News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jackmott42 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:30AM (#35714205)
Our point of view is that we should not allow beta self driving software on the roads until it is proven safe. We do not know how safe it is, nor can we know because Tesla controls that data and is not transparent with it.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:41AM (#35714391)
Should we allow teenagers to drive on the road before they have proven to be safe? We don’t know how safe they are.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jackmott42 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:45AM (#35714470)
No, we should require that they pass a driving test, pay for insurance, and register their vehicle with license plates. If I were emperor I would raise the driving age to 18 as well.

vote often, vote early

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:54AM (#35714603)
A person who was passed a driving test, paid for insurance and registered the vehicle is responsible for the car at all times, even when FSD beta is operating.

Come to Australia, the driving age here is 18. (And for your first three years as a licensed driver, you have to show plates to indicate your lack of experience because, unlike in the stupid USA, we don’t assume that passing one driving test is enough to qualify you as a “good driver”.)

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by tsimionescu on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:55AM (#35714626)
No, and we don't. That's why driving instruction and driving tests exist.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:58AM (#35714688)
Thirty thousand people die on US roads every year because of the actions of people who received driving instruction and passed a driving test.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by rootusrootus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:14AM (#35714974)
This is a better argument for improving training and testing than it is in lowering the bar and letting a buggy computer program drive.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:49AM (#35715668)
Do you really think there's more room to improve human nature than AI technology? I don't.

I think they both have a ceiling and that the ceiling on AI is much higher.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by rootusrootus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:53AM (#35715760)
Yes? The largest causes of accidents are fairly well understood, if we decided it were worth the effort. Not coincidentally, this is why all the arguments for self-driving fall flat. Being as good as an average driver is a low bar. Being as good as a median driver is a harder task. But it's the latter that is the bar we have to pass if self-driving cars are ever to become mainstream.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:16PM (#35716124)
Deaths = N*average, not N*median.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by rootusrootus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:44PM (#35717452)
I was not trying to claim otherwise. But unless you are intending to make self-driving cars mandatory, N*average is meaningless. The median driver is who you actually need to convince, and they are not going to choose a self-driving car that is less safe than they are.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by simondotau on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @09:42PM (#35722236)
It was only intended as an argument as a direct response to the post by tsimionescu. Tesla could focus on making FSD beta satisfy the driver test given to teenagers. It could perform the test as well as any 16-year-old and we'd all agree that it wouldn't really prove anything about the safety of FSD or the human teenager.

Which is my point — the road is full of hideously bad/dangerously inexperienced human drivers holding driver licenses. Given this, it's hard for me to interpret the pearl-clutching around humans co-driving with FSD beta as anything other than confected paranoia.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by kibwen on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:11AM (#35714926)
And ubiquitous FSD could easily make that number worse, not better.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by kaba0 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:07PM (#35716932)
Many (most?) accidents are due to a clearly in the wrong driver (drunk-driving, texting, etc), and the other parties have no way of avoiding that. How exactly would a few self-driving cars help here? They can’t prevent a collision when the other party goes over a red light at some insane speed. They could start breaking sooner, which is great, but that doesn’t need self driving, it is a feature of plenty of cars already.

Of course if every car would be self driving we wouldn’t have crazy drivers, and accidents would diminish, but so would if we simply didn’t have crazy drivers. Neither is feasible in the near future, and in the short term, humans are much better at handling tricky situations (like.. not emergency braking at the sight of a plastic bag in the air)

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by hnburnsy on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:57PM (#35722794)
I'd bet that Tesla FSD could pass most DMV driving tests in the US.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by ndsipa_pomu on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:39AM (#35725026)
That'd be really interesting to see how well it does.

I wonder why there's no modified version of driving tests for AVs that each software iteration takes.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by slg on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:02AM (#35714755)
I totally understand where you are coming from. However, I don’t think it is possible to prove this type of technology is safe in the real world without lots of data of it being used in the real world. Requiring proof first like you suggest creates a catch-22 situation in which self driving technology can never be released.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by rootusrootus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:13AM (#35714956)
Automakers already use proving grounds. We can set a minimum standard for FSD before turning it loose with amateur drivers.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by slg on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:27AM (#35715249)
You can’t test self driving tech the same way you can test most safety technology. It is easy to test something like an airbag. You throw dummies in the seats and run the car into a wall. There is no equivalent for self driving tech. The tech needs to be able to handle any weird situation that humans and nature throw at it. You therefore need a huge number or interactions, billions of miles worth, to be confident in its safety. You can’t just put a car through a test track to see if it is safe. The range of situations the technology needs to be able to respond to is too large to fully test like this.

It is a perfectly valid policy to want that proof ahead of time. I’m just pointing out that this requirement would effectively kill development of this technology for the foreseeable future.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by rootusrootus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:59AM (#35715856)
Is Tesla using customer cars for training data? That should be very noticeable, it is a lot of data that would be getting fed back. If they're not, then the billions of miles driven by customers isn't relevant, and the same "can't just put a car through a test track" problem exists at the training level.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:01PM (#35715887)
Yes they are, yes it is very noticeable, and yes it is a lot of very important data that could not have been collected on a test track.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by rootusrootus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:47PM (#35717497)
I'd like to see something to back that claim. The amounts of data we're talking about are quite significantly more than any I've seen people experience in real life. As far as I can tell, customer cars run inference only, collect very little data unless something prompts them to (and even then, store it locally), and contribute almost zero to the training set.
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:30PM (#35719524)
Here's a statement from 2022. They had a labeling team of 1500 people and they laid off about 200 after the labeling infrastructure team finished an auto-labeler, so it's not just a bloated team. Do you think they are keeping 1300 people busy correcting labels on purely internal data?

https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/tesla-lays-off-over-...

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by UncleEntity on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:09PM (#35716012)
Google’s robocars seem to be taking a very conservative approach to integration with the motoring public.

Don’t get me wrong, I irrationally hate the robots, used to see them all the time around Phoenix, was actively gunning for them and only had one time I could have rammed one[0] with it not being my fault. Which says a lot because it was (well, still is) a life goal to take out a robocar so I was really trying.

I used to see them doing a bunch of really stupid stuff but never anything that was outright dangerous, relatively speaking. One did stop in the fast lane when everyone was zipping by at 70+ because it couldn’t figure out how to merge into the left hand exit ramp but plenty of snow birds do that too so it’s not completely unheard of.

[0] (un)fortunately I was behind on my rent and couldn’t afford to spend who knows how long dealing with an accident investigation so the robot got to go about its day unmolested.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by rootusrootus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:51PM (#35717540)
Google's approach is more defensible. They are careful, default to conservative behavior and stop when confused, and had professional drivers for years. And even then they're a road hazard.

At least they hold liability if anything happens, though, which is an important step.

Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by kaba0 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:01PM (#35716830)
Also, since parts of it is a blackbox, doesn’t any update literally clears out any former result and should be revalidated from scratch?
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by ndsipa_pomu on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:51AM (#35715705)
The sensible method is for the manufacturer to perform lots of testing and make available the data. Legislators can then allow limited real world usage to determine if there's problems and then expand that usage as appropriate. e.g. allow autonomous vehicles to take control on motorways (sorry, that's a UK term - is it freeways in the U.S.?).
Re:Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data by jjoonathan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:00PM (#35715869)
That's exactly what happened. There was a back and forth with NHTSA for years before the beta started going public, and the rollout was carefully staged. At first, you needed a high safety score and it was aggressively geofenced. Those restrictions were gradually lifted as they collected data, and it still has attentiveness monitoring and a strike system. Tesla and NHTSA go back and forth on details all the time -- just recently NHTSA demanded some adjustments for stop signs and yellow lights.