyond the basic "never break a promise" level you're working at, IMO.

No ones endorsing publishing trade secrets randomly, but you're treating all disclosures like they're equivalent.

Re:Why Did Google Brain Exist? by packetslave on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:33PM (#35719552)
Yet for some reason OP and everyone here are supposed to care what YOU think?
Re:Why Did Google Brain Exist? by khazhoux on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:37PM (#35719627)
I'm not suggesting people shouldn't post thoughts and opinions. This is about whether a personal desire to self-express, should override their explicit prior commitment/promise not to do so.