News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:01PM (#35689315)
> Your take is very dismissive and does not align with my experience.

It's not "dismissive" to tell you that I think you're wrong. I'm trying to explain something that you clearly haven't experienced yet. There's no way to do that without actually saying that you haven't experienced it.

I understand why you believe what you do. I believed the same things, but I was wrong.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by paulrpotts on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:22PM (#35689651)
I'm 55 years old and I have _never_ been mentored in person by a co-worker, despite having spent most of my career working on teams, and despite _trying_ in many different workplaces to set up mentoring relationships. For neurodivergent folks - who probably make up the bulk of programming teams, if we're honest - the camaraderie and team-building and all that is a mythical thing that normies experience, but we don't, and it's also a minefield of things that can go wrong because the norms of social interaction sometimes elude us or we simply can't play-act them (I'll never forget being told by my boss that it always seemed like I was lying because I didn't maintain eye contact well). Remote work levels the playing field, and normies hate it because they can't bully and abuse us as easily online as they can in person.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by FredPret on Monday April 24, 2023 @02:06PM (#35691042)
Normie here, and I've always thought this was the biggest benefit of remote work. No more emphasis on what you look and act like. Only the value you add counts.

This has got to be good for racial, gender, etc forms of discrimination. In a wheelchair? Black? Female? Ideally nobody would care because they wouldn't even know.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by SoftTalker on Monday April 24, 2023 @03:09PM (#35691790)
I'm a couple of years older than you and I agree with most of this. Never had a "mentor" though lip service was paid to the concept in a few places, it never really happened in the tech positions.

"Team-building" stuff -- outings, retreats, games, that all the business folks seemed to love were painfully awkward experiences that seemed to be totally contrived. I tried to fake that I was enjoying it but pretty sure I never pulled it off very well.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by sokoloff on Monday April 24, 2023 @03:52PM (#35692282)
I’m shocked that people worked in an office together and the junior person never got mentored.

It seems like if that was your goal that you’d have to go well out of your way to avoid accidentally mentoring someone. “Oh, here’s the trick I just used in the debugger.” “I’ll sketch the architecture change I’m proposing on the whiteboard.” “Why don’t you shadow me in this meeting or interview or presentation?”

I can’t imagine how I’d setup an in-person work arrangement to avoid mentoring.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by ElevenLathe on Monday April 24, 2023 @04:56PM (#35693172)
It's easy:

> “Oh, here’s the trick I just used in the debugger.”

Don't ever talk to one another during debugging sessions. Pick up your bug ticket, fix it, close the ticket. Everyone else has their own work to do so they are not interested in watching you pilot your heavily-customized IDE setup, and the boss doesn't make them.

> “I’ll sketch the architecture change I’m proposing on the whiteboard.”

Don't have whiteboard meetings about architecture. If you must, definitely don't invite juniors. In fact, nobody actually writing code to implement the change will be in the meeting at all. We are architects and managers, they are merely developers. They'll write what we tell them to write. In many organizations, even the people called "architects" are left out of these meetings, and probably even line managers. These are Director Level Decisions, after all.

> “Why don’t you shadow me in this meeting or interview or presentation?”

Easiest of the three. Just never ever have anybody "shadow" anyone for any reason. They have their own work to be doing.

I'm not saying these behaviors are good, but they are pretty much the default behavior in corporate jobs AFAICT.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by paulrpotts on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @01:42AM (#35696896)
It’s the normal, default state of affairs when you have seniors and managers who feel they are competing with each other and so hoard knowledge and techniques, and assign themselves all the interesting work while juniors are left bored doing rite work. In several workplaces when I’ve tried to organize shared spaces like a commons, lunch-and-learns, etc., management had been actively hostile. I had one asshole manager who would even shut down any water-cooler conversation. I finally wound up mentoring a co-worker who needed help with C++ entirely off-site during lunches.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @08:09PM (#35694936)
I mean...there are a lot of anti-social developers who truly want to believe.

But really, people are just going out of their way to resolve the cognitive dissonance: they know that important intangible collaboration is lost in a world of remote work, but they prefer it anyway, so they convince themselves that the human aspect doesn't matter.

Also, don't forget that HN is filled with junior engineers. It's true that a lot of what you do when you're a junior engineer can be done in isolation, and when you get to a self-sufficient junior level ("senior engineer" in modern parlance; achieved in about 3-5 years), it's easy to ignore all the times that someone with more experience made a one-off comment that saved hours of labor or headed off a thorny problem. They forget the number of times that someone wandered over to chat, "interrupted" them, and changed everything.

The sibling comment is a great illustration. I can't tell if it's parody, but it reads like it: "just don't have whiteboard meetings about architecture," indeed. Whiteboard diagramming obviously never happens at every company, ever.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by paulrpotts on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @01:44AM (#35696900)
I had a boss order me to take down a whiteboard I set up in a common area so we couldn’t discuss code during work.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by rmah on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @07:46PM (#35708181)
I can see that because I've experienced it. That said, at most places I've worked at over the decades, there was a lot of mentoring, both formal and informal. One place I worked at, however, was just depressing. No one communicated except via emails. Informal discussions about how the system never happened. No one even went out to eat together No one was hostile... it was just... cold. To me, it was just weird and I got out of there ASAP -- but I suspect many there liked it that way.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by wintogreen74 on Monday April 24, 2023 @04:23PM (#35692677)
>> Remote work levels the playing field, and normies hate it because they can't bully and abuse us as easily online as they can in person.

I'm not sure how remote somehow replaces social interaction in your world, but it sure sounds like you might have other factors at play as well, like categorizing every who's not in the group with which you identify as an abusive bully. I've never worked with you remote or in person, and the only conclusion you've let me make is you're difficult and unpleasant.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by paulrpotts on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @01:49AM (#35696939)
I’m sure that must be it. By the way, go fuck yourself!
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by aix1 on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @02:34AM (#35697219)
Wow, that was unnecessary. But sadly supports GP's conclusion rather than refute it. :(
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by paulrpotts on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @09:56AM (#35700532)
Read this again:

> the only conclusion you've let me make is you're difficult and unpleasant.

Is it, though? The _only_ conclusion? Really? And not that I’ve often had terrible managers and worked in stressful, toxic workplaces with self-serving co-workers, in toxic work cultures that did not allow collaboration or mentoring to take place, and even wound up with PTSD?

I do manage to have a successful marriage (over 20 years) and even friends. Friendships strained, since COVID, but friendships nonetheless.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by dang on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:53PM (#35719068)
Yikes - you can't post like this here, no matter how provocative another comment was or you feel it was. Please don't do that again!

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by dang on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:53PM (#35719062)
Your comment crossed into personal attack. Please don't do that on HN. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by Clubber on Monday April 24, 2023 @06:05PM (#35693896)
I've a little younger than the OP and I've never had a proper mentor either. I had one guy I argued with a lot that I learned some tricks from that I use to this day, but that's about it.

I've never worked in a company with any type of formal mentoring that everyone talks about. The "let me take you under my wing and show you the ropes, kiddo," never existing in my world, it was sink or swim. I spent countless hours reading books (I'm old) and scouring the web for solutions. If I could debug it, I could figure out the problem, I just didn't always know what it was supposed to do. I did all this because I didn't want to fail. Do junior people still do this, or is it more, "I can't figure it out in 5 minutes, do it for me."

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by TexanFeller on Monday April 24, 2023 @06:28PM (#35694103)
> For neurodivergent folks - who probably make up the bulk of programming teams, if we're honest - the camaraderie and team-building and all that is a mythical thing that normies experience, but we don't

Please don't speak for all of us. I used to think exactly like you, but turns out I was just on bad teams in bad companies. My recent teams have mostly been composed of and managed by like minded programmers and the camaraderie, lunch conversation, and ad hoc collaboration that ensue massively help both my happiness and productivity. I'm as neurodivergent as you can get and still hold a job. Multiple severe diagnosed conditions.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by paulrpotts on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @01:48AM (#35696925)
Fair enough - I’m 55 and describing the bulk on my career to date. Lately the culture of a couple companies I’ve been in have been much more welcoming to neurodivergent folks but this is post-COVID. I’m not planning to do in-person work in the near future; I already have long COVID and risk factors that make me want to make sure my family and I never get infected again.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by NegativeK on Monday April 24, 2023 @07:15PM (#35694531)
There are also plenty of us who struggle to reach out and benefit _greatly_ from a slow build up of relationships that form from in-person interactions, facilitated by coworkers.

There isn't a single remote versus meatspace answer, and it's incredibly frustrating to hear almost everyone pretend that there's a Single Right Solution and that anything chosen will be easy to implement.

> they can't bully and abuse us

Without at all denying that this happen, this is still a gross (in both senses of the word) generalization and insult.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by frumper on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:04PM (#35689374)
Your explanation is not much more than "trust me, I'm right". That is quite dismissive. Maybe you if you were in person you could give him examples or a better explanation of why he's wrong. /s
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:16PM (#35689566)
The irony here is that asserting that nobody else can be correct if they don't "validate" you is the definition of dismissiveness.

I have actually done what OP is proposing, and found it to be inadequate. I tried to explain why.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by danaris on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:43PM (#35689974)
Others are saying "This thing works for me."

You are claiming "This thing never works (and therefore your own experience is wrong)."

The person making a categorical claim has a higher burden of proof than the one making an individual one, especially when the former is attempting to invalidate the lived experience of the latter.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:44PM (#35689990)
> You are claiming "This thing never works (and therefore your own experience is wrong)."

I am literally not doing that. Go back and re-read my comment.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by pbhjpbhj on Monday April 24, 2023 @01:21PM (#35690541)
The impression you gave me matches that quote you dismiss relatively well.

Perhaps you should also re-read it, you may have carried less of the nuance you intended into the actual text. What you wrote suggested that one can only attain a moderate capability without in-person mentoring from experts. If nothing else this heavily insinuates those you're conversing with are incapable and inexpert.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @02:45PM (#35691479)
> What you wrote suggested that one can only attain a moderate capability without in-person mentoring from experts.

Like I said, it's hard to frame "you don't have this life experience yet" in any other way. I did use these words:

> this will only take you from absolute noob to moderately competent junior

...in reference to learning stuff online. I stand by that, because even if you are fully remote for your entire career, you're going to need some level of mentoring to level up. That's just a fact. Reductio ad absurdum: suggesting that you can become John Carmack or Jeff Dean by reading Stack Overflow.

But I also explicitly put an edit on the end of it where I disclaim the generalization you're making -- before you made your comment.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by ipaddr on Monday April 24, 2023 @07:59PM (#35694854)
You can become better than Jeff Dean or John Carmack without mentoring in fact mentoring is negatively associated with self learning which you will need to blaze a new trail.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by danaris on Monday April 24, 2023 @01:36PM (#35690712)
You may not feel like that's what you're doing, but lines like

> you're vastly overestimating what you can learn

> highly experienced people in this industry never post in chatrooms

> don't know what you don't know

...are all very condescending and attempt to generalize your experience to infinity. They absolutely attempt to invalidate other people's experience—they're not even just saying "what you're saying is impossible"; they're outright saying "(unlike me, who's smarter and/or more experienced) you don't realize that the learning you claim to have gotten was crap."

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @03:01PM (#35691676)
Well, you're misquoting me. Here is what I actually wrote:

> You're vastly overestimating what you can learn from randos in chatrooms and forums. Most of the best, highly experienced people in this industry never post in chatrooms or forums. You're getting a biased sample, and don't know what you don't know

These are simple facts. They're not "condescending", and more importantly, you wouldn't know if you were wrong, because you're getting a biased sample. That's the point. You don't see or hear from the people who don't post.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by danaris on Monday April 24, 2023 @03:28PM (#35692017)
But, see, here's the thing: you also wouldn't know if you're wrong, because you'd be getting just as biased a sample, only from the other side—if you're just in the wrong chatrooms and forums.

Furthermore, what you are doing is absolutely, unquestionably, telling other people "I don't know what you learned from these people, and furthermore, I don't have to know, because my experience, which is universal and unassailable in all possible ways, tells me that it must not be enough. If you think you learned enough from these people to be a good mid-to-upper-level programmer, you're wrong. No one can learn to be that good from this. Again, with the only evidence given being that I was unable to do that in this way."

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @03:58PM (#35692347)
> you also wouldn't know if you're wrong, because you'd be getting just as biased a sample, only from the other side—if you're just in the wrong chatrooms and forums.

Of everywhere I have ever worked and everyone I have ever worked with -- including some big, extremely well-known names -- only a tiny percentage of those people were active contributors online. Moreover, the most experienced, productive, highest-ranking people contributed less, for a variety of practical reasons, ranging from "PR risk" to "I don't want to get fired from my job" to "don't have the time".

This is consistent with an entire career working on the web, where the pattern is always that the vast majority of people lurk.

Could my sample be horribly misrepresentative? I suppose, but it isn't likely.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by danaris on Monday April 24, 2023 @04:10PM (#35692507)
And if you were coming into a discussion with people saying "I think this thing happens", and you said "No, I don't think this thing happens, based on my personal experience," that would be one thing.

You're not.

You're coming into a discussion with people saying, "I have experienced this thing happening to me," and you're saying "I don't think this thing happens, based on my experience", which means you are trying to use your non-universal experience to tell other people that their experience didn't happen.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @08:30PM (#35695096)
> and you're saying "I don't think this thing happens, based on my experience"

*often

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by ipaddr on Monday April 24, 2023 @08:03PM (#35694887)
That says more about you and your circle and what you know about them. Many of those people could be contributing but not sharing at work.
Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by broast on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:19PM (#35689627)
I personally have experienced it, but my team has only seen greater success since going remote, and filling our roles with good remote fits.

I might say if you haven't experienced carrying a meaningful text-only relationship over years or haven't treated it equal to your "real life" relationships, then you can not know the effectiveness that comes from it

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:28PM (#35689754)
> I might say if you haven't experienced carrying a meaningful text-only relationship over years and treated it equal to your "real life" relationships, then you can not know the effectiveness that comes from it

See, this is dismissive. You're assuming something about me. I'm not assuming anything about you -- I'm just saying, you clearly haven't been bitten by this yet. I have, and I'm trying to share that experience.

When I was younger, just like you, I thought I had discovered a new way of working. To a certain extent, that was true. You can do a lot of things remotely. But the best things in my own career, without exception, have come from in-person relationships.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by broast on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:42PM (#35689947)
Well, I am sorry for that.

But just to add - it's a misconception to see remote work as a "new way" of working for someone like me. For someone like me, who used chatrooms and forums to collaborate with people on programming and similar projects, remote work is returning back to my natural way of doing things. Going to the office for 10 years was unnatural. We have now cut out a lot of overhead of learning how to manage office life, which is only relevant if you have an office, and which was a hard part of my life (I'm ugly).

And my experience is simply the opposite of yours. My strengths and my teammates strengths have only come to shine since going remote. I only became a Team Lead and then Engineering Manager since we've gone fully remote, and I think it is largely in part thanks to the speed and effectiveness my remote teams achieve in on-boarding members, collaborating, and delivering valuable work. Every retro my team members put "Great teamwork!" on the board, and this only started since we've gone remote.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by timr on Monday April 24, 2023 @12:51PM (#35690097)
> And my experience is simply the opposite of yours.

We keep talking past each other. This is the last reply I'm going to make, but hopefully it will add something: please consider that your experience is not opposite of mine, but instead, that you haven't run into the problems yet.

Maybe, for all of your success and advancement, you haven't yet reached the limits I'm talking about. Just consider it.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by broast on Monday April 24, 2023 @01:13PM (#35690419)
Fair enough

I'll also ask that you consider the possibility that you haven't experienced overcoming this limit yet. After all, what do we need to learn about our work that can't be represented as text

Or that this limit might be qualitatively different for different people, and that some people are better at online text-only relationships than face-to-face ones. Our teams may have faced limits in real life that only got solved by going remote. (For example, I do believe that when we were in person, we wrote lower quality software, less well-tested, with less communication and collaboration, at a much slower pace, than we do now (you can imagine why - likely we used to rely on informal processes more than we thought or wanted to))

I did mention that I've seen other teams (anecdotally, on less technical areas of the product) face problems with being fully remote- but that was usually fixed with staffing... or a remote leader inheriting the team... We've had many people in our org exclusively remote for the last 20 years as well - these people became the remote leaders on our teams and led by example. It all depends on the remote fit.

Re:Remote Work Brings Hidden Penalty for Young Professionals... by TexanFeller on Monday April 24, 2023 @06:14PM (#35693989)
Been there, done that, both 12 years ago and again during the pandemic. I loved it at first and later grew to hate and resent it. The advantages are immediate and the disadvantages take a little while to manifest.