News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Could we stop Yellowstone from erupting with a giant geothermal power plant?. Parent comment

Re:Could we stop Yellowstone from erupting with a giant geot... by version_five on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @02:14PM (#35704444)
> I can imagine that the consequence of this might actually just be strengthening the "barrier" the magma has to erupt through, and when it finally builds up enough energy to do that, it'll be stronger in proportion to how strong the newly cooled down barrier had become?

Certainly the movie version has the one rogue scientist working late into the night redoing the calculations and realizing that as soon as the plant goes live it will trigger the volcano.

In real life, I have no idea how this kind of thing gets analyzed, and what kind of uncertainty is involved. It feels a bit like those "put a bunch of reflectors in space to stop climate change" ideas. On the other hand, removing energy from a system seems like a good way to make it safer...

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Could we stop Yellowstone from erupting with a giant geot... by macintux on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @02:29PM (#35704668)
> Certainly the movie version has the one rogue scientist working late into the night redoing the calculations and realizing that as soon as the plant goes live it will trigger the volcano.

Jor El in any number of them.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Could we stop Yellowstone from erupting with a giant geot... by its_ethan on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @02:46PM (#35704894)
> In real life, I have no idea how this kind of thing gets analyzed, and what kind of uncertainty is involved.

This is similar to what I was trying to get across -- how do we know something this complicated will have only the intended effect that the author is describing?

The comparison to reflectors in space to address climate concerns is a great one - something where a first pass/ back of the envelope makes it seem interesting, but any amount of detail added reveals that we'd have no clue what would happen

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Could we stop Yellowstone from erupting with a giant geot... by marcosdumay on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @04:21PM (#35706208)
> On the other hand, removing energy from a system seems like a good way to make it safer...

Nope, that one rule of thumb can't help you. There is way too much energy for that to make any difference.

Just notice how the timescale of an active disaster is completely different from the ones estimated for success.

[ Parent | on HN ]