You're not adding an intermediary. The broker and the exchange do different jobs. Coinbase is an exchange and a brokerage firm. Under the current arrangement, Coinbase is providing its customers with both exchange and brokerage services, so Coinbase customers are paying for both. If Coinbase was providing exchange services to brokerage firms, and these brokerage firms were providing brokerage services to retail investors, these investors would still be paying for both services (directly or indirectly), but prices would be lower due to competition among brokerage firms.
- custody of assets
- margin trading
- customer support
If the answer is yes, then Coinbase is providing typical brokerage services which could be provided instead by firms independent from the exchange. Do you not agree?In traditional stock markets you must do:
Retail -> Broker -> Exchange
Coinbase allows:
Retail -> Coinbase Exchange
Retail -> CB Broker -> CB Exchange
Retail -> Broker -> CB Exchange
How is this not better for retail than traditional finance? How can I get DMA at the NASDAQ as an individual?
"You can't, but it's for your own good" - Brokers
Coinbase is more profitable than traditional brokers or exchanges. Consider that for a moment. We separate the order execution and customer-facing layers because it gets tempting to fiddle with prices when you do both.