http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Act_1998
I naively thought that iOS Apps wouldn't do this, in part, because it was illegal.
Because no-one ever checks up on them.
I guess you're saying don't blame Apple, blame the criminals. Okay, I blame the criminals. Crime is always the criminal's fault.
But I'd also like Apple to protect me from them. Especially since the App Store is advertised as a safe place and this view is reinforced by protecting access to other types of private data in the system.
I'm not blaming Apple for the behavior of criminals, but I am blaming Apple for failing to deliver a product that will protect me from them.
Nobody is suggesting it should be impossible to integrate with contacts. The suggestion is it should be impossible to do so without asking my permission, as is the case with other private data. Requiring that apps ask approval before accessing my private data is not at all like waiting in line for bread in the USSR.
> The argument that it's apple's fault
Is one that nobody is making, so you don't need to debunk it. Or at the very least, I'm not making it, in fact, I very explicitly stated I wasn't making that argument in the post you replied to.
Alternatively, Apple could spend a few thousand dollars and properly secure their MULTI billion dollar platform so the problem couldn't occur in the first place.
Agreed with your outrage on a company taking files off of my system (address book or otherwise) and uploading them. And, from reading the dcurt.is entry - it sounds like 85%+ of social apps do this as common practice.
Maybe its because mobile developers mostly come from web development where it is normal for the server to store such data. For a lot of web applications (web-mail, Facebook) it is part of the service.
If you upload personal data (which, I agree, is wrong unless explicitly requested and authorized) you are having much more data to protect.
Does Apple provide application level permissions system where users can see what permission application require, and where users can choose if they will grant application permission the right to read address book or choose not to install it?
If Apple doesn't do this, than it's Apples fault that it didn't sandbox applications enough in order to protect its users.
The world is certainly 'not' always ideal, and as a phone owner when I download apps, I would like to be able to defend my privacy at the OS level
Here's one reason why we don't scan people's system for interesting private files and secretly upload it for our economic benefit:
1. It violates the user's trust, expectations and privacy.
Here's a second reason:
2. It is a criminal act to do so.
I don't buy these discussions about how it is Apple's fault. It's not. It's illegal to steal private data like this. The companies doing this should be raided and shut down by the FBI immediately. All of them. Whether or not they issued a tearful apology.